I had the Sapphire Reserve for quite a while, and just downgraded to the Preferred a few days ago due to the “nerfs” LSLGuy mentioned.
The Reserve was quite the amazing card if you were responsible with your spending and could pay it off every month (otherwise the 30% APR will far surpass any benefits you get from it). But with it, you got not only airport lounges (crowded though they were), but free food at some airport restaurants for you and a guest, TSA Global Entry and Precheck paid for, free Dashpass and Lyft Pink, primary rental car insurance, travel insurance, accident insurance, luggage insurance, up to 10x points in some categories/merchants and 50% back some redemptions, and numerous other smaller benefits that in the aggregate made the moderately high annual fee worth it if you were careful.
But that was a loss-leader for Chase as they were trying to expand their card offerings to a new generation of middle-class tech money. The Reserve was so successful that other banks tried to copy its success. But then they started steadily enshittifying, losing perks here and there, decreasing redemption values, etc. Fast forward to 2025 and Chase repositions the Reserve not for the middle-class but for the White Lotus wealthy, with perks aimed at fancy luxury travelers who spend thousands instead of hundreds per night and who dine at famous restaurants, not neighborhood joints. The annual fee doubled accordingly. Too bad.
The Preferred, by contrast, is really not anything too special. It’s a basic travel card similar to the ones you can get at any major bank. It has a $95 annual fee and not many benefits — rental insurance, some travel coverage (but minimal compared to the Reserve), free Dashpass (which isn’t that great), etc. You also get a $50 credit a year to spend on hotels, plus more points accrued, if you book travel through Chase Travel. But Chase Travel sucks. It’s basically a white-labeled Expedia with fewer guarantees about reservations and shitty cancellations. Hotels treat you as a second-class citizen when you book through online travel agents like that. Chase Travel customer service isn’t good, the UI is slow, the offerings are lackluster, the ads are numerous. In general it’s just not a good way to book travel.
I only kept mine because I wanted to keep my credit line with Chase open and was too lazy to research their other options that had primary rental car insurance coverage. But for $100/year, you can probably find cards better aligned to your specific lifestyle or region, like an airline card that would give you free flights or luggage on a certain airline. The Preferred is just this kind of bland, mediocre middle-ground card that doesn’t do anything particularly well, but it’s hard to justify the $100 a year for its lackluster benefits. It’s a pretty different situation from the old Reserve (or even the new one), where you DO have a lot of options for accruing and spending points and maximizing value if your card fits your lifestyle. With the Preferred, you don’t really have as much “agency” because it’s such a simple card.
Anyway, since you have it already, try to get the welcome bonus (spend $5k to get 75k points). If you can organically charge $5k to it within the time limit, do that. Otherwise, you can consider paying your rent/mortgage on it (either through your landlord if they have a service that allows that, or sometimes through a third party rent payment processor), or you can Venmo it to a friend for a fee — just do the math and make sure the fee doesn’t surpass what you’d get back from the points. This is called “manufactured spend” and you can game the system this way if you really want to. See the subreddit r/churning index - churning for discussions on that and similar credit card gaming strategies.
Beyond that, it’s basically just a matter of booking travel on Chase Travel (if you can stand it — I can’t) to get the 5x points and taking advantage of Dashpass if you use it. If those benefits aren’t worth it to you, consider switching to another card. If you stay within Chase, they can side-grade you to any other card you qualify for and keep your existing credit line. Or you can reapply at another bank, but best to wait a few months or a year or so between cards — don’t open too many at once, because that looks bad for a while on your credit report.
https://thepointsguy.com/ is a website that discusses all of these things and is generally a good resource, they though are also affiliated with many of the cards, so they’re not impartial the way that Consumer Reports is. Still, it’s a generally useful service.
The most important thing is to make sure you’re not keeping a balance on the credit card, but paying it off in full every month. If you’re not able to do that, the rewards don’t matter at all — the interest will FAR surpass them — and you should be looking at refinancing your debt with something lower interest than worrying about points.