How to turn a pile of seemingly unremarkable coins into money?

Coins which are not legal tender, that is. I have been given a big sack of them by a charity and asked to “do something with them”. Obviously they’re things that have been donated or have come out of the till. There are also some medallions, pins, military buttons.

If you want specifics, there are:

145 American coins (I’m in the UK), totalling $10.31, the only slightly interesting one (because it’s the only one in it’s denomination) being a half-dollar.

50 Eurozone coins, totalling 9.92 euros.

In English coins, a 1922 Maundy threepence, 18 decimal ha’pennys, three each of the old five and ten pence pieces, 17p in legal tender, 9 silver jubilee commemorative crowns, 3 1981 Royal Wedding commemorative crowns, 8 sixpences, one pre-decimal penny, one two-shilling coin, two one shilling coins and two half-crowns.

From pre-Euro and extra-Euro Europe:
three dutch guilders, a five-guilder coin and change totaling 59c
36.65 french francs in denominations between 5c and 10f, the five-franc is very pretty
2750 Italian lira, in 50, 100, 200 and 500 denominations
2155 Spanish pesetas
2.49 of whatever they use in Malta, the largest being a 1Lm coin. Lira? Livre?
I think this is 42 drachmae, certain the numbers indicate 42 and the writing is probably Greek. Could be Cyrillic, I’m no expert
1 Deutchemark, and a 10 pfennig piece
6 Austrian schillings
1 Belgian franc
3 marks and four pence from Finnland
50 Hungarian forint
a single penny from “The Bailiwick of Guernsey”
11.85 Danish Krone
13 Norwegian Krone
8.33 Swedish Krone, it would seem the Swedes don’t value durability in their coinage, as they are all horribly tarnished

from outside Europe and the US:
20c from the Seychelles
10 of whatever Zimbabwe was using in 1980
25 coins in three denominations I can’t identify, but which seem to have Angkor Wat on one side and a studious looking young man in glasses on the other
95 Barbadian cents
twenty six and a half South Africa rand
one Australian dollar
two Hong Kong dollars
335 Malaysian sen

Also, two Air Training Corp badges, four Royal Engineers bronze buttons, five bronze buttons in two sizes bearing a bird flying over a crown, one bearing a cannon under a crown, one bearing a Royal-looking coat of arms, a silver button with two pickaxes on it, a badge for the Royal Masonic Institution for Girls, a medallion for the Royal Life Saving Society, a badge for the Siamese Cat Association, a pin commemorating the centenary of the National Union of Mineworkers, two unidentifiable pendants, one a triangular spiral and the other a white circle with a bird, a butterfly knife, a 1970 Esso World Cup collectible token of Peter Shilton, a round metal token bearing the legend “Parking Equipment and Services Ltd”, and finally a medallion bearing the slogan “Sir Francis Burdett, Champion of British Freedom”.

It’s an eclectic pile of stuff, but it’s for charity. I also find myself wondering why so many coins from those particular places. Lots of Polish people around here, but not a single Zloty. Presumably the Australian dollar and Euros will be easy to convert, and probably the American too, but what do I do with an old 10p? Or a rand? Or five different types of Krone (judging by years and design, some of the Swedish and Danish Krone are old, no longer legal tender, models)? Was Zimbabwe still white-ruled in 1980? If so, does that coin have some sort of historical or racist chic that might give it a numismatic value in excess of it’s current face value, which probably about a millionth of an English penny? Will the bank take decimal ha’pennys?

Advice very much needed on all that.

Sell it as a lot on eBay or similar?

Since it’s for charity, maybe you could convince a local bank to waive conversion fees for you and cut you a check* for the actual money?

*cheque, I guess, ya limey.

The American coins are all worth their face value. American currency (coins or bills) never demonetizes. There’s the chance, of course, that some of them might be worth more than face value to a collector, but they’d have to be pretty old for that (the 1930s, maybe), so you probably don’t have any of those. Half-dollars are quite rare in circulation, but they’re still easily available to anyone who wants one, for only slightly more than their face value.

Francis Burdett being a famous aristocratic radical — he married into the Coutts banking family — generally on the right side, but… annoying to all, you might look for some wealthy socialist organization such as the TUC or the Ford Foundation to purchase this memento. The last has $10 billion…

All of the Swedish krona coins are still legal tender, the Swedish öre coins are just scrap unless they happen to be interesting for collectors however.

I’m tempted to make you an offer for some of the assorted coins, as I have a similarly-assorted (but differently-composed) collection of my own.

A few years back, I culled the coins I had doubles of and sold them in small assorted ‘lucky dip’ packs on eBay - I think I made a couple of quid on each bag of 20 or 30 assorted different coins.

Unless you get them appraised to see if you really do have a rare gem in there, that’s probably the way to go - sort them into bags of, say, 30 (with no doubles in any bag) then sell them as lucky dip starter bags for budding coin collectors on eBay.

Put them in a wooden box, call it a treasure chest, and put it on eBay.

I other thing fell out of the bag: a rough metal disc marked “J Rees Bryn Mining Area 8”, with a hole in the middle.

I like this idea, and I think I have enough variety. I have a huge pile of Maltese cents and twenty-five peseta coins with holes in middle. I have 506 coins in total, but 145 of those are US, 50 are Eurozone and the most common of the others is the 18 decimal ha’pennys, so that would make 17 coins a bag without duplicates or more with a few bags have a couple of ha’pennys.

That seems the most likely course of action.

There are four Krona, but horribly blemished. I can only read the date on one of them, which is 1947. There are also three 50 ore coins, five 25s, two 10s, two fives, a 2 and a 1. The four coppers are at least interesting, having just writing and a crown on them. Most coins have a number on one side and a head or an animal on the other. The Australians have a kangaroo on one side (five of them, in fact) and the Queen on the other. The Hungarians have a bird. The South Africans have some sort of horned beast. Hong Kong had the Queen. And so on.

If any of the American dimes, quarter dollar, or half dollar coins are dated pre-1965, they are 90% silver and have value right there. If the half dollar is dated 1965-1970, then it’s 40% silver and that’s still a good amount of silver.

Also if any of the coins are older, say pre-1960, then they may have numismatic value depending on the condition of the coin and things like mint marks.

You could find a coin shop (place that sells coins to collectors), e-mail them your list and ask them if they’d buy the lot from you (aside from the Euros and US coins which I’m guessing you could just deposit at your bank for a small conversion charge).

Have you tried CoinStar?

If any one else wants tempting, I have 73 different denominations of non-Euro, non-US, non-UK coins, some in more than one design.

Or, if anyone hates diversity but would like a pile of a dozen identical maltese one cent coins, that’s fine too.

Most banks won’t change coins with an individual value of less than a dollar or a euro. A large part of the overhead in currency exchange is shipping it to places where there is a demand for that currency and low value coins just aren’t worth it. That’s why airlines collect coins from tourists for charity, since they can transport them themselves.

The half is 1972, but there are two pennies dated 1959 and 1960, and a quarter from 1941. So not a lot, but a little bit.

eBay

The quarter is worth at least $4 US in scrap and probably about twice that to a collector. The other coins are only worth their face value.

Forget eBay - just list the grab-bags here in the Marketplace forum. I’m sure any number of Dopers, myself included, would take a flyer on one.

1947? Should be 40% silver then. Not that I think has much actual relevance for your problem, but it might be nice to know. :slight_smile: