[QUOTE=commasense]
You misunderstood my point. Both the VCR and the TV (and maybe other components) need to get the signal from the aerial so they can tune in the broadcast stations. This is the case regardless of how the other components are connected to the TV.
If the TV has only one antenna input (relatively rare these days) and you’re using it for the VCR, then you won’t need the splitter. The aerial will be connected to the VCR and the VCR’s RF output will go to the TV. Then, when the VCR is off, the TV will be able to receive all the broadcast stations through its tuner. Or you can watch through the VCR’s tuner, and leave the TV set to channel 3 or 4.
[/QUOTE]
Of course, you get a better picture from the VCR while playing a movie with the RCA cables, even if you use the coaxial for the TV.
Assuming I have one coaxial input and two rear RCA inputs in the TV and no other inputs (which would make it easier) and that the set-top box can at least output a signal using RCA phono, I would: Plug the antenna into the coax on the VCR and then go from the coax out of the VCR to the coax in to the TV. Do not use the RCA plugs for the VCR as the VCR output inherently has the worst picture quality and coax should be good enough. Plug the DVD player into the TV using one set of RCA plugs. Plug the satellite into the TV using the other set. There you go, all set up.
It can get trickier, of course, as you add components, but it can also be easier. To the TV I have in my living room I have connected:
The Playstation 2 (no standalone DVD player) with the video into the front RCA input the audio going directly into the minisystem (the input marked AUX.)
Two VCRs: One is connected only into the other with RCA cables for dubbing purposes, which isn’t really used. The other gets the coax feed from the DVR from the satellite dish. That VCR is then connected to the TV’s single coax input. No antenna is involved. This VCR uses an A/B switch with the video going into the rear input while the audio goes into the minisystem (the input marked Video.)
The Sega Dreamcast: Plugged into the RCA-only VCR. This feeds the signal from the Dreamcast into VCR2 and then into VCR1 and works fine once all the settings are right in both VCRs.
The XM receiver: Audio-only, goes into the other half of the A/B switch. Obviously the audio again outputs out of the switch into the “Video” input.
So, if I want to watch a TV show I just I turn on the TV, set it to the appropriate channel (in this case, 60), and change channels in the DVR while leaving the TV on 60. If I want the audio from the minisystem as well, I have to turn on the VCR and the minisystem with the input set on Video and the switch set properly, but I don’t actually have to use the tuner in the VCR, meaning I don’t have to switch the TV to video mode.
To play a Playstation game or a DVD I just switch the minisystem to the Aux setting and switch to the proper input in the TV.
I can listen to the audio from the XM separately from what’s playing on the TV or the Playstation by switching the A/B switch and turning the minisystem to Video. This is nice when you’re sick of the commentary in Madden or want to watch baseball without having to listen to Tim McCarver and want the game’s radio feed.
Of course this would be easier if I spent the cash on an ABCD switchbox, but I use the Dreamcast so rarely it’s not worth the cash.