I’m barely methodist, and I know it. It’s right up there with “Amazing Grace,” IMO.
I have heard it more times than I want to.
I am more or less an athiest, and the only times I have heard that Hymm, has been at funerals for friends or loved ones I have attended.
So I don’t have great emotional associations with it, despite the hope and joy it supposedly represents for believers.
Regards
FML
Catholic. I’m vaguely aware of the song, maybe from movies, but I’ve never heard it in church or played fully. I’m in Tennessee - did Elvis maybe record it? That might be what I’ve heard.
StG
It was my mom’s favorite hymn, too. It was performed at her funeral back in 1976 (Southern Baptist)
VCNJ~
So far this thread has answered my OP question thus: The hymn is known by most people except for Catholics and atheists. The musician I mentioned is perhaps the anomaly, having been an Episcopalian (I was one of the pallbearers at her funeral) since Episcopalian seems to me to be Catholic without the authority of the Pope.
I play the electronic keyboard. I have the song set up to play on it but I never play it–every time I try I break down and cry because of the memory of my Dad. 
Brought up Catholic…I’ve heard it and played it many times, just not in the Catholic church*
- I was a church organist-for-hire and played in a bluegrass band.
Well, I am one atheist who has heard of it. 
I used to be in the International Order of the Rainbow for Girls when I was a teenager, and “In The Garden” was one of the hymns we sang during one of our major ceremonies.
Attended Christian & Missionary Alliance as a kid, Assembly of God for the past 20+ years- very popular in both.
I’m a keyboard person myself! I should have known that when I met you!
Yes, In the Garden is one of the hymns I grew up knowing. I was brought up in the Cumberland Presbyterian Church.
I’m Catholic, and have never heard it in a Catholic Church. But my ex-wife was a Church of Christ girl from South Texas, and I heard the song regularly at her church (a capella, of course, since Church of Christ members frown on musical instruments in church).
I’ve never heard it. I was brought up Catholic, and it’s never been played in any Catholic Church I’ve been in (but then, Catholics rarely if ever play Protestant hymns).
I’ve since been to lots of church services from many branches, Baptist included, and I don’t recall ever hearing that one.
My father was brought up Catholic, which I never learned until after he’d died. He joined the Disciples of Christ about the time I was born. He often hummed the tune. I don’t know if he learned it there or knew it all along. He loved it.
Here’s Elvis’s version if anyone is interested.
This has been one of my favourite hymns since I was a kid. I grew up Presbyterian/non-denominational Christian, and we sang it reasonably often. I’ve been LDS for years now, and I don’t think I’ve ever heard it sung in church. Haven’t been to many LDS funerals.
Now I’ve been singing this to myself since yesterday. It feels like I’ve been to our local Hobby Lobby where they play muzaked hymns on their speakers, which leaves me humming stuff like *How Great Thou Art *for the rest of the day.
Huh. That is so weird. I know almost every hymn listed on that set (I don’t have the CDs), but I’ve never heard this one. I guess it’s sort of geographical. I might need to take a survey of my friends now.
I grew up 7th Day Adventist (kissing cousins of Baptists, so I guess I probably don’t qualify for the OP’s criteria) and it was a favorite when I attended church.
It’s also the source of a bad joke that used to amuse me greatly:
“I know what God’s name is.”
“Really? What is it?”
“Andy!”
“Andy walks with me, Andy talks with me…” (singing, of course)
Yeah, a bad joke, but I laughed the first time.
Half catholic, half jewish, raised out of church, and I’ve heard it a bunch of times. I think I have a copy of Elvis singing it somewhere. I’ve got a lot of Elvis on vinyl.
Nor in LDS services in Wyoming, New York or Ohio.
The only reason I know the song is because it is a standard in my dad’s 1950’s and 60’s country gospel album collections.
Is it Andy that owns Gladly, The Cross Eyed Bear? 
VCNJ~