Help me remember the title of a murder mystery.

A long time ago I read a murder mystery and I was not able to find it by searching the internet. I read the story as a tween and I don’t have the greatest memory so any (or all) of this may be wrong:

A rich old codger (who may collect rare stamps) is killed–assassinated, really–by being shot through a window. His dying words sound like “I suspect mice…”. The trajectory of the bullet through the window makes it look like it came from a near by house. Both of these facts are red herrings; the codger is attempting to say “I suspect my solicitor” who is indeed the murderer. He rigged up the fire escape in a way that he could fire the gun to look like it came from the neighbor.

Does this sound familiar to any of you? Thanks!

Don’t know. Sounds a lot like an Agatha Christie. Did it seem like it was impossible for the solicitor to have shot him?

It’s from an Alfred Hitchcock anthology: AH’s Solve Them Yourself Mysteries. Not sure of the title of the individual story, though.

Most likely “The Mystery of the Three Blind Mice.”

Here is a review and breakdown of the stories

Thanks for solving another mystery for me – *The Three Blind Mice *is also the story that uses the line “What is so rare as a day in June?” as a clue. I’ve been wondering about that story forever (well at least since around 1972). I do remember the “my solicitor” clue as well. It’s funny how those stories stick with you.

<Lucy Van Pelt>THAT’S IT!!!</Lucy Van Pelt>

You guys are amazing. Solved in less than an hour. I’m already looking into getting it from the library. Thanks Ulf and Mudshark!

Isn’t it Charlie Brown who shouts “THAT’S IT!!”?

Check out the last few seconds of this: Charlie Brown Christmas - Jingle Bells - YouTube

How funny! Same show, different scene:

Funny I only remembered one and not the other.

Hah! And likewise I forgot about that one. I never noticed both of them.

A late reply. I was watching ‘You’ and the subject of murder mysteries came up and triggered a memory of the story I had read in a book borrowed from our mobile library when I was about 9, 57 years ago. I remembered ‘it was mice…’ and that it was my solicitor and that it was a Hitchcock story. An Internet search led me here.

I remember reading this story many years ago - part of the twist was that Americans would not recognize the word solicitor as a synonym for lawyer.

The mother of one of my best friends when I was a teen was a lawyer. She told a group of us once that, while on holidays in the States, asked what she did for a living she replied, “I’m a solicitor,” and everyone assumed that she was a prostitute.