I’m watching “Baseball”, the Ken Burns documentary. Although I enjoy these, he does not always spend a lot of time on a specific topic. They usually leave me with a bunch of questions. I’ve only seen the first two episodes thus far. I will have more.
-
Baseball is said to have been a refined version of “town ball”, which apparently had loose rules. One change was that in “town ball”, the batter was out if physically hit with the ball while running back and forth. So they’d be chucking a hard baseball at someone to get them out? Really?
-
The New York Knickerbockers used to travel to the Elysian Fields in Hoboken to play. Initially crowds formed around the diamond. But once popularity skyrocketed and stadiums like the Polo Grounds were built, mobs of people were still allowed on the edges of the foul lines. How often did people get hurt? How often did fans get hit with fouls, or argue with the umpires?
-
Doubleday, a war hero, was given credit for inventing the game after a 2 year investigation funded by Spalding, desperate to claim it was an American invention. No one now apparently thinks he even saw a professional game. However, the Civil War greatly popularized the game, which people brought back to their hometowns.
A) If this is true, is it possible Doubleday does deserve some credit if he established some rules for soldiers playing?
B) Are there any other sports or games which became popular due to a war?
-
I always thought Jackie Robinson broke the barrier for black athletes. How is it one hears little about earlier players like Moses “Fleetwood” Walker? Why did the series not discuss White or even earlier players who were forced to pretend they were not Black?
-
I did not know the National League was originally puriticanical, then the competing American League originally featured cheaper tickets and beer before being periodically cleaned up. Seems baseball always attracted hooligans. Fans were originally tolerated going on to the field to argue plays. Players tried to spike opponents. Pitchers threw spitballs. How were these cleaned up?
-
Given the propensity of many early players to brawl (like Frank Chance) or be misanthropes (like Ty Cobb), why were popular eccentrics like Rube Waddell too tough to tolerate?
-
I did not know Evers was a perpetual grouch who did not talk to Tinker for two years over a dispute about a taxi bill. What’s the story here?
-
Given boxscores have existed for so long, giving much loved tradition and continuity, how do experts rank historical stars like Waddell, Mathewson, Wagner or Cobb? How do they compare them to modern greats?
-
The screwball (fadeaway) pitch may have been the idea of Negro League pitcher “Rube” Foster and passed along to Mathewson? Is it still used? I used to watch Fernando Valenzuela throw it years ago.
-
Baseball was originally a strictly amateur sport, but good players started getting paid around the 1850s. Were there earlier examples of professional sport leagues? Did they also have player union issues due to “greedy” owners? Individual athletes like gladiators, do they count?
-
Do you ever here anything but the chorus to “Take Me Out To The Ball Game”? There’s a whole song, popularized during cinema bouncing-ball singalongs. When did cinema singalongs stop being a thing?
-
They discuss the “Merkle Boner”. Fans rushed onto the field after a long single brought in the winning run. Merkle ran to the clubhouse instead of touching second base. The ball was thrown into the crowd but found its way back to Evers who tagged Merkle out long after the celebration. Was this the right call under the circumstances? Seems very dubious to me.
-
Throwing games started in the 1850s and reduced attendance. A great early star was kicked out for taking a $100 bribe with 3 others. Obviously it resurfaced for the Black Sox Scandal. My older brother claimed Pete Rose was thrown aside, but only bet for his team and never against them. Is this true? Likely? Was he treated fairly?
-
I played T-ball, then baseball as a lad. When was T-ball invented?
-
We used to mock the other team. “Hey batter, batter”. “Pitcher’s got a rubber arm”. Don’t see that as much in other sports - infield chatter. “Hey golfer, golfer. Drive, golfer, golfer.” But fan insults have a long history in baseball. In 1906, the loud Boston crowd changed the lyrics to “Tessy” to say ‘Honus Wagner hits badly’, and it rattled the opposition. It wouldn’t today. Was it even possible to ignore the crowd then?
-
The reserve clause basically stuck good players with one team for life. Was this common in other sports?
-
“The Christian Gentleman”, Mathewson, wouldn’t give interviews to sports writers he heard were unfaithful. How would he know? Is there much truth to this, or folderol to promote a desired clean league image?
-
When did they get rid of the barrel of whiskey at third base to incentive runners? A great tradition. Should be brought back. Any other semi-professional team games (except Tequila Volleyball) where drinking during the game was once so encouraged?
-
Is it bizarre that early stars supplemented incomes by appearing in plays and vaudeville shows in the winter? Or is this just a rehash of Dancing With The Stars?
-
Black teams or players were often refused hotel accommodation, might spend hours seeking it. Why not a team rail car? When was this problem really resolved?
-
“As long as America has baseball, it will never tolerate monarchy”. Is this true of dictatorship?
-
Why was baseball so anxious to win English fans, or play in Egypt by the pyramids? The British denounced it as rounders and preferred cricket. Why was it deemed so important to win British approval? Why Egypt - was this en vogue after Howard Carter? Baseball became popular in Japan, the Dominican, Cuba, Venezuela. Was this the chicken or the egg? Probably the American presence after WW2 explains Japan, but did a Dominican or Cuban succeed in the majors first before popularity exploded, or was it an American of Dominican background succeed first and popularize things?
-
Is baseball a more democratic game than soccer (football)?
-
Spalding was a good ball player. He established a big sporting goods company. Originally, they tried to encourage every player on the team to have a distinct uniform. It looked ridiculous, so did not get too far. But how far did it get?