[QUOTE=stpierre]
That seems pretty questionable. Under what circumstances is a system immune, as it were, to evolution? Why wouldn’t natural selection reward those individuals who were minutely better suited to the modern American diet? Admittedly, most of the most visible problems with said diet come after the age of reproduction, but good health is certainly rewarded during the mating process. How could the digestive tract become immune to evolution?
[/QUOTE]
Evolutionary “progress” is dependent upon a fairly consistant environmental impetus that effects some result on reproductive fitness, or more to the point, the ability to successfully propogate genes; that if it grows consistantly colder, a species will change to maintain effective thermoregulation, for instance. In the case of diet, the recent high-carb/low fiber, refined sugar diet with excess calories year round is aberation in human evolution; even (as has already been pointed out) groups who subsist on a largely simple starch-based diet require supplementary proteins and fats, and no amount of evolution is going to make up for the dietary need for essesntial proteins that we can’t synthesize. Despite the negative health impact of the typical American diet, this has little impact on the ability of Americans to reproduce; even persons with poor dietary habits are sufficiently healthy to have children (and undoubtedly pass on their own bad habits). Whatever the evolutionary effect of that may be it’s unlikely to be very quick or directed.
[QUOTE=woodflute]
We have two eyes set carnivore-wise on the front of our head. This is to enable us to judge the distance to our prey.
If we were strictly evolved to be vegetarians, we wouldn’t need hunter’s eyes. After all, it’s not like the plant you wanted to munch on is going to up and run away from you.
[/QUOTE]
I see that we have a Larry Niven fan in company. Unfortunately, Niven’s understanding of evolutionary theory is nearly as simplistic and reductionist as his skill at characterization. Having eyes foreward means nothing in particular with regard to diet; there are plenty of predators with side-mounted eyes, and many vegetarian primate species with eyes forward. Side-mount eyes are certainly useful to herd animals who are ever-wary of predators, but binocular vision isn’t particularly useful for gauging relative distances beyond a few feet. (If you don’t believe me, close one eye and try gauging distances at or beyond arm’s length–you’ll have very little difficulty.) Forward-located eyes, at least in primates, probably have far more to do with the nature of socialization and use of facial “gestures”, as well as manipulative abilty, than eating habits.
The real–and only necessary–test of the evolved dietary standards is what material the digestive tract is developed to process. In bovines, for instance, the long tract and multiple stomachs are designed to break down cellulose. In cats, the short intestinal length indicates the need for a high protein diet. In humans, like other omnivores (pigs, bears) the intermediate length of the digestive system, need for vitamins typically found in fruits, need for fiber, and limited tolerance for high protein diets indicates an omnivorous diet. QED.
Owing to the relatively short timespan of modern human divergence in diet, there is little reason to believe that there are significant differences (aside from minor alterations such as lactose tolerance or dietary pressures in small, isolated, highly inbred populations) between populations in terms of nutritional requirements.
Stranger