[QUOTE=athelas]
…why do you care about privacy?
One often hears this question raised, and I have yet to come up with a nice logical explanation for it. Let’s assume that the proposal is to have everyone monitored (visually, let’s say), and that there is absolutely no chance of any information reaching non-government hands (so that nothing that the videos hold will be posted on the internet for all to see). The best arguments I can find against it are
- Everyone’s doing something prosecutable, or has at some point.
- There is no logical reason to oppose this, just an emotional holdover from the times when if an animal was watching you, it probably wanted to eat you.
Any ideas?
[/QUOTE]
The problem is that in the end, the the recordings of your personal life are in the hands of other human beings, and human beings are judgmental, emotional, biased, and cruel.
One might take the route of saying, “Well, what we don’t know won’t hurt us, and since we can’t really tell if NSA workers are having a laugh at your expense, what’s the harm?” However, the issue of human prejudices becomes a problem if someone’s bias, someone’s culturally relative judgment of morals, and someone’s confusion of mores for morals allows an invasion of privacy beyond what is necessary, to ensure the safety of society. Because that’s what we really are talking about, isn’t it? A moral issue/judgment? Do we need someone who holds strict celibacy as a moral absolute passing judgment on a libertine or a “furry?”
Now, one might object to this argument by saying, “Well, that’s why we have standards to follow and well defined laws.” All well and good, but I have two answers to this. First, this goes back to humans being poor judges of character, basing things on emotion and previous bias. Will the Puritan’s criticism of the Fetishist’s behavior lead to an unfair invasion of privacy without any legal precedent? Possibly. And before anyone cries “Slippery Slope Fallacy!” understand that this is a very real possibility, not some distant dystopian future that requires millions of random steps in between.
Second—and this is somewhat related to that Oy! said regarding burden of proof—this is why we have a warrant system, to hold individuals, and the system, accountable to the people it is supposed to be protecting. Now, I think most people understand that we live in troubled times and that, because of the nature of the enemy who threatens us, spying is a necessary tool to stop them. The issue most of us take is with the unwarranted, undocumented, unaccountable spying that seams to be happening. With the warrant system, we are ensured that our law enforcement has provided a reasonable amount of proof to justify the invasion of a citizen’s privacy, and that a separate entity that, ideally, doesn’t have similar vested interest in the possible abuse of the spying system, ratifies this proof. Not only that, but the official documentation with the warrant system means that, in due process of law, citizens have access to the full reasoning behind their privacy invasion, and all parties who are guilty of abusing the system or blatant incompetence that leads to breakdown of due process will be held accountable.
Give us a reason for the spying, write it down, ratify it, and make that information available to the citizens. That’s all we ask. Our entire government is based on checks and balances, with the biggest check of all (if we weren’t so god damn complacent), is that of the approval of the people. What’s wrong with basing our sub-systems on that same principle? What’s so wrong about a system which empowers both the law enforcement agencies to do what is necessary to stop terrorists and the people to ensure that their liberties are maintained and that they system is not abused?