[QUOTE=DefyingGravity]
Oh, no. Now I feel really really depressed. I have truly been here since early days, and when I subscribed when it went to pay I seem to recall that it was if you subscribed within a certain time period you got “lifetime” Charter Membership. Since when I un-lapsed my membership my post count and my account popped back into existence, why do I lose my lifetime charter status?
I wish I hadn’t responded in the first place, that seems like kind of a harsh thing to do, to a 7 or so year member, a first subscriber, a recipient of lifetime charter status, and a generally all-around nice person who doesn’t hurt kitties or anything like that?

EmmaJane
[/QUOTE]
Not meant to be cruel, not at all and I’m sorry you feel so disappointed.
The Charter Member offer was made one time and one time only. It was a promise made to you and a promise on your part.
Our promise to you: Charter Members pay half the going rate for as long as they stay subscribers.
Your promise to us: You will keep subscribing every year.
That’s really all there is to it.
Once Charter Membership is lost it cannot be regained. If you stop subscribing and the subscription expires you are no longer a Charter Member.
(In the interest of full disclosure I will mention we have had ONE person regain Charter Member status, but that was because he was in the U.S. Armed Forces and did not have access to the Straight Dope while overseas, many websites are blocked on military computers. Under the circumstances we felt granting that one exemption was reasonable. We don’t plan on doing this a lot; if it’s up to Jerry it will never happen again.)
All you have to do to keep Charter Membership in force is to continue to subscribe. If you stop subscribing, it’s over and Charter Member designation is lost.
It’s as simple as that. It’s as clear as that.
We remind you when it’s time to resubscribe – there’s announcements on the board, we send you email – more than one email, in fact – people talk about it. It’s not a secret.
I always hate it when someone becomes unhappy like this but dammit, what can we do? I can’t fix retroactively what you didn’t take care of in the first place. I routinely receive email from people who feel they’re still entitled to be Charter Members and request reinstatement. When I explain the situation they become angry and hurt. There’s nothing I can do about any of it.