I came up with a series of ideas about the origin and meaning of the Gorgon, at least one of which struck me with particular force. I wanted to share this insight with the world.
the thing is, it’s a multidisciplinary subject. It involved not only Greek Mythology, but Comparative Mythology, Anthropology, Astronomy, Animal Behavior, Pathology, Psychology, Art History, and other disciplines, none of which I was expert in, or even had (for the most part) any formal training in.
The best place to try to publish these ideas would, I thought, be some journal that touched on multiple topics. Nature, perhaps, or Science. This might be suitable for a long entry in their Letters sections.
Many months later I had a lot of rejected queries from a lot of magazines. I figured the best thing to do was to write my own book and get it published. This is, arguably, insane – if you couldn’t even get a letter published, why would anyone publish an entire book on the same topic? But I had some credentials behind me. Besides a number of technical papers in scientific journals, I had published an article in Scientific American and a science-meets-myth piece in Parabola magazine, and another in Weatherwise, and had published articles on other topics outside my field in other magazines. And I was inspired by David Ulansey’s book The Origins of the Mithraic Mysteries, which sought to explain Roman Mithraism in terms of astronomy. Ulansey’s book had been published by Oxford University Press, and he had a tie-in article in Scientific American.
So I went to work, writing individual chapters in no particular order, each on one aspect of the myth. Then I put them together in what seemed to be a logical order, and gave it to my wife to read.
“Nobody’s going to read this,” she said. “It reads like a thesis.” This is one reason I married this woman.
So I threw the whole thing out and started over from scratch, writing the book from beginning to end, so that the ideas would build in a logical order. And trying to write in a popular style, so that people wouldn’t get bored or lost and throw the book away with great force.
I had my wife and some friends read it and offer criticisms.
Then I composed a Book Proposal – after I had written the damned thing. I had written project proposals, so this wasn’t completely new territory for me. I gave it a snazzy cover and sent it off. to my complete and utter surprise, Oxford University Press – which has a tradition of publishing academic works by previously unpublished authors (and doesn’t always get its money back) – offered to publish it after their university readers had vetted it. even more surprising (to me), they left it almost completely intact. They did minimal revision in editing it.
over the next year I went through that book more times than I can count. (If you write a book, you better love it, because you’re going to be reading it a LOT). Because I wanted it to be heavily illustrated (to help make my points), I spent a year getting photographs and illustrations and permissions*, exhausting the meager advance they sent me. I even spent some of my own money for professional illustrations.
Then the whole thing went into their book incubator and took forever (it seemed) to get turned into an actual book. But it was worth it when I held the hardcover in my hands.
It must’ve been worthwhile. I still get cited (including multiple times by Wikipedia, and by academic tomes as well). The History Channel turned the book into an episode of their series Clash of the Gods (which features me, speaking, on camera. The show still shows up in the wee hours of the morning and startles people who knew me but had no idea what I’d been up to.) It’s still in print – I just got a royalty check a couple of days ago. It’s for a lot less than you’d imagine, so don’t get your hopes up. Somebody’s making money in the publishing business, but Og knows, it’s not the editors or the mid-grade or lower authors.
But the point of the book wasn’t mainly to make money** – it was to get my ideas out there. Writing a book allowed me to express the ideas at greater length and detail than I could have in a Letter to Nature, and it guaranteed that it would be picked up and passed along by other outputs – Wikipedia, the History Channel – so that the ideas really were dispersed.
Plus, it’s great for the Ego. I might not have made much money on it, but, godammit, I wrote a book!
- I now love the Louvre. They actually sent me both illustrations and the permission forms even before I sent them money. By contrast, Italian museums won’t even acknowledge your letters of inquiry. Even if you pay a translator to rewrite them in Italian.
And my wife still loves telling about how a nice lady from the British Museum called about some of the photos I wanted and they had a nice long chat about the weather and our cats.
**Although that would have been nice.