I pit these obnoxious pseudo-intellectual poets

I attend a large, urban, public high school. It is a generally diversely populated school, but infamous for being extremely cliquish. Anyway, we have a teacher who, a few years ago, took it upon himself to start naming Poets Laureate and Cum Laude. Ever since I’ve been here, these kids have been the most obnoxious, wanna-be political, stuck-up people I’ve ever seen.

So anyway, our school has sports assemblies twice a year, to showcase and honor the participants in that semester’s sports. One of these was last friday. So these poets have somehow whined and moaned their ways into being allowed to perform poems at these assemblies. Now, to be clear, these are COMPLETELY IRRELEVANT poems, have nothing to do with sports or anything at all, it just seems like these people are so desperate to express themselves that they’ll do it at any opportunity. So we all sit politely and listen to the poems, but it’s clear that very few people want to listen to them.

But at this recent assembly two of the poets walked up to the podium and said “Insufferably Pretentious Poet (not his real name) wrote a poem, but the ADMINISTRATION deemed it POLITICALLY CONTROVERSIAL so he was BANNED from performing it” (emphasis theirs). Everyone seemed pretty confused by this, but we all sorta let it go.

The next day, poet-appointing teacher’s quarterly arts paper came out. On the back was a poem, under the heading “deemed ‘politically controversial’”. This was… exactly the type of political poem you would expect a high school student to write. It was long, with poor structure, crappy attempts at rhyming, filled with random references, and the political content was cliched and boring. It was absolutely AWFUL. I can find it and type it up if you guys want. But anyway, so there was this uproar, I thought the whole thing was pretty stupid. It was a crappy poem, and actually was politically controversial, and thus unfit to be performed in front of an unwilling student body assembled for other purposes.

About a week later, after all the crap had died down, the normal student newspaper came out. In it, there was an article, written by a Poet Laureate who was also on the news staff, about the poem, in which the poem was printed. The article read as a scathing criticism of the administration for censoring this poem, as if they were stepping on this kids rights by not allowing him to vomit his contrived political opinions all over an unwilling student body.

These kinds of kids make me so angry. He thinks he’s fighting the power, raging against the machine or whatever. Does anyone else see the BS in what this kid is doing?

I guess this isn’t really a normal pitting, just a strong rant.

I dunno. Seems kind of anti-intellectual to rant about someone getting an opportunity to share an artistic creation, however it comes out, when you have multiple assemblies each term at school to celebrate children who play catch with a ball.

capybara, you underestimate the depths of crappiness to which high-school (and college) poetry can descend.

The horror.
The horror.
The horror envelops me.
It enters my every poor
Fills the synapse of every neuron
Words fail.

The horror.
The high schoolers shut up.

The decimation.
Decimated I am.
Decimated by the horror.

The high schooler is mute
but now so am I.
Tell me who has won.
It’s poetry under a gun.

You get the idea. :slight_smile:

So write a scathing reply to the school newspaper. I don’t know about your school, but at mine the newspaper really hurts for any material at all. Heck, join the newspaper. Sounds like you have a lot of opinions to share.

vinniepaz, I understand some of your objections, but why does being politically controversial make it unfit to be performed?

Welcome to the SDMB!

Oops. Looks like I should have welcomed you a couple of years ago…

Er…You should post more often.

Why don’t you pretend to “enjoy poetry”? That is how I finally got out of that situation once.

[Massive points to anyone else who got out of the same situation that way]

Haha. Thanks for the belated welcome.

It’s unfit to be performed because the whole student body is assembled, to watch a sports assembly, and not to hear political opinions. The school has other venues at which people can perfrom things like this, and people can choose to go there or not. It’s simply an innapropriate venue for expressing his opinions.

Get Dan Schneider to do a review of their poems.

Is the assembly mandatory? If it’s not then yeah, the poem was unnecessary. If it was mandatory, well, that’s another problem with the school system.

The Republicans

A poem

The Republicans
Bad, to the last mans
They wear their knees around their pants
Oughtta call 'em Republicants.

Feel free to send this bit of drivel to your school paper and see what happens.

So what was the poem about?

I like you, vinnie. You’re a man after my own heart. The bad news is that this kind of lame pretention gets even worse in college. The good news is that you won’t be forced to listen to it or you can openly mock them as they spout their crap in the quad.

I kinda like this. I was forced to go to endless assemblies for the various sports teams - I like the idea of inserting a little assembly for the poets (or other creatives) into the mix. Sure, high school poetry sucks donkey ass, but so does high school football. Suck it up, jocks.

And why is a high school assembly an inappropriate place for a “controversial” poem? Can only the official line be spoken over the PA? If there is genuine controversy over an issue, why not let students speak their piece, in poetry or prose? If it’s not a controversial issue, and said student is simply expressing a contrary opinion to show how “out there” he/she is, well, the high school clique wars take care of those people quickly enough.

mischievous

I wish they would.

As a poet myself (yay for iambic pentameter!), I would like to express my wishes to stab this person’s poetry notebook with a fully-loaded fountain pen.

Getting back to the topic at hand, though, I agree that you should say something in the paper. Explain that besides the political controversy and the irrelevancy, THE POEM WAS A PIECE OF CRAP. I’m willing to bet that your administration was just trying to find another way to keep this trash out of the assembly without ruining the Poet Laureate’s precious self-esteem. :rolleyes: Kids just can’t take criticism these days…

OK?

So type the poem up. I want to see it.

I don’t want to hear high school poetry, but I don’t want to attend sports assemblies either.

Of course, I usually didn’t. It was easy to sneak away.

Five minutes, man. Seemed like forever.

Welcome to The Dope!

what!?

what do you mean I’m late? :dubious:

Dude, I was totally that poet in high school, only my poetry was good (no, really, I was published then). I went to a magnet school for the performing arts that was in a larger public high school. Anyway, if I could go back and punch myself in the face, I would.