The collar should be removed to prevent injury. With one of leather or some such, it’s not a very big problem, but it also depends on the breed. My dog is very much aware that he must be nicer to smaller dogs, since he grew up with a little ball of twine that weighs about 4 lbs. However, he weighs 70 lbs and will get even heavier the next six months. If a paw gets caught on the collar, there’s a risk that the smaller dog gets a neck injury, even though it was all friendly play.
With metallic, chain link types, it’s very easy for the other dog to get caught with a tooth and break it.
CrazyCatLady: I’m gonna back up a little and be a bit more clear. Well behaved male dags, properly bred and raised, have a code when fighting. And they do fight, believe me. Especially when they’re at the age my dog is. Puberty is rushing around in the system and they are trying to establish rank within the pack. A dog the age mine is, 14 months, will try to challenge an older male in order to move up the scale. This is normal behaviour, and should be watched, so it doesn’t go to far. But 99% of the time, it’s just play fighting, and when one dog gives up and exposes the neck or chest, it’s over. A sound dog will then back off.
The problem with neutered dogs, the way I see it, is that they’re are grown, but smell like puppies, i.e. sex less. This confuses the other males and can result in a more serious fight.
Mind you, I’m not advocating real dog fights in any way. They’re barbaric and quite a big problem around here, where many (too) young people are geting pit bulls and mixes with pit bulls, because they want a dog to help them gain ‘respect’. A couple of weeks ago, I saw two female pit bulls, around a year old, get into a quite serious fight. The right thing to do, of course, is grab the dog by the neck and pull them apart, firmly telling the dog who’s in charge. But the owners were afraid of their own dogs and kept trying to lash them with the leashes. How in the world are you suppose to have a well behaved dog, if you’re afraid of it?
The rule around here is that it’s always, always, the owner of the female who’s responsible. As you say, it can be hard to control the male dog if a female that smells so invitingly is nearby. By putting the responsibility firmly with the owner of the female, it’s just natural that they keep their dogs away from males. Everyone I know who has a female will walk them in areas where there are no un-leashed males around, when the dog’s in heat.
I know it’s not really my fight and that there’s a huge difference between pet culture in Europe and the US. But we’re fighting ignorance here and by spreading the word how things could be done, maybe life with dogs can become better in the US, with time. It used to be the same way here, in the 50’s.
One important factor is that there are more buyers than dogs, so breeders can be picky about who they are going to sell a puppy to. Prices are high too. A pure bred dog will be hard to find for less than $1.000. All in all, it works towards making both sellers and buyers more responsible.
[/soap box mode]