More info on TV cards for the PC. All I originally wanted was to record TV shows just like my old VCR, and occasionally put one on a DVD so’s I could watch it on a regular DVD player. Doesn’t seem like much to ask. I’ve tried three different TV cards so far and the common thread is that they all required a LOT of twiddling and it never ends.
They are all USB connected with a choice of RF antenna input, RCA composite, or Svideo. I’m running Win XP.
One was an oldie called a Dazzle. Sorry I don’t have the model number since it’s currently buried somewhere in the mess. When I find it, it’s hitting the trash. 'Nuff said.
The next one was a Happauge WinTV PVR 2. It’s about the size of a paperback book. It worked well enough, although the user interface seemed specifically designed to piss me off. Every once in awhile it would randomly lose it’s little mind, requiring a re install. The stinkin thing only encodes MPEG2 using a proprietary Happauge codec, which means that most editing software and other people’s PCs can’t play the shows I record. Thus requiring me to become something of an MPEG hobbyist. If I ever meet the IEEE scrotes that designed that MPEG standard… well, never mind. I did like the remote control though, especially the ‘skip ahead 10 seconds’ button. It sucks up around 650 MB per hour of recording on extended play resolution setting.
Then I decided that I should get with the modern age and go to ATSC digital TV. So I got a KWorld PlusTV. The thing is amazingly tiny, about the size of a pack of gum with a USB plug on one end and a coax plug on the other. No remote with
this one, although the wireless mouse & keyboard make that no big deal. Once again the hardware works as advertised. But the software. It’s called Arcsoft Totalmedia, but I call it total shit. It’s like a cartoon, as though your brat sister just learned to code HTML and intentionally put together the world’s most annoying web site. And as usual, it occasionally loses it’s mind and needs to be re installed. To give you an idea what crapware it is, after using it for a couple months it stopped recording. After reading the manual cover to cover and pushing every button I accidentally found that you need to clear the recording history once in awhile. Nobody knows why. Also it gradually loses the ability to display the program listings that are broadcast with the digital signal. You need to un install and then re install to fix it, and they don’t make that easy since it installs a stealth process that seems to do nothing but protect it’s program files from deletion. And of course like the Happauge it uses some strange-ass codec so my recorded shows don’t play on other PCs or with typical editing programs. It sucks up around 1.5 GB per hour of recording on extended play resolution setting. Unfortunately if the program is being broadcast in hi def then it automatically switches to highest resolution, and then it sucks up around 5 GB per hour and you can’t make it stop doing that. So plan on getting a terabyte hard drive too. But it needs to be an internal HD because the hi res is too much bandwidth for the stinkin USB connection on playback. So what you get with a USB hard drive is crystal clear stop motion video.
On the plus side, it’s a standard BDA 2883 device, so other software packages could run the KWorld hardware. I’ve tried a few but none of them can seem to access the digital channels so I’m still looking.
I’ve cracked the MPEG editing problem but it takes a lot of twiddling and hella processing power, and even then it’s way slow. Like, fire it up and leave it overnight kinda slow. I never really wanted to know about frame servers but there ya go.
Bottom line, if you don’t want to make it into a semi aggravating hobby, stay away from the TV card for the PC approach. If you do decide to take the plunge, let me know if you find something that actually freakin works, willya?