[QUOTE=olivesmarch4th]
And you know, I’m all for blasting things that don’t have scientific backing.
That said…
There is plenty of evidence to suggest that violence in the media contributes to aggressive behavior. Lots of scientific studies have been done on this matter, and there are lots of current new ones that have nothing to do with trying to scare people, but instead to learn the truth and rationally address the potential problem that exists.
[Lots of rational arguments and scientific cites snipped]
[/QUOTE]
Yeah, but that’s not how the issue gets addressed in the popular media. They don’t say, “Exposure to violent media can be a contributing cause in increased agression in young children.” They say, “Playing video games will make your teenager blow up his school!”
The problem with media coverage of violence in video games is that it is, a) usually divorced from discussions of violence in the media in general, and is treated as if video games present a unique danger. b) It’s treated as a direct cause of acts of horrific violence. For example, many journalists and pundits tried to create a direct link between the Columbine massacre and Klebold and Harris playing the game Doom, as if absent the video game, they’d have been honor roll students. Popular commentator on video game violence and professional douchebag Jack Thompson refers to video games as “murder simulators,” and has tried to tie MicroSoft Flight Simulator to the World Trade Center attack. And c) video games are presented as a kids-only medium, as if the primary audience for Grand Theft Auto is 6 year olds, as opposed to 18 to 35 year olds.
I agree, there is plenty of room for debate on the harmful effects of violent media on the development of children. But you won’t find that debate on the nightly news, which is the point of this pit thread.
While you’re here, I wanted to ask you a question about the studies your husband is involved in. In those studies, what constitutes a “violent video game?” Are we talking, “Blowing people’s heads off in a gigantic spray of blood and gore,” or are we talking about “Italian plumber jumping up and down on the head of an anthropomorphic mushroom?”