Hey, that's my credit! (Advice please)

I have a co-worker who I also consider a good friend. We work together as Public Defenders, and we share an office.

Recently, she was very stressed, and very overwhelmed because she had two pretty heavy motions due the next day.

My load was rather light that day, and I offered to help her. I took one file, and wrote out most of one motion. In fact, all she had to do was plug in some case law and add a few things our boss wanted her to add.

She finished her other motion, added what my boss wanted, found applicable case law and added it, and gave it to my boss to peruse.

I read it too. I wrote about 80% of what was in the finished motion.

My boss came in our office, congratulated her on an “excellent motion.” He asked her to make some changes to the things that she added, leaving my contribution alone. He sat at her desk, leafed through the motion, and would say things like “this part is great. . .Good point. . . excellent, excellent.”

She was standing behind him, and I was at my desk, facing them. She turned to me, flashed a thumbs up, and mouthed the words “That was the part you wrote.”

Odd, I thought.

She gave the motion to another attorney in our office, and he came in to tell her that he had especially liked the conclusion.

Her response to someone complimenting my conclusion? “Thank you.”

I know it’s petty of me. I was helping her out, and didn’t expect anything in return. I hadn’t even thought about receiving credit until she started taking it all.

But it irks me. I wrote the damn thing. Everyone loved it. She took all the credit.

I did ask the other attorney later on if she had told him about my contribution. He laughed and laughed, and then said no.

So, I’m thinking I should let the subject alone. As I said, she is a good friend. But part of me wants to tell our boss.

Am I being an asshole for wanting the recognition for my (significant) part of what has been declared an “excellent motion?” Would I be hurting a friendship to declare my part in the motion?

Any advice?

At minimum you should tell your friend that you would have appriciated recognition for your contributions. Perhaps she will go to the boss on her own.

A few things to consider:

Do you need the recognition? If not, let it go. Does your boss already know that your work is as good as the work he was complimenting? If so, have you received such accolades in the past? If not, speak up (privately).

Do you think any promotions/raises could be in jeporady? No sense being passed over because you made someone else look better.

Is your friend not capable to handing in work equal to your quality or was she just backed up on the work load and could have gave the same quality if she had the time you did?

How would your boss take it? Will he think your friend can’t handle the work load or is helping out like that expected? How do you think ratting out your friend will go?

It would probably hurt your friendship if you told the boss, yeah. But if it bothers you, you should probably talk directly to her. Is it possible she didn’t say anything because she was embarrased someone had to help her? If she gave you that secret thumbs-up, it sounds like she thought you were doing her a favor (which of course you were) and didn’t expect to get credit for it…

My point is it sounds like a misunderstanding and you should get her story before you do anything rash.

No, don’t tell the boss; it’s too late now. Chalk this up to experience. You’ll know what to do and how to do it next time.

As for your friend? Don’t offer to help any more. Should she happen to ask again, bring up what happened last (this) time and ask how she’ll handle it.

Helping her was the right thing to do. Helping her in the future would be the right thing to do. Going out of your way to make sure everyone knew you wrote the good bits would be petty and demeaning.

If you write that well when just helping someone out, you probably write better when focused on your work. People will notice. No need to seem like George Costanza trying to get credit for the big salad.

Yeah.

Suck it up.

Were you or were you not trying to be helpful?

If she says “Well, I didn’t write THAT part” to anyone, she loses face. And she loses face big time, IMO. And if you insist that she do that, then you haven’t been in the ‘helping spirit’, so to speak.

So suck it up and leave things be. Or simply refuse to help amynore.

When your birthday rolls around, remind her of the help you gave her and hint about that really really expensive present you want.

That is a very good point. Your friend knows that you did the parts that were considered good. Unless your boss thinks your works stinks, let it go. She’s your friend, you helped her in a pinch and helped her get kudos from the boss. Don’t start getting greedy.

I can’t believe a lawyer would do something that sleazy.
All illusions I’ve held have now been shattered!
.

What leenmi said. If you complain you’re going to look like the sibling running to Mom complaining that Johnny cut the pie and then took the bigger piece. You sowed some good karma, and it sounds as though your friend realizes how much you helped her. It’ll come back to you :slight_smile:

Don’t mention it to your boss. It’s, what, less than one day’s worth of work? Pfft. Let it go.

On the other hand, I would probably mention it to her that you were a little uncomfortable about it, and, unless she apologizes and agrees to share credit appropriately in the future, don’t help her out again. This happening once is no big deal, but if it became a common occurrence, it would certainly put a great deal of strain on your friendship–which, based on the OP, is important to you.

I had the same thing happen to me. In this case the co-worker received a bonus check and recognition in front of the entire company, for solving such a difficult problem. Afterwards she came up to me and said “you must really hate me”. I was pissed at the time, but I decided not to say anything, mostly because I am a wimp. Later I realized that I did the right thing. I didn’t have to toot my own horn and look petty, and I got noticed for my abilities anyway. Just let it go… maybe the birthday present thing is a good idea though. I did guilt her into Chinese lunch on the bonus, which was only $100 bucks anyway.