I recently bought the graphic novel of the Dark Phoenix Saga, compiling Uncanny X-Men #s 129 to 137. I owned those issues years ago, but sold much of my collection in the 1990s to help finance a backpacking trip through Europe. After watching the 2019 movie, which I liked more than most people did, I wanted to revisit the original.
First of all, the John Byrne artwork is stellar (with help from Terry Austin and Bob Sharen). And Claremont may well have a talent for plotting and character creation, depending on how much of that should be credited to him rather than Byrne. But the endless verbiage cluttering up the panels…oy. It would be cool to see someone erase all that nonsense and replace it with less than half the word counts in the captions and bubbles. The thought bubbles in particular need to be hacked away like noxious weeds.
“Still, Jean Grey is the woman I love. I’m the man she loves. That has to count for something. “
“There she is!”
“She’s dressed as the Black Queen – that’s not good.”
Three redundant thought bubbles, before he even starts speaking. :smack: His actual voice, crying out to Jean, is the fourth bubble (and ought to be the only one), all within one small panel.
I know some of this was because they had to catch up kids who may have just happened upon the title for the first time in a drugstore and did not have access to back issues in those days. But then why did they not rework it when it was made into a graphic novel? The constant thought bubbles about the characters’ own powers, their relationships to other characters and their powers, etc., gets really old and most importantly undercuts the art.