Hey Cecil! Can UPS Read My Mail?

We all know it is illegal to tamper with the US Mail, but recently a question arose: Is it legal to tamper with the competition to the US Mail? What laws cover that? When you send a letter by FedEx or Airborne Express, etc., what laws protect your privacy and such?

Recently, USP wanted me to open a package in front of them so they could see the contents. They claimed if they couldn’t see the contents, they wouldn’t ship it! I know you might claim they’re invoking the long arm of Patriot Act for everyone’s safety, but what about my rights? The USPS wouldn’t require this! And so, this started me thinking about if UPS could start reading my mail…since the laws we all know and love pertain to the USPS.

What gives? What’s the scoop? Who does UPS et al. have to answer to if one found out they had indeed read the mail they carry?

Call me paranoid, but they’re all out to get me! :wink:

  • Jinx

They are a private company that you are hiring to transport packages. Their rights to open those packages are determined solely by the contract you have with each other.

Yes, but private companies are bound to operate within the confines of local, state, and Federal laws. Is there a law esp at the Federal level protecting our letters and packages going via a private route? I mean, I don’t say to UPS: “Now, sign a contract to promise you won’t read this…”

We assume they won’t read otu mail, but that’s as good as the paper it is written on in the eyes of the courts. - Jinx

The short answer is that it’s illegal to send letters via UPS. Parcels, yes. Letters, no. And we’re not talking about some obscure federal statute in a dusty old law book. The USPS’s exclusive right to carry First Class Mail is protected by the US Constitution.

You are permitted to send literature with your non-USPS parcels – like operating manuals, and invoices and packing slips. But if you put a birthday card along with that Teddy bear to little cousin Lulu you’re breaking the law, buster!

And First Class Mail may not be opened or viewed by the USPS (though I’m sure there are eclusions to this rule). Other classes may be opened or inspected as the USPS wishes.

~ stuyguy, the retired postal clerk’s son

This is patently untrue, unless “First Class Mail” is being defined in some narrow and obscure way. Because if it is true, then FedEx, UPS, Airborne, and every corporation in America is going to jail. We regularly send things that we would have sent via US Mail via FedEx (i.e., letters, contracts, memos, etc.), just b/c it will get there sooner (not b/c it’s a “parcel”).

Actually, this was a major issue back in the 80s, covered in all the major news and business magazines as a hot new trend. It certainly was illegal for the carriers to deliver such mail (but not necessarily for the sender to send it; that issue was slightly murkier). The original “2-lb document packages” made available by the major carriers were transparent attempts by commercial carriers to get around this restriction, by ostensibly being designed for “Media Mail” and “Parcel Post”, not first class mail, but of course, the commonest use for the fixed-fee up-to-2lb cardboard delivery envelopes was for material that could have been sent by first class mail. No one forced you to actually send 2lbs, and if they did, no one could prevent you from shipping a small brick with your letter, any more than the USPS could prevent you from sending a letter by USPS Parcel Post rather than USPS First Class. It’s just cost more (as the commercial service envelopes did)

Just because it’s a common practice today, doesn’t mean it wasn’t a well-acknowledged violation of the intent of the original law. Even the CEOs of the carriers ‘officially’ discouraged the practice (nudge nudge, wink wink) but claimed they couldn’t control the contents of the sealed packages. The USPS couldn’t enforce this law without alienating Congress and the public, but they certainly wanted to.

I should also note that even today, when commercial carriers are being subcontracted by the USPS to handle some Postal services, this issue is still a legal barrier:

I’m pretty sure that express mail or overnight mail doesn’t count as first class mail.

Okay, we need some definitions here. According to the USPS’s website, First Class Mail (a trademark, I was surprised to learn!) is defined as follows:

First-Class Mail (FCM) - A class of mail that includes all matter wholly or partly in writing or typewriting, all actual and personal correspondence, all bills and statements of account, and all matter sealed or otherwise closed against inspection. First-Class Mail comprises three subclasses: postcards, letters and sealed parcels, and Priority Mail. Any mailable matter may be sent as First-Class Mail. First-Class Mail is a USPS trademark.

The USPS’s exclusive right to carry FCM are is protected by the “Private Express Statutes.” One USPS publication ( http://pe.usps.gov/cpim/ftp/manuals/qsg/q011.pdf ) defines the PES as follows:

The Private Express Statutes are a group of laws under which the U.S. Postal Service (USPS) has the exclusive right, with certain limited exceptions and suspensions, to carry letters for compensation. The Statutes are based on the provision in the U.S. Constitution that empowers Congress “to establish Post Offices.”

The publication goes on to cover the exceptions as follows:

The law allows for the private carriage of letters under certain circumstances, including letters:

Sent with and relating in all substantial respects to the cargo that they accompany.

Carried by the senders or recipients or their regular, salaried employees.

Carried by private hands without compensation.

Carried by special messenger on an infrequent, irregular basis for the sender or addressee.

Carried to or from a postal facility prior or subsequent to mailing.

For example, an individual may transport without restriction his or her own letters, or a company its own letters (but not those of a parent or subsidiary) if it uses its regular salaried employees as couriers. Contract couriers would not qualify under this exception to the Statutes.

More information regarding exceptions and suspensions to the Private Express Statutes is available in 39 CFR 310.3 and 320. In addition, the USPS has suspended the Private Express Statutes for extremely urgent letters (see below).

Certain extremely urgent letters may be carried by means other than the USPS and without the payment of postage. To ensure that this provision is not open-ended, two tests of urgency are prescribed. If either of these tests is met, the suspension applies:

(1) The letter’s value or usefulness will be lost or greatly diminished if not delivered within specific urgent time limits, and the private carrier meets that time limit. Specifically, the time limit for this test for letters dispatched before 12 noon and within 50 miles of the intended destination is delivery within 6 hours or by the close of the addressee’s normal business day. Delivery of letters dispatched within the same distance after 12 noon and before 12 midnight must be completed by 10 a.m. on the addressee’s next business day. For letters sent more than 50 miles, delivery must be completed within 12 hours or by noon of the addressee’s next business day.

– or –

(2) It is “conclusively presumed” that a letter is extremely urgent if the amount paid for the private carriage of the letter is at least $3.00 or twice the applicable First-Class rate (including Priority Mail), whichever is greater.

OK, is the following actually legal under these laws?

My local electric company has tried having the individual customer bills delivered house to house by people (not regular company employees) and placed on my porch (not in the mailbox). Can they legally do that?

P.S. I think they’ve given up on this practice. It didn’t seem to work very well for them. I know that I (like, apparently, many others) saw this brightly colored envelope laying there with the pizza delivery coupons and window replacement offers and figured it was all junk mail, and just tossed it in the garbage.

Then a couple months later I get a call from them about my past due bill. They wanted to charge me late fees, etc. but relented when I objected, especially if I promised to send a payment (even partial) right away. Seemed to me they were in a bit of a cash crunch! And it was clear from talking to the person that she had been making these calls all day, and been hearing the same story from many customers – they hadn’t seen the bill at all. I don’t think they do this anymore.