Far harder than you seem to think.
Everyone thinks a low to zero budget horror film can be pushed out and horror fans will excuse poor plot, acting, direction… And actually it can be true. Such films can be a financial success. Any studio can pick up hundreds of ready made films each year from festivals for peanuts.
The problem with a really cheap film is that it costs far more to actually get it in cinemas - A cinema release is where it gets expensive. But even the marketing costs of a straight to DVD soon add up. Allow that these days most studios are only interested in blockbuster movies and demand for any given horror film soon dries up.
Many completed films sit in studio vaults because the companies buy them for many reasons but can’t be bothered to pay the costs of releasing them. **All The Boys Love Mandy Lane **is a good example. Got GREAT reviews, supposedly reinvented the slasher genre, best horror film of the year at all the festivals, bought for a tidy sum… Then sat unreleased for years.
While the studios love a franchise movie these days what they ACTUALLY love is a ‘clean’ franchise where they have clear legal rights to characters, plots and, of course, collectables.
Your Friday the Thirteenth is legally polluted with dozens of prior producers who still have partial control over any future films that get made. All have to be negotiated with. All have some degree of ‘Artistic Control’ and worst of all they are all entitled to getting paid. Even though they probably won’t have any active part in making a new film.
And that’s not to mention most of these long running franchises already have ongoing legal battles (usually over money) from the various previous versions.
Then there is the usual hiding to nothing with a horror film franchise. Make the narrative different to attract new fans and the established fan base won’t like it. Plus the (almost inevitable) bad reviews mean potential new fans won’t be interested either.
Read your own quote. Jackie Earle Haley was discussing salary (he wants more money making the film less financially viable from the off) and storylines (he wants creative control as will the director, all the other producers) plus the hard core fans will still want Robert Englund back anyway…
More trouble than it is worth.
TCMF-2L