If I didn’t know better, I’d think you were trying to lure me off-topic to manufacture a ticky-tacky excuse for the mods to close the thread for going off topic. But you wouldn’t do that. It’s me- I am >probably< neurotypical, yet nevertheless sometimes don’t pick up on things like the extraordinary offensiveness and rule-breaking of responding to people addressing me in a thread I started, substantiating the point I am making or calling out bad arguments. I am trying to do better.
So, as for “what about all these other lobby groups”, first of all, I do support comprehensive campaign finance reform, and a look at how money warps our politics and takes power away from the public. But that’s not really the subject here.
I am prioritizing who becomes Speaker, and >why< it can’t be an AIPAC candidate, because of what Israel has done (really bad stuff), and the fact that the Speaker has a lot of influence in setting the agenda. We’ve already seen with the current administration what disastrous results follow from allowing Israel to set the agenda for America. An AIPAC candidate puts an Israel-influenced person in the position of setting the legislative agenda in the next Congress, and we simply Cannot have that. The public very much does not want that. If you care about reforming money in politics, you shouldn’t want that either, as Israel will never approve of reforms that limit their inappropriate influence over our government, and will likely pull strings to block it.
As Neguse said, “Israel has broken American laws and violated American values.” We want a Speaker who is aware of that and will act accordingly, like I believe Neguse would. As for your list of controversial PACs and special interests, there is one important distinction to make about all of them- with the exception of AIPAC, none of them are for the purpose of promoting the interests of a foreign power. I may not agree with MAGA, or the gun lobby, or the Christian right- I don’t agree with a lot of things if you haven’t noticed- but this is ostensibly a democracy, and aside from AIPAC, they’re all promoting the interests and concerns of segments of the US public. I should get my say, and they are entitled to their say. The only one that shouldn’t get a say is the foreign-power lobby. Especially Israel, considering what they’re doing with My tax dollars and to My government, which represents us, not them. At least in theory- people are angry and disillusioned because it seems like that is not the case.
I don’t think Jeffries will pursue an agenda that really reflects the will of the Dem majority- not fully at least, as he will be beholden to Israeli interests. Joe Neguese has demonstrated that he puts his duty to represent above his interest in contributions, which makes him seem more likely to act in good faith regarding what the public actually wants.
But yeah, money in politics tilts the whole system towards an oligarchy, something the Founders specifically led a revolution to escape. Which Speaker would be more likely to reform things in favor of the public and de-emphasize Big Capital- Neguse, who bucks Big Capital when it is against American interests, or Jeffries, who is far too interested in the interests of a foreign power that has already set our agenda to disastrous results? It seems obvious to me that Neguse would do better.
But the thread is about Why Not Neguse, and he’s not the only one to reject AIPAC demands and money. Among the others who have done the same, do you like any better for Speaker than Neguse?