Three sets of rotating magneto-optic disks for incremental backups every five days (with one set stored in my garage) + weekly incremental backups to hard drives (thence to segmenting and burning to CDRs) + monthly cloning to hard drives. This is just for my home system where all I have is e-mail, quicken-esque data and porn.
This came up at work a few days ago, and there seem to be two types of people: those who have byzantine and rigorous backup procedures and those who just don’t get it. At the end of our lab shifts, there’s a guy who backs up his software to the local hard drive, the server, the server again (in a different location), and someone else’s local hard drive on the network (CDR’s & hand-carried magnetic media are not allowed in our area). Half of the crew look at him like he’s nuts and the rest of us look at him and say, “there’s a good story behind that.”
FairyChatMom: Floppies bad. Optical (CDR or M-O) good. IMO here’s the list of backup media, in decreasing order of reliability:
DreadCthulhu’s method. I’m embarrassed that I don’t already have that in place.
Magneto-optic (amorphous silicon instead of chemical dyes)
CD-R (fairly stable chemical dyes)
DVD-R
CD-RW (less stable dyes)
DVD-RW
DLT (also convenient, but less stable organics than the disks listed above, plus magnetic field susceptibility and bleed-through)
Hard drives (also convenient with quick recovery; but susceptible to magnetic fields and physical shock)
Carefully arranged arrays of belly button lint
Floppies
Why do I put floppies at the bottom of the list? Variable production quality, mechanical complexity (even as compared to hard drives – integrated over the size of your backup, you’re comparing the aggregate reliability of 50-200 floppies versus one hard drive), sucsceptibility to temperature, magnetic fields and dust, and (the big one) you won’t be able to find a drive to pop your floppies within in a couple of years even as your current floppy drive is filling up with shmutz. Contrast that with belly button lint, for which you’ll always find a reliable supplier.
Long ago I worked at JPL and we were having severe problems with hundreds of data tapes from the sixties that were both brittle and rotting. Note an interesting factoid that many people don’t seem to know: all (?) plastic is derived from organic materials (i.e., petrochemicals), so somewhere out there, there’s a fungus or bacteria or something that would like to dine on said material.
Sorry to throw this out without a cite, but there’s some company that takes data sets, convolves them into two-dimensional error-corrected patterns and prints the patterns on acid-free paper using either very stable chemical dyes or india ink. Of course, then you have the silverfish problem. If that were made more practical and the paper were stored correctly, it might compete with the CD/DVDRs. Ironic that originals of The Canterbury Tales are readable whereas some Apollo, Gemini & Pioneer data is gone forever.