I’m thinking about a transgendered man (woman --> man) who marries a transgendered woman (man --> woman). It seems to me that however you define each partner’s sex - either pre-op or post-op - it will be a marriage between a man and a woman, thus valid in all states.
I think you’re right. States that do not recognize post-operative gender will recognize it based on birth gender. States that do recognize post-operative gender will recognize it based on post-op gender. Either way, you’ve got one man and one woman.
Y’know, assuming they have a legal license and a legal officiant and all that jazz.
[QUOTE=gonzomax]
They could have some real confused kids.
[/QUOTE]
No, they couldn’t. There would be no equipment with which to make kids. (No uterus, fallopian tubes or functioning ovaries or testes, that is.)
They could adopt kids, of course, but I see no reason why they would be “real confused” about their mother and father. Is there any research showing that kids of post-op transsexuals are “real confused”? (I’m not asking about kids of transsexuals who transition after the kids are born, I will conceed that that could be real confusing.)
[QUOTE=Alex_Dubinsky]
Having gay parents is one thing. But I wouldn’t even dare show my face on the playground if my parents were some weird genitally mutilated trannies.
Shouldn’t the kids get some say in this?
[/QUOTE]
I’m not answering your other assertion, but I’d like to know where kids get a “say” in so-called normal families. What exactly do you mean by say? A say in being adopted?
Hmm. Many kids are so desperate and needy for families & love they wouldn’t care.
When I was a Marine recruiter there was this girl who joined, perfectly normal girl, very good shape, super smart, former ballerina, college-educated, so-on and so-on.
So, she enlisted and was going to go to boot camp soon. Turns out her dad was a former Marine. I asked to meet him, looking forward to meeting a guy who served. So, he comes in…BAM.
A fucking ‘woman’ now. Turns out that Dad realized he was ‘different’ around the time that the girl was 11 or 12. He was post-op and I actually had a long discussion with him about a lot of things. She still called him Dad, well, because…he was Dad to her. But he was/is now a she.
[QUOTE=Alex_Dubinsky]
Having gay parents is one thing. But I wouldn’t even dare show my face on the playground if my parents were some weird genitally mutilated trannies.
[/QUOTE]
Okay, but how about if your parents were normal transexuals?
[QUOTE=Alex_Dubinsky]
Having gay parents is one thing. But I wouldn’t even dare show my face on the playground if my parents were some weird genitally mutilated trannies.
I’d love to hear the household arguments:
"You go right back upstairs and change those clothes, missy! When I was a woman we never dressed like that! Pat, talk to our daughter!
[QUOTE=Alex_Dubinsky]
Having gay parents is one thing. But I wouldn’t even dare show my face on the playground if my parents were some weird genitally mutilated trannies.
Shouldn’t the kids get some say in this?
[/QUOTE]
Wow, that’s awfully hateful.
Oh, look, and it’s not even remotely germane to the discussion.