Today I took little black cat Serena to the barn and left her there in a cage. She’s in a vacant stall, with a litter box, food, water, a corrugated scratching pad, and a fabric tunnel she can crawl into to hide in. The floor of the cage has a plastic liner, and I’ve put hay over that. When I left, she was huddled half into the litter box, nothing but her eyes moving.
I feel like a heel. But I’ve reached the end of my rope with her.
It’s the pissing. That, and the hissing. She came to me as a feral rescue kitten, and she’s never really trusted or bonded to me. There’s a sweetly affectionate side to her, but still, two years and more since I adopted her, one wrong move on my part and she’ll hiss with fearful rage and bolt.
She pisses all over the house. When I tried caging her in one room of my house to retrain her, last winter, it seemed to work. She became more affectionate when I was her only company. I eventually released Serena into the general feline population, and the pissing appeared to have stopped.
For a while. Now it’s resumed, worse than ever. I’ve caught her at it, so I know it’s not one of the other seven. There are seven litterboxes, at least one on each floor of my home, that are cleaned daily, so it’s not a Statement About Housekeeping Services.
I’ve talked to the rescue operation I adopted her from, and been told that they would take her back, but given her behavioral problems, she’s probably unadoptable and would have to be euthanized. I tried the caging at home as a last resort, and it’s failed. Now what?
One last option: rehoming as a barn cat. I’m following the procedures that another local feline rescue organization has developed for making barn cats out of otherwise unadoptable rescues. The cats are brought to the barn and kept in large cages, singly or (if already sociable with each other) in twos or threes. The cages go in a vacant stall or other convenient place, where the cats can acclimate to the sounds, smells, and sights of the barn and learn to consider it their home. They stay caged for about a month, then are released.
This system isn’t foolproof. Last summer, the owner of the barn where I board my two horses adopted a dozen barn cat candidates and went through the process faithfully. After their release, about half of them disappeared within a few days. Another two hung around for a while, then vanished. Today we have three still in residence, who started out terrified of humans but are now almost approachable.
So, it’s a crapshoot whether Serena will stick around, or survive at all. At least it’s late May, so the weather is just right for trying this. The stall she’s in is right next to the area where the current barn cats are fed. They’re quite friendly to other cats, and don’t try to drive off strange felines, so she should be accepted by them. My gut feeling is that when she’s finally released she’ll vanish, but hopefully I’ll be proven wrong.
I feel like such a heel, but I also feel like I’ve given her a last chance.

(I would never!)