[QUOTE=even sven]
In many cities there also exists a large *native[/] Spanish speaking populations that have been here since well before any English speakers arrived. Speaking Spanish does not go against American culture, because it is a part of American culture.
[/QUOTE]
True. But it is a matter of degree. If I bought 30 million people here tomorrow from China, I think you wold agree that it would be a shock to our culture. It’s a combination of the number and the time over which they are brought in.
[QUOTE=even sven]
Should we kick them out, too? Or should we recognize that being “Indian” or “Mexican” and “American” isn’t a contridiction.
[/QUOTE]
We shouldn’t kick anyone out who is here legally. Certainly not for how they self-identify. I think that one thing even more sacrosanct than freedom of speech is freedom of thought. I wouldn’t even thow out someone how thinks and professes to hate America. I would wonder why they are here and suggest they leave. But not want to use the force of law to make them leave.
[QUOTE=even sven]
Indeed, in countries with an official language, that language is usually the language of government but not at all the language that people speak at home.
[/QUOTE]
I think that’s a great model for here. And I don’t mind aigns in Spanish or Chinese or any other language. My guess is that it makes sense for those businesses to do so. But when the incidence of those signs reaches some point, it starts to make America look less like America and more like the place represented on the signs. This seems very basic to me. Do you not agree?
[QUOTE=even sven]
This is a mischaracterization of what that was about. Muslims were hoping for recognition of their family law, regarding things like divorce, inheretence, etc. For example, if you were undergoing a divorce you could both choose to have custody, etc. decided according to Islamic law and have the state recognize those decisions. Recognizing the family law of different populations is an ancient and common practice in much of the world.
[/QUOTE]
I do not think it is a mischaracterization. What you described is what the group was petitioning for. The government had to either grant the same privleges to this group that they hasd extended earlier to the Jewish community or disallow any special consideration. I recall reading that the government, seeing that they would paint themselves into a corner down the road concerning Sharia law, took a consistent stance and withdrew special consideration for the Jewish community. I haven’t heard abou this or looked into since it was in the news, so I don’t know where things stand now.
And, if I recall correctly, it was not just family law that was at issue for the Jewish community. They were able to also resolve business disputes in a way that was in line with Jewish law.
[QUOTE=even sven]
As for dengue…well, when we bring our troops back from Iraq, they will have been exposed to a lot of foreign diseases, right? We can’t just bring a mass of potentially disease ridden people right in to the heart of our cities all at once, can we?
[/QUOTE]
Hopefully, for their individual well-beiing and that of the communities they will be returning to, I hope that they are checked. But it’s one thing to catch the flu from your child, it’s another to catch it from someone who breaks into your house and sleeps in your bed.