I bought **Rhiannon8404 **an mp3 player for Christmas last year. I did quite a bit of research before making the purchase. I found out far more then I ever thought I needed to know about portable audio players. In the end I purchased a Rio Forge 512 MB .
Here’s why…
Flash memory instead of hard drive:
Hard drive based players have considerably more storage space than flash based players. They hold anywhere from 5 GB to 60 GB, maybe more now. Flash players are typically in the <1 GB range, although the iPod nano will hold up to 4 GB.
The downside to hard drive players is that they contain moving parts with very small tolerances for error. Give it a good jolt, and your music can skip; drop one on the floor, and you might trash the drive. Flash players have no moving parts; as long as you don’t crack the case, they’re pretty much indestructible.
My wife spends a lot of time working with horses, where her player would tend to get bumped around a lot, and where there is quite a bit of dust and dirt to foul up a hard drive. A flash based player is ideal for her because she doesn’t need to worry too much about damaging it.
Replaceable batteries:
Most mp3 players have a rechargeable internal (non-removable) battery. They should last several years, but when the battery dies, so does the player. Apple will replace your iPod battery for about $60, I believe.
There are a few players with replaceable batteries, like you have in a cell phone. That way you can buy an extra battery, swap them out when they run down, and always have a full battery ready.
TheForge runs on a single AAA battery (possible only because it is a flash-based player; a hard drive would suck up too much juice). It runs for 6-8 hours on a single battery. The downside is that you need to keep buying more batteries; if you are going to use your player all day long every day, it could get expensive. But for **Rhiannon **that isn’t an issue, because she doesn’t use it *that *frequently. She went on a two week trip to Italy last year, and took the player and a handful of AAA batteries with her to run it. This way she didn’t have to worry about taking a power adapter, finding a place to recharge the player, etc. When the battery ran down, she just popped another one in and moved on.
SD Memory expansion:
The Forge was one of the few players I found that has an SD memory slot. Although the player only comes with 512 MB internal memory, I bought a 1 GB SD card to go along with it. With additional cards, you can have virtually unlimited storage. Of course, it winds up being more expensive than buying a 40 GB player, but you don’t sacrifice the other advantages mentioned above.
A few questions you should ask yourself before you buy:
How much music do I want to carry with me?
A 512 MB player will hold 8-16 hours of music. A 40 GB player will hold enough for you to listen for a month without repeating a song. How much storage do you need? Do you want to carry your entire music collection with you, or do you just want to have enough to listen to for a few hours while you do whatever you do? Do you have a few albums (10-15) that you listen to all the time, or do you want to listen to something new every day? If the latter, do you mind spending the time to “reload” your player with new music from time to time?
What will I be doing while I am using my player?
If you will sit it on your desk at work or school all day, where it will not be subject to excess vibration or rough treatment, then a hard drive based player might be the best for you. If you plan to use it while working out or doing manual labor, then go for a flash based player (flash players are also smaller and lighter, which helps when you are wearing them).
What kind of music do I listen to (file formats)?
If your music is all in mp3 or Windows Media format, you can choose almost any player and be assured of compatability. If you are an Audible subscriber, or have a bunch of OGG files, then your choices are a bit more limited. If all of your music is currently on CD, then it doesn’t matter, because you can rip them to whichever format you need.
What “advanced” features do I want?
Other things that mp3 players can do, depending on which model you get:
FM radio receiver
data file storage and transfer
photo storage and viewing
probably a bunch of other stuff I can’t think of right now
If you just want to listen to music, then again, you can choose any player. If some of these other features interest you, then you need to pick and choose from those models which suit your needs.
http://www.mp3.com/ has a great deal of information on mp3 players: reviews, compataility with different formats, etc.
In the end, it all comes down to personal preference and need. There are quite a few very good players on the market, and there are no compelling reasons to choose one particular model or brand over all of the others. A player that is perfect for me might be the worst choice for you. Do your research, and pick the one that suits you best, and don’t be overly influenced by what is “popular”. The iPods get the most press, but that is mainly because they have the best marketing. They are not necessarily better than everything else. They are not necessarily worse either; if they weren’t quality players they would not still be selling the way they are.
Good luck, and happy listening!