Guitar Question

I think I want to learn how to play the guitar. And it seems as though the first step would be to buy one.

There are dozens of cheapish instruments littered over ebay, and buying one seems like it might be a good solution in case I don’t like playing, I won’t have spent huge amounts of money for a now useless block of wood. But if they’re not any good at all, learning will be painful and if I do like playing, it’ll need to be replaced almost immediately.

So, would they make a good first guitar? If not, any suggestions?

Thanks…

Go to a music store that sells used guitars, or even a pawn shop. You’ll probably still spend a decent chunk of change on a good guitar, but if it doesn’t work out you can always sell it. There are a lot of good brands out there, and a lot of crappy ones too. Do a little research. Ask a lot of questions.

Get an acoustic guitar. It’s not as sexy as having a Strat slung low plugged into a 10 foot stack of amps, but it’ll be more useful to you in your learning process.

MOST IMPORTANT: Remember that nothing happens overnight. Take lessons and bear in mind that it might be months before you play anything recognizable besides “Twinkle Twinkle Little Star”. If you think you might lose interest if you’re not Jimi Hindrix after two weeks, maybe music isn’t for you…

Good luck. Even total hack guitar players like me enjoy the hell out of it.

Most beginners find electric guitars easier to play, most steel-string acoustics are pretty stiff and it takes some time to develop sufficient calluses on your fingertips to play them without discomfort. Nylon string acoustics are really easy to play, but are not recommended unless you’re studying Classical Guitar, the techniques are quite different, and the necks are quite wide and the frets spaced farther apart, I have a hard time switching to a nylon-string classical guitar myself, I keep reaching for a note in the old familiar spot and it’s way farther down the neck.
I’d recommend investing in as good a guitar as you can afford, there’s nothing worse than a crappy guitar, it positively fights you, when a good guitar helps you along. Find a friend who plays, and have them help you. I wouldn’t buy any guitar sight-unseen, you really should play it first. So skip ebay.

I have to agree with Kilt-Wearin’ Man’s suggestions, namely, find a shop that sells used guitars, and start on an acoustic. See, small mis-fingerings that might not be totally evident on an acoustic will be glaring, nasty, UGLY things with an electric, which will lead to a very discouraged guitar student and that sexy, low-slung Strat sharing closet space with the Thighmaster.

Shop for a guitar in person, too. Guitars are individuals, really, regardless of the name on the headstock. You don’t have to know anything about playing yet, all you need to look for is how comfortable your hand feels on the neck (I can’t play most Strats nearly as well as Telecasters or my beloved '63 Les Paul). You’ll only find a good guitar for you by picking them up and playing them. Ask lots of questions, too. And if you have a friend that plays, bring him/her along.

Good luck! Playing guitar is a lot of fun, and well worth the effort you put into it. And if you’re ever in Ottawa and need a jamming partner… :smiley:

One more suggestion:

Go to your local library and grab a copy of Guitar for Dummies. Or if you’re feeling extravagant, buy it. When I decided to start attempting to play again after a {mumble} year layoff, it was about all my library had that really fit the bill. It includes a CD, so you can listen to what things are supposed to sound like as you try them. It also devotes a fair amount of space to picking a guitar, guitar care and maintenance, etc. You can check out the table of contents online, or read a sample chapter.

Not sure if you have this covered already, but once you buy a guitar, you will of course need to tune it periodically . . go here for a free download guitar tuning program:

http://www.audio-phonics.com/

Happy strumming!

I strongly recomend starting with an acoustic. You will build up better finger strength because the strings are thicker, and it will force you to learn to play more precisely - a chord on an electric with some of the strings accidentally muted a bit will still sound OK, it will be immediately obvious on an acoustic.

I also recommend starting with one of those hokey beginners books that starts you out playing nothing but basic chords like C, G, F, etc. It will be longer before you can play anything recognizable as music but the sooner you learn to finger open chords correctly, the sooner you will have full mastery of the neck. Don’t even mess with trying to play melody or power chords until you can play all the most common chords and change between them without hesitation - by then the rest will come easily. And if you learn on an acoustic, the first time you play an electric you will be blown away by how much easier it is.

I’ve been playing guitar for well over 20 years and have some credits to my name. I started fumbling on an old, crappy acoustic (“Kent” brand) with a high, tight action. This forced me to get incredible strength, but at the cost of finesse. (Tough to play a gentle fingering pattern when you have to stand on the strings.) I really got serious when I bought an electric guitar at a pawn shop for $50. The action was so light, I was screwing up on simple chords, and I had to relearn a lot. Now, I’m back to acoustics (I gave my electric to my nephew.)

While I agree with the above respondents about starting on an acoustic (they are also lighter, easier to travel with, don’t require an amplifier to listen to them, etc.) I would like to specifically recommend a brand or two.

Consider

[li] The quality of a guitar is important to your enjoyment. A guitar that is too hard to play (high action) or doesn’t stay in tune will never be fun to play and will gather dust faster than you can say “ab-roller”.[/li]
[li] The cost of a guitar is important to your wallet. High quality guitars come with high price tags. Cheap guitars are, well, cheap. The difficult part is finding that middle ground of what you can afford vs. what is reasonable quality.[/li]
I’ve played old Epiphones and new Epiphones, Collings, Nationals, Ovations, Applause guitars, Martins, Takamine, Taylor and a few others. All have good and bad points specific to my likes/dislikes. I have, however, been impressed with a few models…

Takamine has quality guitars for reasonable prices. For about a grand, you can get a B to B+ Takamine, if you don’t mind that tinny sound.

About a year of so ago, Martin started producing a line of less expensive guitars. These run in the $600 range. Most of them are part mahogany and have a mellow sound. These are in the B to B+ range also, if you like that mellow thing.

Martin also started making a new composite backed guitar. It’s a carbon/fiber composite back with a wood top. I think it’s called an X-1. I’ve played one, loved it and had my father buy it! Because they were just testing the water with this guitar style, the prices were very low. I think my dad paid $185 and got a case! (I almost bought one for myself!) It’s bright and has the high quality of a Martin.

I am not suggesting that you buy an X-1. I am just mentioning it as a model you might want to check out for quality and price. Of course, all above recommendations regarding comfort and feel are spot on.

What do I play? Right now I divide my playing between a $300 Applause (Made by Kaman guitars, which makes Ovation) and a custom built guitar, hand made for me by JWL guitars. (I won’t tell you the price. :wink: )

I have to agree with the prior advice…

Buy a good quality instrument and you’ll never regret it. Resale value for finely made gear is always decent if you decide to sell, since they tend to hold their value at least.

Shoddy made stuff is just an annoyance, cheap guitars should be illegal and would probably result in you giving up… just an observation…