I know there are no right answers here, but I ran into this dilemma while pondering my own memories of preschool, which was that groups of kids always singled out ‘weaker’ classmates to pick on, and that no disciplinary strategies seemed to stop them. Sorry, long OP coming up…
Imagine you are a preschool teacher, and you notice that a group of your students (let’s call them Jim, Bob, Sally, and Laura) have regularly been picking on other students (Harry and Ellen) who are small, shy, and somewhat socially awkward. Their actions include name-calling and a small amount of violence (throwing toys at Harry and Ellen and pulling their hair). Harry and Ellen’s response is to attempt to fight back, but eventually – because they are outnumbered and weak – to cry until you, the teacher, arrive.
What is the best course of action in this situation?
First of all, do you want the result to be that Jim, Bob, Sally, and Laura are rendered unable to pick on Harry and Ellen (somehow separating them from the rest of the group, or making sure that they are never near Harry or Ellen during activities), or do you want it to be that they learn to be polite and friendly to Harry and Ellen?
The biggest problem with the first is viability. You could take the extreme route and expel the four bullies from the preschool, but you would do this with the knowledge that they will go on to another school to torture other small children. This will also make their parents very unhappy. As for separating the students during activities, well, what can you really do about times like recess when students can freely mingle?
Learning to be polite – well, how do you teach that? You are not the children’s parent, and you serve only as a part-time model of behavior, at best. For all we know, these children’s parents are bullies themselves, in the adult world. Is it best to teach the children that behaving wrongly has immediate negative consequences (putting the bullies in ‘time out’, or even corporal punishment)? Is it best to focus your entire class on cooperation and the value of equal treatment for all (perhaps even with historical examples such as segregation)? Is it best to simply repeat lessons about courtesy (which probably bores students, but maybe you could use interesting teaching aids like television clips)?
The last solution I can think of is focusing not on the bullies but on Harry and Ellen, providing a safe space for them and keeping them separate from the other children, who make life hell for them. If you asked Harry and Ellen, who have small children’s brains, this is probably what they would want. Overall though, I think this would cause them some serious social difficulties in the future, as well as teaching them that they have the ‘right’ to be sheltered all their lives.
Is there a better solution than any of the ones I’ve thought of, or is one of my solutions just OK enough to work? IANAPreschoolTeacher, and if anyone who is or has studied child psychology has any thoughts, I’d love to hear them. Opinions from the rest of the world will be just as valued.
(And pardon my snark, but answers claiming that Harry and Ellen just need to grow a spine will be ignored. Not that I think any of you will respond in that way, but that seems to be what some of my teachers believed. :smack: )