Has Scarface been embraced by youth culture for the wrong reasons?

When I watched Scarface, the message of the movie was clearly the rise and fall of a charismatic leader through poor life choices - like many of Scorsese’s movies, drugs were shown to have negative consequences in the long run, and ultimately the characters are destroyed by their egos and their addictions. Tony Montana went out not as a “hero” in “a blaze of glory” but as a desperate and disturbed man.

However, Scarface has been appropriated by the youth culture as “cool.” It was not always this way - Scarface only recently became a cult icon in the way it is now. Scarface T-shirts, posters, patches, shot glasses, and every other conceivable bit of merchandising is littered all over the rooms of high school and college students.

Usually the guys that have Scarface stuff tend to be alpha-male types who like to get high and drink a lot, and the girls with Scarface stuff tend to be the girls who are attracted to these type of guys.

It seems like they like Scarface not because they find it to be an interesting movie, or Tony Montana to be a compelling and tragic figure - but simply because cocaine and swaggering bravado = cool in their minds.

I don’t know if it’s connected or not, but cocaine use definitely seems to be trendy right now among college students. And aggressive macho posturing, of course, will always be in style, but for some reason these forces in the youth culture seem to have appropriated Scarface as their patron saint.

I think Scarface was embraced by youth culture because it’s been a big part of hip hop culture for quite a long time. We’ve got it on DVD, probably because of my 13-year-old brother, and I’ve been meaning to check it out so I can see what the big deal is.

But was it embraced by hip-hop culture because of its drug and macho appeal?

I don’t really know enough about hip hop culture to answer that. I think it’s got a lot to do with the ‘self-made man’ aspect of the story as well.

It’s man who’s made himself in opposition to conventional “rules.” It’s the outsider “winning” through sheer force of will. And force. The ending is just heroic martyrdom. It’s like war movies: no matter how bad you try make war look, the more battle scenes there are, the more the end result is macho heroism.

Recently?

It’s been popular with youth culture practically from the time of its making, just as the original Scarface was always an iconic movie with the counter-culture in the 60s. Sure, they’re both morality tales, but people always take the message they want to take from a movie. In this case it’s yes, you’ll come to a violent end but it’ll be a fun ride getting there.

The young are never particularly concerned by death. They know for a fact that they are immortal.