If you could change genders temporarily, which gender would you have sex with?

I doubt - my dear - whether the two experiences are as similar as all that. OTOH, what would I know? I submit that you are better placed to know someone who was, say, a gay man earlier in life and is now a lesbian - I’m sure they must exist - so do you have any hearsay to share with us?

My perception of sex between two women is that it’s vastly different than between two men… but it’s not a perception based on any first-hand experience or even any testimony, so I freely admit I’m in no position to say. Still, with due respect for all lesbians who correctly observe that their sex life is not intended to provide titillation for straight men, I admit that granted the sex-change, I’d be very curious to find out. (Though it’s going to be no blot on my personal landscape if it never happens.)

Don’t need any hearsay—there are two such ladies right here on the SDMB. I imagine they are studiously avoiding this thread and banging their heads against the wall, though.

I don’t understand what all the problem is with this thread. He’s only asking what would you do given the situation not whether it would change your sexual orientation or who you’re naturally attracted to.

Being a heterosexual female, if woke up one day as a man I would choose to have sex with a woman - even though I probably wouldn’t be as attracted to her as to a man. I’ve always been curious about the sensations a man experiences when having sex with a woman.

Having sex with a woman now only tells me what it feels like for two women to be together and I’m not curious about men havng sex with men (although if I stayed a man long enough I’m sure I’d find out.)

Even if I were changed into a female, I don’t think I could bring myself to have sex with a man. Too weird.

Honestly, I think the first thing I would do would be to go out and buy a vibrator… (cheating, I know)

(Straight man here)

Umm… how about a woman with a strap-on? :smiley:

Seriously, if I could get together with a woman and we both switched, so that she became a he and I became a she, I wouldn’t have any problem having sex with her/him.

Sorry I have to disagree with you, Eve, but I don’t think a person’s preference would necessarily stay the same. If I woke up tomorrow with the other type of plumbing I’m not sure who I’d find myself attracted to. I identify as a straight person, which at the moment just happens to agree with my biological attraction to women. Probably as a woman I’d try 'em both and then be in a position to give a qualified opinion.

Thank God somebody gets it. This is really about curiousity (and courage), not sexual orientation. I think most people would learn a lot about the sensations and perspective of the other gender, and it could benefit the sexual experiences that one engaged in when one “turned back”.

Art

It’s the references to courage and putting learning ahead of personal pleasure only in the context of switching genders that I don’t get. Maybe the idea of changing gender helps remove the stigma of homosexuality for you, but if you advocate bravery for the sake of learning, you can learn just as much about how a woman feels giving head from giving a guy a blowjob as a guy than as a woman. Mouths are mouths. Penises are penises.

Pretty much, I’d either have sex with my boyfriend, or I wouldn’t have sex at all. Since I’m pretty sure he wouldn’t want to have sex with a guy–and we’ve had this exact discussion, actually–I’m pretty sure I’d be going the high and dry route.

That being said, if I weren’t with my fiance and I found myself temporarily in a guy’s body, I’d likely do what my natural inclinations tell me, and have a relationship/sex with whoever struck my fancy, whether they be male or female. I might be more likely to hook up with a female than I am now, though, simply because I’d have easier access to more of them. But I’d still come down mostly on the side of guys. Women are insane.

You know, I was beginning to think that people were starting to understand the difference between “gay” and “transsexual,” that “what you are” and “who you’re attracted to” are two different matters. That the concept of a post-op woman maybe being a well-adjusted lesbian, or a post-op man being a well-adjusted gay man, would no longer make people scratch their heads and say, “well, why did you bother changing?” That people didn’t think transsexuals were just “gay people who went too far.”

Guess I was too optimistic. There will always be people who will just never get a clue.

Hey, by the way–if you woke up tomorrow with dark skin, would you start drinking malt liquor and playin’ basketball? Betcha would–it’s the skin, ya know.

I dunno if this is what you’re meaning or not but:

I don’t see where waking up tomorrow with no boobs and a penis would change my already maladjusted self so that I would CRAVE the companionship of females. If I wrote up a list of people I consider friends there’d be maybe four women, one of which is my sis, and about 15 guys! I like guys… and with a penis I’d still like guys. Just like them in a different way… Lord I’d be the most handed around boy toy at the air base here! :o

I’d just whack off alot (and other stuff too) to learn what being a woman is really like so i can be a better man once i change back. :slight_smile:

I’m not sure where you’re coming from, Eve. A lot of people here have said, “If I changed bodies that wouldn’t change who I’m attracted to. I might try it but I wouldn’t be too excited about it.” Is that not keeping the notions of physical body and sexual identity separate?

You seem to be expecting a different kind of answer here. Or have I misread you?

Is this in response to me? :confused: I hope I did not say anything offensive. :frowning:

Originally Posted by NurseCarmen

Posted by Eve

Is that an intentional non-sequitur, Eve? Seems to have nothing to do with NurseCarmen’s little joke.

I once repeated the same old joke, and wasted time apologizing to a dogpile of people, gay and otherwise, who showed an absurd level of outrage. So I’ll reiterate: I also sometimes feel like a lesbian trapped in a man’s body. That’s both an old joke, and a valid insight. If that offends you, I’m sorry, and kindly fuck off.

As for the OP – as noted elsewhere by Eve:

Excellent point. If I wanted to have sex with a man, I’d go ahead and do so now (well, as soon as I could find one suitable). So if I could switch genders, I’d still want to be with a woman.

Or at least that’s the theory. If we really could magically become the opposite sex (“we” meaning people who have a pretty stable perception of their own gender), who knows what new feelings would be coursing through us? Exciting idea.

Obviously I’m the only one who is tired of these threads. Like it’s such a novel concept that nobody has ever thought about before.

Uh, Eve, I was straight before I transitioned (and, of course, I’m a lesbian now). That leaves at most one that I know of. Did someone come out and I missed it?

As for NurseCarmen’s lame joke: Bah. Not worth the effort. They never listen anyway.

Finally, responding to the OP: Changing one’s gender would change who one is in such a fundamental way that I think it’s impossible to answer the question. Changing sex, on the other hand, isn’t that hard (although it’s somewhat easier to go from male to female than the other way around), although timeconsuming, painful, and expensive. Please use the right terms next time, and remember: sex is not the same as gender.

Now, if we talk sex: I never had any significant attraction to men, before or after I grew breasts. Of course, I’m not quite done yet, and there is a possibility that once I have a vulva of my own, I’ll find some mysterious attraction for men that so far has been absent from my life. But I wouldn’t bet the farm on it.

KellyM: You’re tired of these threads and you post in them?

Funny…

Me? I’d go down to the Office and screw Choo-choo’s brains out. Or he’d screw mine out, one way or the other…

For the same reason that people gawk at train wrecks, I suppose.

That, and there is still the lingering hope that someone will actually Get It.

And besides, Eve posted here, and I rather owe her the solidarity.

To clarify: are you saying that a person’s sex is superficial, anatomical, whereas gender is more a state of mind? Just trying to be sure I understand.

Perhaps what the OP is trying to say is, if a genie granted somebody the option to temporarily change from a man to a woman or a woman to a man. In that case, I agree that it would change the person in a fundamental way. I can honestly say that I do not know how I would orient in such a situation.

However it is a fascinating topic, especially for those of us who have arrived on this board relatively recently and have not had a chance to participate on very many of these types of threads.

No disrespect to actual TGIs is intended, at least not by me. On the other hand, let’s not stifle honest debate, even if it is pure blue-sky fantasy. The terms of the question in the OP suppose that I could, were it offered, change sex for a day. (Arguing over the terms “gender” and “sex” doesn’t help, of course. Once upon a time we knew pretty well what was meant by the “Sex” question on an application form and we knew what “changing sex” meant. Don’t blame me for the confusion.)

Now I’m assuming for the purpose of the answer that my entire anatomy is changing but the essential Malacandra personality doesn’t alter a flicker. Although I’m not sexually attracted to men, I’d be curious to experience the female end of heterosexual intercourse - a curiosity which cannot be satisfied merely by going out in my real live male body and finding a man to have sex with. But I’d be even more curious to find out what lesbian sex actually feels like. Obviously my knowledge of lesbian sex is highly limited. It’s perfectly possibly that the fantasy that so fascinates me does not exist in actuality. Still, presupposing that I could change sex just for the asking, with a guaranteed return ticket at my disposal, I’d be more than intrigued enough to find out.

Obviously this is so far removed from the actual motivations of those who truly wish to transition in the non-fantasy world as not to be remotely on the same page of human experience. I would be curious to experience sex as a woman, but I’m under no delusion that I actually am one. Those who wish for gender reassignment (see, there we go again. Now “gender” is what can be corrected by surgical intervention. Sorry, I can’t keep the terms straight) are not, I dare say while arguing from ignorance, motivated by anything so trivial as curiosity.

Perhaps the world is waiting for technology as advanced as in the sf writing of John Varley. I’ve not read “The Ophiuchi Hotline” but in his short-story collection “In the Hall of the Martian Kings” he depicted a future in which one could “Change” pretty much on a whim. There weren’t any specifics on how this worked exactly - maybe by cloning, as the individual seemed to acquire a completely new body; a woman was appreciably smaller and weaker than her male equivalent. But given the capability, I imagine there would be no real distinction between Changing just to have fun playing with the opposite-sex body for a while, or Changing to correct a perceived personality/physique mismatch. Indeed, given the ability to Change as often as desired, I suspect that gender identity would go the way of the dodo pretty quickly. No mismatch, no trauma, just be what you want to be and switch over when you want to walk the other side of the street for a change.

Short of “a technological solution so advanced that it defies rational explanation to our 21st-century comprehension” (the word “magic” would get the idea across more briefly), I don’t see it ever being an issue, though, and in the meantime, acting as if I’d changed sex, absent the actual different pudenda, ain’t going to hit the spot, at least not for me.

All clear and free of offence to everyone?

Well, yeah, except if the thought of sex with a man is icky to you now, it will be no less icky to you just because you suddenly have a vagina.