I don’t know the exact date, but it was well before the income tax was constitutional. In fact, the main rationale behind the estate tax was that the government had little other way to tap into accumulated wealth.
Wholly different today. What with income taxes, corporate taxes, capital gains taxes; the goverment has several other ways of getting its share. In my opinion, the estate tax is an artifact whose time has come and gone.
for danielandthewolvesden; I did not mean to imply that family members were “working in the fileds” like migrant workers or something. Truthfully, they would most likely be managers. But this still doesn’t prevent them from contributing heavily to the family business/farm. In the case of a farm, the land plus a few pieces of heavy machinery will likely put an estate over the estate tax threshhold, with or without cash reserves on hand. (Then, often as not, the land is sold and subdivided for cash. Development ensues. From a conservation standpoint, the best thing to do is repeal the estate tax so this doesn’t have to happen so much.)
I agree that there are things one can do to find loopholes in the estate tax. Creating corporations or trusts or something. But why should one have to spend big $$$ to pay accountants and lawyers to do this? I can imagine a complex estate situation could cost well over $10,000 in administrative fees just to avoid the estate tax. Then what do you have? The government doesn’t get the money–a big chunk goes to the lawyers!
I still say that the rightful heir of an estate is the family, not the government. Of course, if the deceased didn’t want the kids to have the money; well, the will could certainly reflect that.
For those of you who are so vituperative against the rich and accumulated family wealth: Well, all I can say is that this class envy gets rather tiresome. Who cares if some other family is wealthy? What do I care if someone inherits gobs of money? It’s no skin off my nose. Good for them. I certainly don’t sit around begrudging their fortune.
It’s like a joke I read just recently. Two Russian farmers live side by side. Nikolas was rather poor, but Ivan was fortunate enough to have a goat. Well, one day, Nikolas came across a genie who offered him one wish. He thought long and hard, especially about Ivan’s good fortune. He then presented his wish:
“I wish that Ivan’s goat would die.”
That’s what I perceive with many of the attitudes shown here (and elsewhere). “It’s not fair that someone else has more,” or “They didn’t have to work hard for what they have.” Therefore, take away what they have. Ugh.