I'm being tormented by a mouse.

I have a mouse. No, not a pet mouse, a city mouse who has moved into my apartment.

I have multiple live-catch traps set but he refuses to go into any of them. They’re full of peanut butter, cheese, cheerios, chips, crackers, carrots and raisins and seeds. He’s not afraid of me anymore and will sit and stare at me from 5 feet away. I say “Mouse! Get in the damn traps!” but he won’t listen. He has a crooked tail and if I snap my fingers at him, he twitches his tail like he’s mad.

When I go to bed at night I lay awake hoping to hear the sound of a trap door snapping shut. If I wake up to use the washroom I peek down the hall to see if he’s caught. The first thing I do when I get up in the morning or come home from work is look to see if I’ve won. I’m constantly turning to look at the area he hangs out to see if he’s there.

This has been going on for two weeks.

Any suggestions? Maybe something that mice just can’t resist?

Maybe he’s claustrophobic and fears live traps.

Time to escalate to the old-fashioned kind. snap

The plastic ones are reusable and pose less of a risk of a painful finger injury. I have found that peanut butter works best.

This reminds me to clean and reset traps in the basement. The onset of cold weather is a cue for rodents to invade.

A mouse thread and no pictures?
taps foot impatiently

I emailed you a picture of the interloper! Feel free to post a link to it, if you want.

Cute!

No close-ups? :smiley:

He’s getting food from somewhere. You need to find the source and eliminate that before mousie will go for food in traps.

He’s getting food from under my budgie cage. I vacuum every day and have spill catchers on the cage but there’s always a stray seed or two under there. But I’d think that, even though he has some seeds, he’d love some peanut butter and cheerios!

Darn mouse!

Have you tried one those sticky paper trap?

These things worked for me.

I once caught 5 mice in a single trap.

Yeah…I’d rather not torture small animals. If it got to a point where I was worried about it, I’d use a trap that would kill it instantly. For now I’m going to continue with the live traps and see if he won’t give the treats a try.

I have never tried a ‘humane’ trap for something I wanted dead.

Call me hard-hearted. My cat would disagree.

When the snap traps didn’t work, I deployed glue blocks on known runs.

Nailed it within 2 days.

I did use ‘natural’ disposal - I tossed the trap and its victim into the over-grown lawn for the local predators.
Cycle of life and all that.

Have you tried looking up success rates for live vs. kill traps? My guess is that the critter would avoid things it can’t walk over.

My sister used to work in a mouse/rat lab. She told me that they would train the rodents by getting them hooked on Froot Loops, which the rats found irresistibly addictive. I tried it with my year-long vermin infestation (thanks to being cat-less for the 1st time in 30+ years) and it worked! I scattered the cereal around so that the rats would get hooked, also put some in traps along their pathways, and, bam! Have caught 7 rats so far with the Froot Loops.

I also tried some rodent attractant from the hardware store. I caught a couple of rats, but they quickly lost interest. Froot Loops worked much better!

Two tips:

Use Nutella to bait the traps. I think they like that better than cheese or peanut butter. I’ve never failed to catch a mouse with Nutella. One exceptionally smart mouse eluded me for about three days. Usually it only takes a day or two.

Put the traps in paths where the mice are going to go. Usually that’s around the edges of the room and in corners. If you’ve seen the mouse, you know where it hangs out, so use that to figure out where you can put the trap so it will walk through it.

One more tip: When you’re using the live traps, don’t let the mice go right outside your house. They’ll come right back in. Take them further away before you let them out.

Good luck!

Oh, yeah, if you can borrow a cat from someone, that might help. If you already have cats, they’re not doing a very good job. :wink: [URL=“http://boards.straightdope.com//www.pinterest.com/pin/create/extension/”]

Ok I’ll try fruitloops and nutella - thanks!!

I don’t have a cat but I have been shaming the budgies for not being birds of prey. I’m going to take him to a big field area a couple of blocks away. I haven’t seen him tonight which is odd. He’s always here in the evening so maybe he found his way out, or he might be visiting other apartments, too, and they might not be as soft-hearted as I am.

Don’t let it drive you TOO insane. It didn’t end too well for the guy in this documentary.

Get a cat.

I had an issue with mice a few years ago. Some things that I have noticed:
While I appreciate the idea behind live traps, I have found the traditional traps more effective. They can often work within minutes.

Peanut Butter is the best bait but you have to be careful to not put too much on. Very little will do. Too much and the trap will snap while the mouse is far enough away to not get trapped and then he will just finish off the bait. This is bad (see below).

Put the trap in an open space, not against a wall. Look where the mouse poops and put the trap there. That is a place he will go. For me, under the sink would always work.

If the mouse gets the bait but not the trap I think it either makes them crazy due to the sugar or makes them think you are feeding them because when that happened to me the mouse became more “aggressive”. He would start to come out in the open, during the day and be less afraid. It was very gross.

Good hunting :slight_smile:

I had a mouse guest poop on my pillow while I was out of town.

Thermite works.

These. You are at a disadvantage living in an apartment - if you share walls with neighbors you can make sure mice don’t have access to a single crumb of food in your space (and you do need to do that; make your own space as unattractive to them as possible) but you can’t control anyone else’s.

That said, you can continue to try putting the traps in the places where mice like to travel. They do tend to be curious - I’ve caught mice using no bait at all just by putting the traps in the places they like to go, and they can’t resist checking the trap out. We have better control of our space, though, since it’s a detached house and we can make sure they don’t have access to any food anywhere inside. We use these traps, and they’ve worked very well for us (here’s proof) - mice like to try coming inside at this time of year, when the weather starts to cool off and natural food sources get scarce.

If you succeed in catching any, you will need to take them at least a mile away, or they’ll just come back.

You
must
try
the
whole
cause
and
condemn
them
to
death.

My tips (based on years of apartment living): Gummi bears, gumdrops or other sticky candy for bait. Mice like sweets, and a sticky sweet will detain them at the trap.

Place the traps over the mouse’s travel routes. Find the routes by looking for mouse poop and pee, since they excrete wherever they go. Mice don’t like crossing open spaces, so they’ll chose routes along walls, alongside furniture, any route that lets them keep against a solid body (they’re thigmotaxic, if you want the technical term). Best is to find a bottleneck, e.g. between furniture and the wall, and place the trap right across it.

You can also consider poison bait, though they usually result in the mouse dying somewhere inaccessible and stinking out your home as it decays, by way of posthumous revenge.

Cats only work if they’re good at mousing; not all cats are.