Is "Fresh Salt Water Taffy" a fake?

You could just pay a hit man; but no, you have to do it yourself.

Re: taffy pulling.

When I was a kid, we once decided to do homemade taffy. We took turns pulling. It came out fine.

But emphasis on the “once”. Yet another time when being in a large family helped.

What I remember from the shops with machines in the windows at the beach when I was a kid was that they really did use the taffy off the machines. Getting a “fresh batch” was considered a plus.

In fact, the difference between taffy and plastic is merely one molecule!

Taffy is made of margarine!