[QUOTE=Der Trihs]
Besides the others mentioned, two explanations I’ve heard are :
1 :Without evil, you cannot appreciate good, therefore God permits evil ( which makes God evil, IMHO )
2 : Without suffer and despair ( especially despair ), people will not be impelled to make a leap of faith to worship God. Faith is the only good ( anything is better than not having faith; it’s better to kill in the name of Kali, because at least you are affirming a faith ), therefore evil is necessary in order to promote faith.
[/QUOTE]
You are right, both make god evil. Number two is akin to a slave master too. I will beat the obedience out of you.
[QUOTE=Der Trihs]
IIRC pleasure, and not having more children.
[/QUOTE]
It would all be very well until, for example, he got paralyzed in a car accident……. Of course, we could still endure this if we have a very strong mind.
[QUOTE=Der Trihs]
Not really. We can do something about evil caused by nature and ourselves; if it’s infilicted by an omnipotent being there is no hope. In that case, we are all damned, and already in a Hell; if there is an afterlife, I expect we’d all go to an even worse Hell.
[/QUOTE]
It is true that we can deal with most suffering caused by nature and human. But what about the rest of the suffering we simply cannot resolve?
What could we tell a kid with terminal cancer?
[QUOTE=Sam Stone]
How about:
Adam ate from the tree of knowledge of good and evil.
…..
Call it mankind’s climb back up from a fallen state.
[/QUOTE]
But the original sin put the blame on ourselves. Isn’t this like kicking a man when he is down?
[QUOTE=David Simmons]
Or is could be the Book of Job on a larger sample. God and Satan might have a wager as to whether people worship God out of love of God or just because He gives them things.
[/QUOTE]
Similar to the Dualists explanation. Has this ever been the official explanation?
But of course, this also cannot explain that if god is omnipotent, why would he allow such thing to happen?
[QUOTE=GIGObuster]
After being religious and now being more of an agnostic,
…..
Eventually we would had figured the reason as many parents discover, but for sure the bible then would had been less sympathetic to god.
[/QUOTE]
Very interesting. So god is teaching us to walk on our own feet.
This would actually be a very good explanation, if we could ascribe that the sufferings were not deliberately caused by god.