"Israel's existence is illegal, therefore it should vanish?" (focusing on one argument only)

[DPRK]

There are areas like the West Bank that are not currently part of Israel and people living there have no Israeli citizenship. You can be a Palestinian or Arab or Muslim and also Israeli, but that is difficult if you live in Jericho or Ramallah, let alone Gaza.

My impression is that the number of Palestinians who are trying to gain citizenship in Israel as it now exists is pretty small- does the option exist for them, and if so, for real and not as some sort of bureaucratic hell? A lot resort to working in and travelling to Israel illegally, or via some restrictive work permit that does not confer political and social rights. Also, I imagine that many Palestinians are not too fond of the government of Israel as it now exists and that they may not jump at the idea.

[Chronos]

Heck, I’m not too fond of the government of my nation as it now exists, either. So I vote to change it.

[Kimstu]

@DPRK

My impression is that the number of Palestinians who are trying to gain citizenship in Israel as it now exists is pretty small- does the option exist for them, and if so, for real and not as some sort of bureaucratic hell?

Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem legally can apply to become citizens of Israel, but it appears from, e.g., this Ha’aretz article that “bureaucratic hell” is a fair description:

Although in principle the law allows Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem to receive Israeli citizenship, the obstacles on the way have become more and more difficult over the years. Simply getting an appointment to present the necessary documents has taken three years. Then it’s another three to four years until there is a decision. […]

Lawyers are convinced that this is not something initiated by officials in East Jerusalem but rather a deliberate Interior Ministry policy to prevent the city’s Palestinians from becoming citizens. “It’s clear that the Interior Ministry doesn’t want these applications. They don’t want to pollute the Population Registry with more Palestinians,” said Adi Lustigman, a lawyer specializing in the issue. […]

More than 95 percent of East Jerusalem’s Palestinians have residency status rather than citizenship. While the number of applications for citizenship has grown, from 69 in 2003 to more than 1,000 in 2018, very few receive a positive response.

Palestinians in the occupied territories as opposed to East Jerusalem, AFAICT, are not eligible for either Israeli residency or citizenship.

[Sam_Stone]

@TonySinclair

Jesus, listen to yourself. 5% is not pretty good as a justification for taking the other 95% (or if you include the West Bank, the other 130%).

Is that 5% an accurate depiction of the situation? My understanding was that before the creation of Israel, there were large regions of unpopulated desert. So it seems to me that a better measure would be the percentage of populated, economically valuable land that the Palestinians sold to the Jewish people.

After all, if someone bought every town and city and farm in Canada, They probably wouldn’t own a significant percentage of the total area of Canada. But they would own a very high percentage of all the land that mattered.

[Jackmannii]

@Kimstu

Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem legally can apply to become citizens of Israel, but it appears from, e.g., this Ha’aretz article that “bureaucratic hell” is a fair description

Not that it justifies whatever Israeli policy may be, but “bureaucratic hell” is a pretty good description of qualifying for citizenship in numerous countries, including the EU (including such requirements as prolonged residency (which can be for up to 15 years), getting a societal “integration diploma”, meeting fairly stringent language and national history knowledge standards, giving “loyalty” declarations etc.).

5 of the Hardest Countries for Obtaining Citizenship

Hard to tell what the average waiting times are once you begin the application process in various countries.

[MortSahlFan]

@Ike_Witt

If the existence of Israel is illegal, who determines that and enforces it?

Who knows… It seems like “The West” will use the UN, etc., only when it helps, and ignore them when they disagree. What happened to the Oslo Accord?

[TonySinclair]

@Sam_Stone

This is what bothers me, and makes me suspicious when people claim that their arguments against Israel are not anti-semitic.

Congratulations, you agree with Trump.

Here’s another viewpoint, implying that people who say criticism of Israel is anti-Semitic are themselves anti-Semitic. How does it feel?

'A Bullhorn to His White Nationalist Base': Progressive Jews Hit Back After...

IfNotNow, a youth-led progressive Jewish advocacy group, quickly hit back, condemning the president for once again deploying the kind of hate-filled rhetoric that has fueled recent anti-Semitic attacks in the United States.

“This is an explicit dual loyalty charge wielded by the president of the United States against 80 percent of American Jews who voted against him,” the group said in a statement to Newsweek, alluding to 2018 midterm election data from the Pew Research Center.

“It is not merely an anti-Semitic dog whistle—it’s a bullhorn to his white nationalist base,” said IfNotNow. “American Jews and Democratic voters know full well the impact of the racist policies of Netanyahu and the Israeli government on the Palestinian people. This is why an overwhelming majority… oppose those policies, like unchecked settlement expansion.”

[Kimstu]

@Jackmannii

Not that it justifies whatever Israeli policy may be, but “bureaucratic hell” is a pretty good description of qualifying for citizenship in numerous countries, including the EU (including such requirements as prolonged residency (which can be for up to 15 years), getting a societal “integration diploma”, meeting fairly stringent language and national history knowledge standards, giving “loyalty” declarations etc.).

Very late in responding to this, and I don’t disagree with your statement of fact, but just pointing out that burdensome requirements for obtaining citizenship in a foreign country are qualitatively somewhat different from burdensome requirements for Palestinian natives of East Jerusalem to obtain citizenship in the national entity that controls East Jerusalem.

Comparing requirements for immigrants to become naturalized in a foreign country to requirements for natives and lifelong residents of a region to obtain citizenship rights in the nation that controls their native region is a bit apples-and-oranges.