Help me decide on the Mini Cooper

liirogue:

Your credit score is reallly irrelevant, unless it’s a disaster. Most automakers will be more than willing to sell you something that is WAY more expensive than you can really afford. They’ll happily finance it, too.

More important: How much money can you afford for a car payment? What’s your disposable income?

Bear in mind that buying new is a FAR more expensive way to own a car than buying a vehicle that’s four or five years old. The best ‘bang for the buck’ can probably be had by buying a used car that still has a year or two of its original warranty left on it. For two reasons: One is that cars under warranty get maintained better than cars that aren’t - people follow factory oil change schedules, and issues get dealt with before they turn into serious problems. And two, you still have some warranty left if you discover some nasty surprises.

If you want to buy new, that’s fine - I just bought new myself. But be aware that you’re paying a pretty hefty price for the privilege.

Anyway… Here are some more hints when shopping for a new car:

  1. Negotiate everything individually. Don’t let the dealership talk you into a package price including your trade-in, financing, rebates, etc. They’ll offer you a great deal on the car, then stiff you on the trade-in. Or they’ll offer you a great trade-in, then stiff you on the car price. So negotiate the price of the vehicle first. If they ask you if you have a trade-in, say “I don’t know yet. I may sell the vehicle privately, or keep it for my husband. I’ll worry about that later.” If they ask you if you are financing, say “I haven’t decided yet. I just want to negotiate the price of the car first, then I’ll decide.”

  2. NEVER negotiate based on monthly payments. If the salesman starts by saying, “How much can you afford per month?”, say “Whatever I need to pay. I’ll worry about that after I choose the car I want.” A standard trick is to get you to name what you think is a low number - “I’d buy that car if I ccould get it for $350/mo”. Then they’ll look concerned, and say, “Well, that’s a little lower than what I thought we could do, but let me talk to the manager.” Then he’ll go away, come back 15 minutes later with ‘great news’. They need to make quota, and they’ll willing to do a special deal, yada yada yada. They’ll have documents drawn up for a monthly payment of $349. Then you read the fine print later, and find out that you paid full retail for the car, and your payments were lowered by financing it out over 84 months or something. Then you’ll get killed twicce - once with a high purchase price, and again with huge interest charges.

  3. When you agree on a price, make sure the salesman puts down, IN WRITING, “No additional fees”. After you agree on a price, the dealership will write up a bill of sale and add on all kinds of extra fees, like dealer prep, documentation, etc. They’ll tell you that this is standard, and that everyone pays it. This is a crock - these things are added to pad the dealer’s profit. I just saved myself $1,000 dollars this way. I had to fight with the manager, who claimed I had to pay it. I just kept pointing to my original contract and saying, “What part of, ‘no additional fees’ do you not understand?”. When he insisted, I threatened to walk out, since my sales contract was void. I got the fees deleted.

  4. NEVER buy the factory ‘protection plans’. Undercoating, scotch-guarding, special clear coat on the paint, etc. These are a huge rip-off. Often, the dealer will make more profit from the protection package than they make on the vehicle. Buy a couple of $20 cans of Scotch-guard, spray the interior, and you’re done. That’s about all they’ll do anyway. Ford tried to sell me undercoating, cloth protection, and ‘special clear coat to protect the paint’ (i.e. wax) for $995. After I refused, they STILL wrote it into the sales contract. I told him I wouldn’t sign until they removed it. They removed it.

  5. Most extended warranties are also a waste of money. They offer very little extra coverage (how little is only apparent if you read the fine print), they cost a bundle, and they don’t kick in until after the factory warranty is over, even though you have to pay for them NOW. Ford wanted to charge me $1200 to extend my warranty from three years to five. If I put that $1200 in a mutual fund earning 10% (the historical average), then by the time my warranty runs out I’d have $1600 in the bank to pay for whatever happened. The chances are, I’ll come out WAY ahead - probably with $1800 in the bank at the end of the 5-year extended warranty.

  6. Go into negotiations prepared. Know the Kelly Blue-book value of your old car, and know the MSRP and Invoice cost of the one you are dealing on. In today’s economy, there is no reason to pay anything over invoice for your car. Don’t let the dealer tell you that invoice is their ‘cost’ and invoice +500 means they are only making $500. Dealers get kickbacks and incentives from the factory, and even at invoice they make reasonable profit. You can get all this info at Edmunds.com

  7. Don’t get married to the vehicle you’re looking at. Always be prepared to get up and walk out the door if the deal isn’t right. There are lots of great cars out there. It’s a buyer’s market.

  8. Sell your other vehicle privately. If you negotiate prices separately like I recommended, I think you’ll be shocked to find out just how little the dealership is willing to give you for your car. They like to negotiate the trade-in with the price of the new vehicle so they can make it look like they’re giving you good value for your car. If you succeed in negotiating a near-cost price for the new vehicle, they’ll probably offer you thousands less for the old one than you could get on the private market (unless it’s a beater, in which case it won’t matter).

  9. If you’re offered a deal, get it in writing, and then tell them you’ll think about it overnight. Don’t let them pressure you into signing on the spot. Then come here and tell us the offer, and we can help you out.

  10. I hate to say this, but… take your husband along. In my wife’s experience, many car salesmen treat women like idiots, and make it twice as painful for you to get a great deal. If you do go by yourself, impress him with your knowledge right off the bat to save you both some time.

Hope this helps!

Wow, thanks for all the advice! This will be the first car I buy from a dealer, so I don’t really know what to expect, other than to be prepared to walk out.

I am not interested in “American” cars (ie Ford, Chevy, etc.) My experience with them has been less than lackluster, to say the least.

My husband is currently pitching a fit. He doesn’t want me to get a new car, since the one I have is paid off and runs fine. And to tell the truth, I won’t be buying unless I find something that I just absolutely fall in love (lust?) with. And then I will wait at least a month before considering it.

I intend to have this car for at least 7 to 8 years (when we plan on starting a family, and our needs will change).

What do you all think of the Honda Insight? That gas mileage is awfully tempting, and the sticker price isn’t bad at all if it is a year or two old.

Again, thank you Sam!!

I actually looked at the hybrids, because I was interested in the Escape hybrid (which isn’t available yet).

I don’t think the Honda Insight is nearly as nice as the Toyota Prius, for a couple of reasons. One, it’s not very practical. Only two seats, and not much cargo space, either. You said you liked to shift a manual - the Insight has a continuously-variable automatic. Those take some getting used to - I test drove a Nissan Murano with a CVT, and it felt a bit strange. You’re always waiting for a downshift which never comes. Apparently, you get used to it fairly quickly, and it is a technological advantage.

There’s also a Honda Civic hybrid coming out in a few months.

Hybrids have a couple of disadvantages to be aware of: For one, the batteries have a finite lifespan, and they are expensive to replace. Five or ten years down the road, you’ll be looking at a $3,000-$5,000 battery replacement cost. Add that to the $3,000-$4,000 premium a hybrid costs over a similarly-equipped conventional car, and you’re paying a lot of money for that extra gas mileage. If you drive 10,000 miles a year, then the difference after five years between a car that gets 30 mpg and 60 mpg is about 850 gallons of gas. At $2 per gallon, you’re saving $1700, and paying $6,000 to $10,000 for the privilege. That’s obviously a bad deal, which is why automakers are trying to get tax breaks for hybrids.

Okay, so hybrids are out. They sound like a neat idea, but I did not realize that the batteries had such a short life span (compared to the rest of the car) or that they were so expensive. No website I had looked at even hinted at that.

So what about the Echo or Matrix? (Btw, I’m still looking at the Mini, but we’ll see after I drive it tomorrow)

I’m still pining for the Celica, but I am rethinking it… it isn’t practical for what I need :frowning:

Hybrids are really close to being competitive, though. The new ones may have increased the battery life to 10 years, and the costs are coming down and the power is going up.

Ford has a new Escape hybrid which has the same power as the non-hybrid V6 version, and it gets 45 mpg. It’s $3000 more than the non-hybrid version. If you get the $3,000 CA hybrid credit (don’t know if that’s law yet), then you’re just trading off better gas mileage for the cost of batteries in a decade. I’d buy that.

If you’re thinking about an Echo, then forget almost all of my suggestions - I thought you were looking for a sporty car, given that you had been looking at the Celica. An Echo’s only real claim to fame is that it gets good gas mileage and it’s cheap (around $12K, I think). It’s just your basic econobox - under powered and cheap. But it does get great gas mileage, so if that’s your primary thing, it would be worth considering.

Bear in mind with the Mini that I believe it needs to burn premium gas. So even though it gets 37 mpg, you should factor in the extra 10-20% cost of gas.

The Volkswagen New Beetle with the diesel engine gets almost as good mileage as the Echo. You should also check out the VW Golf, which is quite sporty and gets great mileage.

The print verison of the current issue of “Autoweek” had some excellent info on the Mini.

First, this is a “boutique” car. IIRC BMW plans to bring only 5500 or so to the US per year to try to manage demand, avoid rebates and financing deals and try to leave some profit for the dealers. Anything’s possible, but I can imagine many of these will sell for list price or more. Just for comparison, Ferrari manufactures about 4000 automobiles per year.

Not always true, but oftentimes it can be difficult to get parts for non-US make “boutique” cars, especially in the first few years and if you are unlucky and a part that the planners had not anticipated failing, does.

Just MHO, but I imagine most of these will not be purchased as primary transportation. By some measures, these cars are self-indulgent “toys” for the wealthy, just the latest new thing on the market. IIRC, a Mini Cooper measures 30 inches shorter than a 2003 base Honda Civic, which, IMHO, compromises safety. Because most of these cars may not be purchased as primary transportation, an expectation for a Mini dealer to get the car back to you running again “yesterday” may not be realistic.

Although BMW purchased the rights to the Mini name, the Mini is not manufactured by BMW nor are there many, if any, BMW parts inside. IIRC the vehicle is manufactured in England by Rover. Anyone concerned about the reliablity reputation of a US “domestic” nameplate should research long and hard before purchasing a Rover automobile.

Summing up, I would be concerned about the vehicle’s reliablilty before any actual data becomes available. Safety seems compromised and parts availability could be a problem. You also should inquire about insurance costs.

If the Mini purchase is as a third car that will be driven a few thousand miles per year during good weather, this car could be perfect.

As primary transportation it seems like maybe not the greatest idea. YMMV.

You bring up very interesting, valid points Lorenzo. I had no idea that the mini wasn’t BMW under the hood, and frankly I’m disappointed. I think that roundly trounces it from my list.

Sam, yes I would like something sporty, but sometimes my practical side gets through. The Echo is attractive because of cost and gas mileage. I have heard good things about the Golf, but I have not heard good things about VW lately. You seem to be pretty knowledgeable about cars, perhaps you would indulge me with more of your opinion? (What are we up to, about $2.00 worth so far? :wink: :smiley: )

Specific things that bother me about what I’ve heard about VW is their quality going to pot. Are they as difficult to work on as some (most?) claim?

Sorry, I really don’t know much about Volkswagens. I’ve never owned one, or even known anyone who owned one.

I would keep the '91 Celica before I’d buy a Toyota Echo. You’d be stepping down in quality, style, and comfort, and paying big money to do it. Even if your maintenance costs are higher, your overall cost of ownership would be far less.

The mini cooper is a very cool car, and I must say that I’ve looked at it lustily as one has driven by…but that’s always short lived. Why? I don’t fully understand it myself, but I have to admit my ongoing love affair with, yes, the Volkswagon Jetta. Out of all the cars out there, I like the Jetta. It just seems to fit me to a T. Sporty yet dependable, sleek yet practical. Go for the Jetta!! :slight_smile:

Not knowing anything about climate in Oklahoma, this might be a stupid suggestion, but have you considered the Miata?

Well, I drove the Matrix, Prius, Celica, a Miata, and the Nissan 350 Z for shits and giggles. The only one I didn’t car for was the Miata, and the Nissan was waaaay out of my price range.

I was pretty impressed with the Matrix. It drove so much better than I expected. And I liked the room inside, so I think it is something I will consider once I have a family.

At the Nissan dealership they also had Maximas that were program cars with no more than 20k on them, for about $17,000. That’s within my price range, and they were well-taken care of, but I didn’t get a chance to drive one. What do you all think of the Maxima?

Tomorrow I may go give one of those a spin… Most people I’ve talked with love their Maximas, but I gotta get the SD on 'em :wink:

If you buy a Mini, you can have sex with two women at once - or so the advertisements have led me to believe.

Maxima is a great car, but it doesn’t sound at all like the kind of car you were talking about. Is that with the 265HP engine? That’s a bigger, heavier, less frugal car than things like the Mini or the Matrix.

But yeah, the Maxima is nice. One thing to check - are they sold as ‘used’ cars? If so, can you get factory financing? Check the finance rates - you may wind up paying 2 or 3 points more for the older car, and that’s something to factor in to the decision.

I recently moved to Germany and did the rounds looking for a second car as it looks like my beloved sportscar is stuck at home for a while at least for tax reasons… I toured the BMW, Audi and Mercedes dealerships looking for a family car and ended up with an Audi A6 - but it was close… I could not help going back to that gorgeous little green mini in the BMW shop. The styling inside and out is a perfect blend of modern and retro, it is an absolute blast to drive (in a different way as much fun as my Boxster S), and the doors close with that reassuring clunk of well-engineered German manufacturing. Only the desire for luggage space for long European road-trips and skis on the roof gave the Audi the nod…
Your Toyota has done its job but indulge yourself with the mini!

I drove the Mini today for shits and giggles, and I love that little car. But the dealer was blowing smoke out it’s ass (regarding price, their cost, warranties, the engine, etc.) that that alone turned me off the car.

Oh but I want one… Perhaps in a year or two when they are more readily available and I have some bargaining power.:frowning:

I’ve had my new MINI Cooper S for about 4 weeks now. And though I’m still “in love”, there are a couple things I would note:

MPG is about 25, not 35 as mentioned above. (May be because I have the “S”.) Also, it requires premium gas. More $.

It’s small but handles much “larger”. Everyone who has driven mine agrees.

They also agree it’s a lot of fun to drive.

However, I have noticed that being seen (or rather not seen) by other drivers is something of an issue one has to be a little more aware of.

The parts may not be BMW (? not sure) but the engineering is - the car has many BMW-specific features (e.g. turn and hold the key in the door adn all the windows close) as well as the aforementioned “thunk” when the doors are closed.

Really nice and quiet on the road (low road/engine noise).

Fits in my garage even with all the other crap in there.

I do have a second car (much older, much larger) for those times I need the cargo capacity.

More later if I think of anything…

I read an online review of the BMW Mini when they came out, where it was compared to the original Cooper Mini. The original one was said to handle like a go-cart – very quick. The article said the new, larger Mini lost the handling that made the original so endearing.

Premium gas. As I said, I’m restoring an MGB. I remember my last one would “ping” (predetonation) on warm days (which were common in the desert, and here in Los Hideous) when I used regular gas. I’m having an unleaded head put on the car to replace the original, cracked, one; but I’ll bet I still have to use premium gas. I’ve noticed that as the days here have gotten into the mid- and upper-70s my Yamaha pings a little on regular gas. Two bucks a gallon isn’t so bad when you’re getting 50+ mpg, but at 25 mpg it will be a pain.

Is the Smart car available in the U.S.? The new roadster they make is fabulous and would fit in your pricerange. I saw one on the street yesterday and my first thought was “Want. To. Own.”

Gaspode, I don’t believe it is, but I will check into it. I seem to recall someone else mentioning the Smart car elsewhere on the boards…

Right now I’m trying to convince hubby to let me get a new car… He’s pitching a fit at the thought of it :frowning:

I checked Smart’s website, and they said that it was not currently available in the US. I emailed them and asked them if they were planning on bringing it over here, and how much it would cost.

That is an awfully cute car. I tend to like European style cars