I made a video of some little league players, and I used John Fogarty’s “Put Me In Coach” as a soundtrack. I got an email from YouTube that my video “[FONT=Arial]may have content that is owned or licensed by UMG,” although it does not happen to mention WTF is UMG.
Anyway, there are billions of songs out there. How does YouTube figure this out? It can’t possibly do an exhaustive search, not every version of a song will match bit-for-bit. I had a similar experience when I made a video of my son’s laser tag birthday party and used a *portion *of a song by Joe Satriani.
Edit: I am asking this out of intellectual curiosity, not to figure out how to circumvent copyright law.
[/FONT]
From what I understand, it’s really the copyright holder who does it, not YouTube (although they may use YouTube provided tools). And it’s a pain in the neck to try to use YouTube’s built in soundtracks, as they are organized poorly, fill up the whole video, and you can’t do anything about length differences.
I recently pulled a YouTube of Stephen Colbert appearing on Jimmy Fallon, singing “Friday” with Taylor Hicks. It was obviously not from NBC.
It was also flipped - i.e. the “film” had been reversed, so all the letters, actions, etc., were mirror images. I assumed it was to escape some kind of filter/scan that identified protected works.
No, it is YouTube that performs the scan these days. Here is an article that explains what is happening every time you press submit on a video (the main thrust of the article is copyright vs fair use, but it links to more technical articles that go into more detail). The copyright holder gets to decide what should be done with any content that matches their submissions.
I was gobsmacked when I heard about this system. It’s not technically difficult to compare video files to see if they are similar. What amazes me is that they can do this against a vast database of copyrighted content in an efficient enough manner to make it economical.
Its not perfect. My record label deals with a few original metal bands. We posted up a music video we just shot with their original song on it, and WMG flagged it.
The song was most definitely not the property of WMG.
You can however dispute the claim, which we did. Two minutes later the audio was back up.