[QUOTE=BrainGlutton]
Well, to be fair, it provides for removal if the president is “unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office” at all, not competently. At least, that’s how I read it. I.e., the prez would have to be clinically insane or non-communicative or comatose for that clause to apply. Just being an America-destroying dumbass doesn’t rise to that level.
[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=xtisme]
As for the OP…give it up already guys. The odds of it happening in the time he has left are vanishingly small at this point.
[/QUOTE]
OTOH, in Al Franken’s The Truth (with jokes) he envisioned a newly elected Dem Congress in 2008 impeaching W, who has only a couple months left in his term, just because they can!
[QUOTE=Airman Doors, USAF]
The 25th Amendment allows for removal due to incompetence:
There’s literally no chance of that happening, and it would not be within the bounds of the intent of the drafters of the amendment to remove the President because he’s a moron, but this amendment as written provides for a means for it to happen without impeachment.
[/QUOTE]
Very true. The OP asked about “impeachment” and not “removal,” but I think it’s fair to say that he would be fine with your scenario.
And I love the 25th: it made for a great subplot in Air Force One.
[QUOTE=BrainGlutton]
Don’t speak of that as if it ran against the democratic principle. Many state constitutions provide for recall elections.
[/quote]
A recall is a democratic act. What the OP is proposing is not.
You know, BG, you’ve proposed some nutty ideas here before that one takes the cake. Presidential elections are often razor thin these days, and a recall amendment would guarantee that every president would face, and often lose, a recall. We could very well have a new president every year.
[QUOTE=John Mace]
Presidential elections are often razor thin these days, and a recall amendment would guarantee that every president would face, and often lose, a recall. We could very well have a new president every year.
[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=John Mace]
A motion of confidence in a parliamentary system is not the same a recall.
[/QUOTE]
Indeed. A motion of confidence can be dealt with in about a hour of debate in Parliament, if the house decides to limit debate to the mover of the motion and to the Prime Minister (or whichever other minister is defending the government). That costs a lot less that a recall ballot in which all the voters take part.
I don’t like the idea of the Electoral College, but given that the President is choen by it, a recall process would have to go like this:
(1) A recall wold be initiated by a petition signed by a majority of the Electoral College.
(2) When such a petitioon was received, the EC would reconvene, and ballot again for President and VP.
(3) If no candidate received a majority of votes, the Presient and VP would continue in office. (This is to deal with the situation of a third party having the balance of power in the EC).
(4) If a different candidate received a majority, then he/she would immediately replace the exiting President or VP.
You might also have to set up a process for replacing Electors who die during the 4-year term.
[QUOTE=BrainGlutton]
No, it isn’t. A recall is much, much harder to win. Therefore, less to be feared.
[/QUOTE]
You can’t know that in advance since we’ve had neither at the federal level in the US.
But even if it were true, a recall would just exacerbate the divisiveness in the country, and every president would be permanently campaigning as a primary function, not just as a secondary effort as it’s done now.
[QUOTE=John Mace]
But even if it were true, a recall would just exacerbate the divisiveness in the country, and every president would be permanently campaigning as a primary function, not just as a secondary effort as it’s done now.
[/QUOTE]
That does not seem to have happened (WRT governors) in states where the recall is an option. At least, Ahnold does not seem to govern as if he is permanently on campaign, AFAIK, or even as if he gives a shit about what anybody else thinks.
[QUOTE=BrainGlutton]
That does not seem to have happened (WRT governors) in states where the recall is an option. At least, Ahnold does not seem to govern as if he is permanently on campaign, AFAIK, or even as if he gives a shit about what anybody else thinks.
[/QUOTE]
National, presidential politics is much more contentious, and the country as a whole s more deeply divided.
Personally, I’d like to see Bush ridden out of D.C. on a rail… but then we’d have to get rid of Cheney and everyone else who encourages Bush to behave the way he does. That’s a lot of rails.
However, it ain’t gonna happen.
I do have a question, however… if Bush had been exactly the way he is, but Democrat, how long would he have lasted in office? I’m betting he would’ve been kicked out a few months after 9/11. I think he gets way too much leeway just because he’s Republican.
[QUOTE=Airman Doors, USAF]
The 25th Amendment allows for removal due to incompetence:
There’s literally no chance of that happening, and it would not be within the bounds of the intent of the drafters of the amendment to remove the President because he’s a moron, but this amendment as written provides for a means for it to happen without impeachment.
[/QUOTE]
As wonderful as that sounds, even someone who despises Bush as much as I can’t buy it. As incompetent as Bush is, I see nothing that makes him unable to perform the duties of his office. He can perform them, he just makes boneheaded decisions.
There is already a means to deal with dunderhead presidents- it’s the midterm election. Elect enough Democrats and that will clip his wings enough to keep any more real damage from happening.
[QUOTE=Lightnin’]
I do have a question, however… if Bush had been exactly the way he is, but Democrat, how long would he have lasted in office?
[/QUOTE]
Depends on who controls Congress. Partly, anyway. OTOH, Nixon was dumped when, IIRC, the Dems controlled the House and Pubs the Senate; and Johnson’s impeachment was partly a faction fight within the Republican Party.