Hamster vs. Gerbil vs. Rabbit vs. Chinchilla, etc...

I’m thinking I want to get a pet but unfortunately I can’t have a dog where I live and my roommates won’t tolerate a cat. I figured I could get by with a small animal that generally lives in a cage.

However, while I have some experience with all the animals (and others such a Guinea Pigs) I don’t really know all that much about any of them. I am interested in people’s experience with these animals. What are they like as pets? Upsides? Downsides? Life expectancies? Should they have companionship (i.e. more than one of the animals)? That may seem like a nice thing to do but a friend of mine had two hampsters and one cannibalized the other (and they had lived together for awhile at that point…one morning there was a carcass in the cage).

Any ideas? Any other animals I haven’t thought of?

I have had all kinds. Hamsters are nocturnal and short-lived. The longest we had one live to was 3 years. They, and mice, though, take up the least amount of space and don’t need much care. But they’re very fragile. Some can be “litter pan trained” to go to the bathroom in one corner of the cage, making cleaning easier. They are solitary. Your friend found out the hard way. (They don’t do it instantly, but eventually, one will kill the other)

Guinea Pigs/cavies need a LOT of care and lots of human attention, almost as much as dogs and cats, IMO. But I always had a lot of them, and they squeak and are so cute. Fragile-ish. Lots of cage cleaning. They prefer company.

I don’t recommend rats. Yeah, I know they’re nice, but they need to eat a lot and they urinate a whole lot and I was forever cage cleaning. They are fine solitary.

Chinchillas are great for people with enough room for a big cage, however, I don’t recommend them for what you need. They chew everything, need a lot of space to run (so a big cage, or else you have to watch them when they’re out exercising). http://www.patmedia.net/ljstier/

(The links don’t all work in that URL because my ISP was sold to another, but you can see the cage we made)

The chinchillas are very long-lived, up to 15 years, and I have to drive 2 hours to take them to a vet who is good with them. (I have had bad experiences with most veterinarians and small animals. Many say they do exotics, but don’t know the first thing about it.)

I wouldn’t recommend sugar gliders or degus or things like that.

Bunnies are big and fun, but they take a lot of work and shouldn’t be caged a lot either.

From your situation, it sounds like you’d be best off with a hamster in a habitrail (the fun plastic houses), and just be ok with the fact that they don’t live long.

I’m gonna have to disagree with Ellis1138 about the rats. They are amazingly good pets. Cleaner and less smelly than mice and very friendly and social. They loooove their people. It’s important to get at least two (same sex, they’re very fertile), because unless you spend a lot of time with them, they get really lonely. :slight_smile:

Anyone have any experience to share about hedgehogs? They seem to be a good little pet.

Also have to chime in with the rat-support. Rats are fantastically, wonderfully, amazing little beasties–far and away the best of the pocket-pets. They are bright, clean, charming, friendly, remarkably tolerant, and way too smart for their own good :).
They need less cage cleaning than cavies, don’t smell as bad as hamsters (MUCH less evil, too. Hamsters are of the devil, and not in a good way), and are far more cuddly and friendly than chinchillas. Their only downside is their short life expectancy–two to three years, typically :frowning: --however, this can be mitigated by buying ratties from a hobby breeder who breeds for health and longevity, keeping them on a paper-based bedding, and feeding a varied diet of healthy foods. I bred rats for about five years as pets, and was attaining life-spans of upwards of four and a half years in my litters. Also I have to vehemently disagree that they’re okay on their own–one of the reasons they make such good pets is that they are extremely social. A solitary rat will get sick much more easily, tend to be shy, neurotic, and generally extremely unhappy. It also seems to drastically shorten their life-span.
Hamsters are very short tempered–unlike the majority of animals we keep as pets, they are solitary and thus do not need or desire companionship the way most other animals with which we share living space do. Therefore, you’re likely to end up with a critter that would rather you just leave it the hell alone, thank you very much. Plus, they’re desert animals and conserve water–their urine is extremely concentrated and thus very, very strong smelling. Life expectancy, 1.5 years for Russian Dwarves, 2-3 for any of the Syrian varieties.
I don’t know much about gerbils, as they are illegal to keep as pets here, but I have interacted with them in a research environment. They seem a lot like hamsters, but more jumpy. They do backflips, though, that’s pretty cute.
Rabbits are a lot of fun, but just as much work as a cat, if not more so. If kept as a house-bunny, and not stuck in a hutch all day, they make fantastically fun and intelligent pets. They litter-train very easily, much like cats, and will learn to play games like hide and go seek, and peek-a-boo. They’re much brighter than most people give them credit for, I think. Watch for chewing on electrical cords and digging carpets, but there are fairly easy ways to solve or circumvent these problems. Bigger breeds are typically much friendlier and more laid back than mini or dwarf breeds. Netherland Dwarves are rather testy. Average life expectancy, 7-12 years.
Guinea pigs (cavies) are very vocal, talkative little beasties. They pee a lot, and eat a lot. Very friendly with a lot of handling as babies, otherwise can be skittish. Mine learned to recognize the sound of the refrigerator door opening and would start making “eep!” noises immediately :wink: Average life expectancy, 6-8, up to 10+ years.
Chins are the softest animals on the face of the planet–literally. They have denser fur than any other animal that exists. Too bad they don’t like to be held, heh. They’re very high energy, very intelligent, and very, very nocturnal. Reccomend not keeping the cage in your room if you’re a light sleeper. They’ll sit on your open palm, or climb on you, but prefer not to be held or confined by hands. They’re not unfriendly, but tend to like to interact with you on their terms. Feed a very strict diet of chin pellets and timothy hay and a little grain with the occasional raisin as a treat. They’re also way more expensive than the others, if that’s a factor, and need a much larger, much more elaborate cage. Life expectancy, 12-15 years and sometimes up to 22(!).

Oi, that’s long. If you have any other questions, feel free to ask.

Peace,
~Mixie (small animal specialist and rat fan)

I opened this thread hoping someone was taking bets on who would win if there were a fight between these animals. Grr at you.

(I don’t condone the actual fighting of animals. That’d be cruel!)

Bunnies. It’s gotta be the bunnies.

But beware - the little bastards chew anything they can get their mits on. They’re cute, snuggly, fluffy and fabulous, but they chew, chew, chew.

And if you get a male, you’ll have to get him neutered, cus otherwise they spray and its really stinky.

However, my vote still goes to bunnies.

Thanks for all the great advice so far. I remember handling Chinchillas in my high school bio class (no experiments…they were just decoration so to speak). They were indeed incredibly soft…so soft you almost couldn’t feel their fur. Still, I could almost count on getting bit at least once everytime I held one. They wouldn’t break the skin but more like a painful pinch. I was kinda hoping those were just feisty Chinchillas…guess not.

As for rabbit I really like them but I recall an old girlfriend of mine who had a rabbit. After dating a few times I saw her in short sleeves and thought I was dating a psychotic. Her arms had scratches all over them like those people who intentionally cut themselves. Fortunately (for dating her further at least) the scratches were all from her rabbit. Still, there was no telling when the little bugger would have at you. I’d have the rabbit resting on my chest while watching tv and at some random time it’d go nuts and claw with its back paws a few times. The rabbit could have easily hopped off me…I wasn’t holding on. The effect was usually more startling than painful but it did hurt a little and occasionally left a good scratch. You’d think I’d learn but I love all animals and couldn’t help myself.

I admit Sugar Gliders didn’t cross my mind. What’s wrong with them? Hedgehogs? Can you even buy those? I probably wouldn’t get one since I would like something nice to pet and while a hedgehog can be handled and pet they aren’t what you’d call soft.

I’ve had chilchillas and I think they make great pets. I’ve never had one even nibble on me. Also, they’re a lot of fun to let loose and watch cruise around the room.

When I was in college, degus were a very popular pet. I never had any myself, but my roommate did and I never really say anything wrong with keeping them.

My wife has a rabbit now and I would not recommend them. She has to clean out it’s cage every other day.

Gerbils are the most fun out of all of those… I think… Hamsters are cool, but most of the time they just sit around doing nothing. Gerbils react more to their environment. they dig tunnels and respond more to you when you play with them. They are usually not afraid of your hands… they even will run up in to your hand if you put it down inside the cage.

I think they are easier to upkeep also, compared to the bigger animals you’re talking about.

Hamsters do nothing but sit around and look cute…:rolleyes:

When I asked about capybaras in GQ the other day, didn’t lissener say that they are sold as pets? What kind of a pet do they make?

Damn, from the title I thought this was a biology student’s version of Battlebots…

All I know about them is that their care requirements (food, cage) seem to be pretty strict, and also that you shouldn’t expect them to interact with you in any meaningful way. They will basically consider you a funny looking moving tree. They are damn cute, though.

Another vote hear for NEUTERED rabbits. They are a fair amount of work, though.

It sounds like your former girlfriend’s rabbit may not have been neutered and that is why it was occasionally aggressive. Or maybe it was just a psycho bunny. Rabbits can also get aggressive if they feel threatened, for instance if they are mistreated. I’m not saying this was the case with the former GF, though.

Personally, I’m not a small rodent person. I have had mice, gerbils and hamsters, and something about their tiny size and proclivity for escaping their cages, making you look for them while trying not to accidentally crush them before you can see them, freaks me out. If I ever got another rodent, I’d buy a rat. They’re bigger than my hand (which seems to be the cut off for freak-me-outness. I have no problems with squirrels either, though you can’t own them) and they’re supposed to be fairly bright.
OTOH, I also dislike rabbits as pets, since none of the dozen or so we had would tolterate being held without raking the crap out of your arms with its back claws. And this after reading books about the proper way to hold them and position their back legs so they wouldn’t feel scared! One of them bit me when I was very young, so I always worried about that too. (rabbit bites hurt)

I’d recommend ferrets. They are only “stinky” if you neglect to bath them, they’re somewhat bright, very inquisitive, and if you have two they’ll entertain each other the way kittens are supposed to. They’re not very cuddily, or at least mine haven’t been, but they love to play with you as long as you don’t expect them to sit on your lap and be petted.

They require a B-I-G cage if you’re going to restrain them a lot(when you’re at work or sleep for example) though. I know some people let them roam around unsupervised, but they’re curious enough to get into a lot of dangerous things when alone. One of mine escaped her cage and got between the floor boards! I had to remove the light fixture (a sort boxy kind, thankfully) on the floor below to retrieve her since she couldn’t find her way back to the crack she’d slipped through.) You better believe I bought a new cage right after that!

I had a Little Siberian hamster. Our cat ate it.
I got another one, it died of old age at 2 years.

Personally, I can’t really see the point of non cat/dog pets.

A review of some of these animals:

Be aware that hamsters are very susceptible to viruses humans carry–they can’t handle cold and influenza bugs. None of the hamsters I had as a child lived more than a month.

The gerbils did pretty well, though they are a bit hyper and may be quick to bite if annoyed–and when they bite they often don’t let go. Don’t ever tease a gerbil. When I was a kid my mom wouldn’t buy us a habitrail type cage so we made one out of cardboard boxes and paper towel tubes. While we couldn’t let the gerbils live in it permanently as they’d shred it, it was fun to let them play in it once in a while and to rearrange the boxes each time. The gerbils loved scampering around in our homemade habritrail.

Guinea pigs are quick to learn about food sources–when I was a kid mine learned to squeal whenever the refrigerator door opened and later to sqeal when someone opened the back door because they wanted to go outside and eat grass. (They can graze on the lawn but need to be watched so hawks or stray dogs don’t snatch them.) They live about 3-4 years, although we had one who lived to be 6.

I only kept a rabbit for a short time, but I’ll never forget the night it started slamming its feet on the floor at 4:00 AM, causing my roomate to run to the door because he thought some weirdos camped out in my neighbor’s yard were breaking into the house. That might be something to consider before you keep a rabbit in the house.

Rats are friendly but you will need to change the cage litter frequently as their pee is strong smelling. As for chinchillas, my sister kept a couple but they both came to bad ends–one died of shock when her husband picked it up and another dove off the bathroom counter and broke it’s neck. They also kept a ferret, which lived to be about 6 years old and died of natural causes.

Me, I now prefer cockatiels.

My next pet will be an African Grey parrot… they are the world’s best talking parrot… I’m going to name mine Snoop Dogg and teach him abusive gangster rap language and let him listen to 50 cent all day!