How much do you like people?

Here is the premise: you and a handful of close friends are heading out for a meal or drink (or whatever you are into). There are only 2 pubs/restaurants/venues to choose from. One is completely empty, the other is somewhat busy, but not busy beyond capacity and there is enough space for you and your friends. Otherwise they are identical, run by the same people with the same quality of food/drink/whatever. Which one do you prefer?

Which venue do you choose?
  • Empty venue
  • Busy-ish venue
  • Don’t care either way
0 voters

I like privacy, so I choose the crowded venue. We’ll draw a lot more attention in an empty place than in a full one.

I picked ‘Busy-ish venue’, not because I like people necessarily, but because I like good food and service. The completely empty venue is probably empty for a reason.

OP specified the two places are identical. The difference maybe is just time of day or day of week.

Empty is fine. Room enough for us is fine.

Packed and need to shout over the din of everyone else shouting over the din? Fuggedaboudit.

Having the flexibility to go out any day of the week and at any time, I generally avoid Fri & Sat at peak times exactly to avoid the “shout over the shouting” effect.

Oh yeah, I’m usually a little better at reading the OP than that. i blame it on an early morning and lack of coffee yet.

Still, I might avoid the empty place for the reason @Alessan mentioned. I’ve eaten at restaurants before where we were the only patrons for whatever reason, and it’s kind of weird.

Busy-ish.

  • Enough that we could blend in and feel a “part of society,” but not enough people that we’d have to yell across the table just to be heard.
  • Enough people that we’d understandably wait 5-10 minutes for drinks (my iced tea should be there within 2-3 min), but not enough people that my friends’ drinks would be taking 10-15 minutes from the bar while I’m on tea #3.
  • Enough to start a rockin’ food fight, but not busy enough that we couldn’t find cover or clearly huck a dinner roll at the manager’s head.

Tripler
It’s all about firepower and maneuver, yo.

My wife avoids empty restaurants for that reason. If we magically knew that we were going to get good food and service in advance, presumably it wouldn’t matter; I’d probably have the unicorn steak with a side of pixies.

I’ve been to mostly empty restaurants that were good. I went to a surprisingly nice Japanese place that was good Friday night. My host recommended the place.

Since the pandemic I’ve been a shy of eating in crowded places. I was just easing out of that habit when my husband contracted cancer, and the treatment leaves him immunocompromised. (He’s in remission and otherwise in very good health now.) So I’m avoiding crowded restaurants.

I chose the busy-ish location, because while I don’t like people I kind of like people watching

(Airports are an especially good venue)

I liked another poster’s assumption that a busier restaurant would have better food. I bought a breakfast burrito from an empty fast food place a week ago, shoved it down and found out the salsa was awful. It was mostly distilled vinegar and hot pepper flakes. There’s a reason no one was buying one.

I chose the empty place, because I have a hard time hearing/conversing with someone if there’s any background noise. Many of us here at The Home wear hearing aids and even the relatively mild hum of voices PLUS the fans in the open-ish kitchen make it very hard for us to hear each other.

We have many great places that are uncrowded. At least out of snowbird season and at non-peak times. I know several small places with ~10 tables that are run as a labor of love by a retirement-aged chef. Great food, great service, few customers and no crowd buzz ever.


Story time:
This most recent Saturday = 2 days ago GF took me out to a real nice place for ruling class dinner in a trendy area. We had a 5pm reservation so we could finish in time to make a 7:30 show about 15 minutes’ drive away.

Place has about 150 seats ~= 40 tables plus a 20-seat bar. At our reservation time we were the second occupied table, plus 2 couples at the bar for the happy hour deal. IOW, the place was nearly empty. It was nice and quiet, superbly attentive service, etc. Exactly what you want for a leisurely romantic dinner.

By the time we left at 7pm they were over 90% full, lots of customer chatter, and our server, a real pro, was real busy juggling several tables, a couple of which were 8-person groups. Receiving a high quality multi-course experience was gonna be a lot harder for those folks than it had been for us.

We’ll definitely return; it was great. But I’d be inclined to avoid peak times on peak days. So I get the peak experience, rather than management making peak money per minute.

Bottom line: somebody who walked by as we were seated, looked in the window, and concluded “This place must suck since nobody is in there” would be making a major mistake.

The question posed in the OP and poll doesn’t really seem to actually have much to do with “how much do you like people?” That’s a totally different question from “Would you eat in a completely empty restaurant.” I would probably pick the busy-ish one just because being the only patrons in an establishment is a very weird vibe. (If it was actually crowded, I would go elsewhere.)

Yeah, I don’t think this is based on how much you like people either. If a restaurant is empty on a fairly ordinary night, there’s usually a good reason to avoid it.

Agreed. The question posits that I’ve already decided to go out to dinner with other people; therefore I’m not already seriously peopled out at the time, but am feeling sociable. If I really need to be alone right then, I’m staying home. And it specifies that the restaurant with other customers isn’t overcrowded, so I don’t have to worry that it’ll set off an occasional problem I have with crowds so thick that I don’t feel I can rapidly get out of them if necessary.

I voted that it doesn’t matter, because it isn’t my own reaction to the people that would matter. However, if I know the food, service, and ambience are all equally to my taste, I’d be somewhat inclined to give the empty place my business, as at least at that moment they’d seem to need it more.

For me, the less people, the better.

Daughter and I went to a Mexican restaurant last night. We were the only ones there. Was nice and quiet, which I like, and the food & service were excellent.

What @ThelmaLou and @LSLGuy said.

If the quality of the food is equivalent at both places, I’m picking the emptier spot, so we can easily converse, and get better service.

My choice, however, is unrelated to the question posed in the thread title. I like people a lot.

Co-signed.

I love people, just not all together at once.

I’d pick the empty restaurant, and often do. I can’t concentrate with ambient noise. It’s like being pelted with small rocks. So I try to only come during off-hours.

I’ve been to some very good restaurants that have predictable lulls in service.

I voted “don’t care either way” but actually it hinges on what the OP means by “a handful”. There’s a point (6 or so) at which it doesn’t matter either way and the party is self-sustaining. But 3 of us, I’d prefer the fuller venue.

The older my wife and I get, the harder it is to hear even in a moderately busy restaurant. Same for people our age we know. We’re now picking times that we would have scoffed at as senior citizen hours because we can have a pleasant meal before the crowd gets there.

Nothing else really matters. All else being equal, other people are fine, emptiness is fine. Only loudness counts.

Sorry, OP. I bet you’re still a young’un.