This isn’t entirely true and some explanation is warranted.
At the heart of this matter is the ‘Deepwater’ fleet modernization program. I suspect that you are referring to the patrol boats that were recently pulled from service. Here’s the story.
The Island Class patrol boats (110s, as they are 110 feet long) were built in the mid 1980s. These boats, based on a proven British design of coastal patrol craft, were originally designed for about 15 years of service. They were a ‘temporary fix’ during the height of the drug war until a better boat could be developed. 49 Island Class boats were built.
These boats were rode hard and put up wet, to put it mildly. Poor maintenance due to a constant pace of heavy operations took a huge toll on these boats. Fast forward to the 21st century and the CG is in the midst of the Deepwater program. One component of Deepwater was to take the 110s out of service, one by one, lengthen the hull by 13 feet, upgrade the accommodations, electronics, etc, and then place them back in service - good as new! Eight boats were converted in this fashion and are now 123’ long. However, the boats were in no condition to undergo such major renovations and problems were encountered from day one. For starters, the hulls were all degraded well beyond initial estimates. Another problem was the lengthening of hull and added weight of the upgrade affected the structural integrity of the boat in ways that were not accurately predicted. As soon as the new 123s hit the water, cracks developed, shafts became mis-aligned and each boat had new and unique problems which made them unsafe to operate in moderate to heavy seas. The threat of a major catastrophe became very real. So earlier this year, the Commandant had to pull the eight boats from service. Last week the final decision was made - the eight 123s could not be repaired and would be retired from service.
So, of 49 Island Class patrol boats, eight were converted and subsequently scrapped. The remaining 41 are still in service, well beyond their initial life span. They will not be upgraded as originally planned. Their crews are holding them together as best they can. (and doing a hell of a job with what they have!) Six of those boats are in Iraq and we’ll likely never see those boats again.
The other major Deepwater problem is the brand new National Security Cutter, Bertholf. The Bertholf had design flaws that AHEM escaped the notice of CongressCOUGHCOUGH for various reasons and, as it is right now, will not be able to meet the projected 30 year life span without significant upgrade at some point during the life of the cutter. Subsequent hulls of this class will have those problems addressed during construction, however I believe the Bertholf is still seaworthy and will be commissioned on time.
The Deepwater Program is the largest acquisition/modernization program in Coast Guard history. It is also, quite possibly, the largest black eye. That point notwithstanding, I think the Coast Guard does one hell of a job serving the public and should be considered a program that the government ‘does reasonably well’ on a consistent basis.