How I lost some weight: apps, portion control and walking

In mid-March I got on the scale for the first time in a few weeks and saw a number that I had never seen before: 221. I think 218 was the highest I had seen prior to that, and the fact that 221 equates to 100 kilos made it seem extra significant.

I am 61 years old, 6 feet 2 inches tall, and I’m a software developer with a somewhat sedentary lifestyle. My diet was diverse but uncontrolled, at times immoderate. At 221 pounds, my BMI was around 28.4, in the overweight range, just 1.6 points south of obese.

I decided to do something about my weight by reducing input and increasing output. Brilliant and radical, I know. Since March 17, my weight has declined from 221.0 to 194.8, a change of 26.2 pounds. My goal is to stabilize at 190, so I am almost to the point of switching to a maintenance regimen.

An app called myfitnesspal has been the key to this. I use it to track my calories throughout the day. Using some basic facts about me and my goal, it provided me with an intake goal each day. As I add info about what I have eaten, it shows how many calories I have left to eat that day. The app has a staggering amount of data on packaged and chain restaurant food in it. In three months, there has been only one instance of a packaged food product that I searched for and didn’t find. For things it can’t find, there are generic comparable items from which to choose. The usefulness of all of this already-existing data is that when I search the app for Pepperidge Farm Seedless Rye Bread or a Longhorn Renegade Sirloin 8 ounce or Heritage Farm Thick Sliced Bologna Made with Chicken, it finds it. Someone has already input all of the nutrition info from the label or the restaurant website, and I just click it to add it to my diary.

The only food item that I have eliminated from my diet during this period has been cola. I used to have cola at restaurants, now I have water. I eat out about once a week, so this has not been significant. I still eat everything I used to eat: ice cream, potato chips, meat, fish and dairy. The app is helping me with portion control.

A few other pieces of technology are in the picture as well.

I bought a Withings scale. It claims to measure fat and heart rate, but all I care about is that is a pretty accurate scale that Bluetooths or Wifis my weight to myfitnesspal as soon as it gets a stable weight.

My company gives a health insurance discount for tracking steps, so I wear a fitbit Charge. This is a very accurate steps counter with an altimeter that tracks steps and stairs climbed and sends that info to myfitnesspal. If I take enough steps to exceed the average daily steps for my lifestyle, myfitnesspal adds some calories to my daily allowance of food.

Finally, when I go on an exercise walk, I use a GPS-driven app called runkeeper. This tracks my route, time, distance and pace and stores the info from each walk. It also allows me to post each walk on facebook to annoy my friends.

I have also been doing upper-body exercises at a local fitness center three times a week.

All of the apps are free. They have paid versions, but I am not using those.

The short description of what I have been doing is “portion control and walking”. If someone really presses me, I will tell them some or all of the above, but I really don’t want to be tedious about this stuff. I do get asked what’s going on frequently because it is really obvious that I have lost weight.

I realize the weight loss or control is easier for some than for others. I have posted this in the hope that someone in a similar situation to me might benefit from this approach, the apps and devices, whatever.

I can answer questions if there are any.

myfitnesspal is a killer app.

Congratulations on such a straightforward approach and for getting to your target weight in such short order!!

I need to make the decision to manage my weight better - right now I am stressed on a number of fronts and “self medicate with food” as the saying goes. This seems like a great, common-sense way to approach it.

Thank you for sharing your approach!

Yes, it is. I used it for a while and it really got me to recognize proper portion size. I still measure out my food, although weightwise I’m where I want to be now.

Congratulations!

I love myfitnesspal, too. I just went from a BMI of almost 32 to 24 in 5 months using it.

I also love myfitnesspal. The database of foods is VAST. And I love my FitBit Flex.

I forgot to mention any details of the walking I have been doing. I usually walk two to four times per week, 3 or 4 miles per walk, at a pace between 16 and 17 minutes per mile. I also do at least a mile per day of brief walks to take a break from whatever else I am doing.

Well done, Crotalus!

I did a weight-loss regime last year, lost a good amount. Just riffing on some of your points:

MyFitnessPal really is a killer app
Exercise is good
Portion (really, calorie) control is the biggest factor in weight loss.

Only thing I would add is that I wouldn’t worry too much about the scale measuring fat and heart rate. But I would urge you to weigh yourself every day and record it. Put your daily measurements into the free Hacker’s Diet online tool. Or of course, since you are a software developer - just make a basic Excel spreadsheet with your daily weight, exponentially smoothed - to get good feedback on your progress.

I need to get back on the weight-loss horse - I’ve been distracted with a recent move. I’m still weighing myself every day and I can see it creeping back up. Time to get serious again.

Keep it up!

Hey, I love my Withings scale, too, precisely because it feeds directly into MyFitnessPal, and also Health, Wahoo, Strava, and GarminConnect. When Health knows your weight and you use a heart rate monitor during exercise, every other app is able to magically calculate the stuff it needs to calculate (mostly energy consumption).

I do basically what the OP does, except my moment of realization was when my scale hit 300 lbs (and I’m only one inch taller).

I’ve always been a strong walker, but it wasn’t nearly enough, so I’ve returned to serious cycling instead, both endurance road (mainly) and mountain (cross country, just for variety).

For portion control I’ve been eating keto style (low carb, high fat). It just works, and is surprisingly compatible with endurance exercise (I’ve only got a couple of sprints in me, which is the only downside). Sometimes I forget to eat!

I use MyFitnessPal for all weight loss tracking, but currently only intermittently as a sanity check to ensure my portions and macronutrients are still under control.

My health check and bloodwork after nearly the five month mark came back absolutely fine with markedly improved HDL and LDL, so I’m convinced that I’m not killing myself. I was (luckily) never pre-diabetic, and blood sugar was just fine.

I’m under 230 lbs now, still losing steadily, and expect to be around 190 lbs by my one year “ketoversary” in December.

Congrats, Crotalus!

Tell us about your caloric intake. What you limit yourself to, how often you’ve gone over, and how exceeding your limit affects your motivation.
mmm

This is how I lost weight as well, although I didn’t have the scale or fitbit. I lost a lot of weight and managed to keep most of it off.

I have 7 pounds I’d like to lose, but with my new hours, I can’t seem to fit in my daily walk anymore. I need to work on that, but I think I’ll wait for the fall. It’s too hot right now.

Congratulations, Crotalus. Job well done. I bet you’re feeling so much better too.

Thanks for the kind responses, and congratulations to my fellow losers. :slight_smile:

mmm - When I first started, I weighed 221, had a goal of 200, and entered my activity level as sedentary. myfitnesspal gave me a daily allowance of 1850 calories based on that. A couple of months in, I had reached my goal. At that point I decided to try to get my BMI into the normal range and changed my goal weight to 190. Since I was averaging over 10,000 steps a day I changed my activity level setting to “lightly active”. That gave me an allowance of 1990 calories. I usually do enough walking so that the app adds a few hundred calories to that.

I have exceeded my daily allowance a couple of times. I started this with a long-term perspective, so I don’t worry about a lapse or two. The calorie allowance I have is in no way a starvation diet. I don’t feel deprived at all. What I feel is restrained, slightly. I just need to think a little bit about what I ingest.

What I find a little harder to deal with is the mornings when I get on the scale and have gained a pound or two. For instance, yesterday I weighed 194.8, the lowest since I began this regimen. This morning I weighed 197. The graph of my weight in myfitnesspal is a jagged line with a negative slope, and I know that I’m moving in the right direction. I am even confident that I will reach my goal of 190 in a month or so. But it feels kinda bad to see a two pound increase after a day when I did a four mile brisk walk, lifted weights, and was 400 calories under my exercise adjusted allowance.

GameHat - Even though my scale sends my weight directly to myfitness pal, which records and graphs it, I started a spreadsheet early in the process with moving 3-day and 5-day averages. Now I’ll have to add exponential smoothing! :cool:

Way to go, Slim!!!

My story and timing parallels yours somewhat, although I’ve not been dedicated enough to use and follow an app or program. While I’ve always been reasonably fit, about 6 months ago I started experiencing some issues with my feet and in the course of getting medical advice about that learned I was at least pre-diabetic and right on the edge of Type 1. So not that I ate a lot of sweets but, like your cola and being from the south, I loved sweet tea. So that went out the door, I cut back on red meat, ate even more veggies and got a puppy that needed lots of walks. I also have a room that doubles as a gym with free weights, a treadmill, etc. The result, I’ve lost 22 lbs and 2 pant sizes (the waist, not the length).

I must say I love going back to any doctor I saw before and surprising them with the weighing in. And buying smaller clothes, that’s nice too. Right now I’m at college weight and by Christmas I’d like to be back at 196, what I weighed at my fittest when a senior in H.S.
ETA: Oh yeah, “portion control”, absolutely!

Good job!

I came in here hoping for some more exercise apps. Food is not my problem. I tracked everything I ate on Lose It! for a couple of months and I never even came up to my recommended calorie level. I eat healthy.

What is my problem is my sedentary lifestyle. I need to exercise more! Thing is, I hate exercising, it’s always a chore.

But yes, I have to lose weight, too.

Way to go, lieu!

Anaamika - The only exercise apps I have looked at are GPS and step based apps to track walking, running and cycling. The one I use is Runkeeper. I’m sure there are apps that will track and encourage other kinds of exercise. The app I am using to track calories will interact with tons of fitness apps, including those that track heart rate. Good luck!

Thank you!

Crotalus - my story is eerily similar to yours (portion control, calorie tracking, more excercise, lose weight, profit!), but I just used the tracking program that came with the FitBit Charge (the dashboard). Any real differences between that and MyFitnessPal?

I also have a FitBit, but I do my meal tracking on MFP. The database is unbelievably huge. It’s because users can add items. You will find multiple entries for Costco Cesar Salad (or whatever), and that can be annoying, as there is no uniform way that people input food items, but you’ll also see a notation that says “7 confirmations” which means other users have verified the data.

You’ll find house brands from your local grocery store, even dishes from local restaurants (provided you live in a city larger than 1,000 or so).

MFP is free, so why not try it? I don’t get any spam from them (but if you want to look up Spam, I’m sure it’s there in all its varieties).

ETA: I did Weight Watchers online for a while, but not only is it rather expensive (compared to free), the database didn’t come close to MFP.

I also use Runkeeper – actually it has loads of exercises you can enter. Its GPS functions are more directed at distance-traveling exercise, but you can log almost anything using the “log” function. It sometimes gives you prizes for personal bests – I’ve gotten some decent stuff like a Zipcar credit.

Try Couch to 5k. And enter a race! Personally I find that the terror of actually entering a race keeps me on the program, and 3x/wk x 30 minutes feels really doable and not an overwhelming time-suck. I get two runs in at lunch during the week, and one on Sunday morning.

I’m starting to find that running clears my head and I’m developing a grudging enjoyment of it after about a year. But, sometimes I think needing everything to be fun is bit of a distraction. Its perfectly fine to exercise because its something good for you, like brushing your teeth.

On June 1st, my wife and I both returned to a modified Weight Watchers program. I say ‘modified’, because - much like drunks - we don’t attend meetings. Their point system is very effective, as it automatically imposes portion control without eliminating anything from your diet. If you stay within the allowed point maximum for your weight category and exercise even moderately, it’s impossible not to lose weight. I never feel hungry. Although I still have the urge to snack, I don’t do it unless it’s planned for the day’s intake. In 18 days, I’ve gone from 238 down to about 227 (I only weight myself on Mondays, so that’s an estimate); slow but sure wins the day. I’d like to get down around 200, but I’m taking it one day at a time.

Added bonus: after a week my glucose dropped from 115 (fasting) to 103.

Bumping my thread to report on a happy coincidence: exactly four months since I decided to reduce my weight to 190 pounds, I got on my scale this morning and saw a reading of 190.0. maybe I’ll bump it again in a year to report on my success or failure at maintaining that weight.