Perfectly good explanation for the Disney movies: the guy went to animation school and draws cartoons. This also explains the anatomy books, the anime, the American comics, the bandes dessinees, and the French-English dictionary.
Wait, Win. You didn’t specify gender. Is the “creep” factor restricted to the collector being male? Is a female with the same penchant less threatening?
Well I am a single man with no children and I just bought 4 classic Disney movies last week. Because I like watching them occasionally. I keep my movies in an alphabetized binder so I don’t have a shelf, does that make me less creepy?
As for creepier how about single young man with shelf of porn and a shelf of Disney who picks at random for the same purpose. :eek:
The person that inspired this thread is female.
You win.
I dated a girl briefly who had a canopy bed, tons of stuffed animals, maybe some Disney or princess-related stuff on the wall, I don’t remember. She was maybe 25 give or take.
I felt very weird having sex in that room.
:Looks around at house full of toys:
:Looks at SpongeBob watch:
:Looks at clown suit he made himself:
Ummm, well, ya see . . .
But I like cartoons…
Is it less creepy if they aren’t all Disney? And there are other types of movies in residence on the shelf?
It’s only not creepy if you have a shelf full of Resident Evil II or Texas Chainsaw Massacre films as well.
I love Google ads…
“End Deviant Behavior Now”
“Are You a Slacker Mom?”
“Child Custody Help”
“How to Talk to Kids”
Apparently the GoogleGods think you must be a deviant female who’s lost custody of your kids with a shelf full of Disney cartoons…<sigh>
Hmm. Married female, 51 years old here.
I own the entire set of Asterix comic books. I just adore them. I was an adult when I discovered the character and started reading them.
Hey! That’s my 60-year-old aunt! She’s got all sorts of Disney stuff, and her vanity license plate has a shortened form of Disneyland on it.
But her thing is that she lived with her slightly younger sister for years, until younger sister got married and moved out at age 35. And their big fun thing to do every summer was going to Disneyland together. She’s continued to go to Disneyland almost every year.
Oooh, Astérix! I discovered them when I was a kid and we had dinner at Ed Broadbent’s place in Ottawa (my mom worked with him) and his wife had a number of them and left them with me while the Adults Talked. They’ve been translated into many languages. What’s interesting is reading the same book in several different languages.
I maintain that comics (bandes dessinées in French) are an excellent way to learn a language.
[sub]And Astérix kicks Tintin’s butt.[/sub]
Don’t ever feel the need to apologise for Asterix. That’s culture. Especially compared to what Disney puts out. 
I’m 36, have 1 kid, recently split from my husband (I have custody), and have lots of anime, along with several manga titles including “Revolutionary Girl Utena” and “Cardcaptor Sakura.” No hentai, though, I’m afraid the children currently living here will find it. Am I still creepy?
You’d like a current television commercial in the U.K., Eonwe. Couple arrive back at the woman’s flat, and head all very gaspingly hurrying desperately to the bedroom, only for the man to flee in horror at seeing the room of this grown-up, dressed-to-undress sexy girl appear just as you have described, all fluffy, girly. “O NOES”, thinks our (now frustrated and miserable) heroine as she realised she really *must * change the style of her room to be a bit less twelve year-old. In another version, the same happens in reverse, with the suave young man’s room turning out to be all “young boy football fan with rock star posters”. As an advert for “time to buy a new bed and associated stuff”, I bet it does work.
And Asterix, people? Heaven, I that’s not in the same league as Disney at all, and it seems I was not the only one to love how easy it was to buy them in a variety of languages.
To address the O.P. I’d think it a tiny bit odd, but it would make a lot of difference what OTHER films and books the person had. If Disney was all there was, that would seem strange.
Now you’ve got me thinking about Jessica Alba’s character’s bedroom in Good Luck Chuck. Penguins, penguins, penguins.
Adult male, single (again sigh) no kids, self full of Disney films.
But let’s see
101 Dalmatians (original animated) is between 12 Monkeys and The 400 Blows.
Bambi is between Brazil and Big Trouble in Little China
Bugs Life is between Blade Runner and Carrie
Dumbo is between Don’t Look Now and Empire of the Sun
Finding Nemo is between Field of Dreams and The Fisher King
The Great Mouse Detective is between The Great Escape and The Green Mile
Hudsucker Proxy, Incredibles, Jaws, Jungle Book, To Kill a Mocking Bird
Lady and the Tramp is between Labyrinth and The Lady Vanishes
Lifeboat, The Lion King, The Little Mermaid, Little Shop of Horrors
The Night Before Christmas is between Night of the Hunter and North by Northwest
The Perfect Storm is followed by Peter Pan, Pinocchio, Pirates of the Caribbean (1 and 2) and Planes Trains and Automobiles.
Snow White sits between The Sound of Music and South Park: Bigger Longer and Uncut.
So am I creepy or what?
Creepy is also have more dogs/cats wandering around your house than you have teeth in your head.
Zebra - you’re only creepy because you can alphabetize everything but B. People who have trouble with 'b’s are inherently creepy. 
Honestly, I don’t think being single and having Disney movies is creepy. I think the creepy barrrier is set a tad low there. I’m a female, and I don’t have Disney movies, but as long as the person in question had other movies too, I wouldn’t think a thing of it.
Anyway, creepy is not limited to a set of facts. Creepy is much more a VIBE. Generally speaking (and of course excluding extreme objectively-creepy type facts), you can tell a lot more about creepiness by meeting a person than you can by a set of facts.