It's true, people don't stop to help someone in trouble

I live on a street that’s just off of a very busy main thoroughfare in my city, one of a handful of “pikes” that radiate from downtown. This pike is all businesses, but the side streets are residential.

Driving home from work yesterday, I was in line at the stoplight at my intersection, about 6 cars back. I saw a older woman up ahead, on her knees on the sidewalk next to some bushes and a post-and-chain barricade. She was pulling at the chain and fiddling with something. For a minute I though she was working on the chain or perhaps doing some landscaping work. The light changed and I drove by, and I realized she was trying – with no success – to pull herself up.

The small business on that corner has a parking lot you can enter from both the main street and my side street, so I turned the corner and turned back into that parking lot, and tried to yell and ask if she needed help. It was so noisy from the passing traffic that she either couldn’t hear me or I couldn’t hear her, so I parked the car and got out and went over.

Sure enough, she was at least 70 and had fallen down walking home from the store – she had a little shopping bag. She’d hurt her knees and ankle and was just too weak to get back up. I wasn’t sure how long she’d been there but obviously I was the only person in that rush hour traffic who’d stopped. I tried to help her up from a few angles and approaches and I just wasn’t strong enough to overcome her awkward position, injuries, and general weakness. During this 10 minute period, when it should have been obvious what was going on, with several changes of traffic light resulted in vehicles parked right next to us, no one said a word.

When it was clear to me that I wasn’t going to be able to get her up on my own, I had her get into a sitting position on the sidewalk to get off her knees, which were really hurting. I went back to my car and got my cell phone and called the non-emergency number for help. I thought they’d send a policeman – which, in my city, at rush hour, in a non-emergency, can take an hour or more. Luckily they sent the fire dept, and they were there in about 5 minutes. She was embarrassed, but as we were waiting I tried to reassure her, that’s what they’re here for, my father was a fireman (true) and they’re happy to help.

The guys got her up and asked her health-related questions to make sure there weren’t other problems – dehydration, diabetes, heart or lung problems, etc., and checked out her leg and determined it was hard for her to stand, much less walk, on her own. So they got an ambulance there right away and bundled her off to the hospital. She was so grateful to me, thanked me endlessly, and all I could say was, “You’re welcome, would hope someone else would do the same for me.” From the time I placed the call to the time the ambulance pulled off was 10 minutes, maybe 15 at most.

I live in a city well that has a strong reputation as being “friendly” and “helpful.” I have NEVER been in a position where I had car trouble or some other similar issue where at least 3 or 4 people stopped and asked if I needed assistance. So, I was doubly appalled that this poor woman would probably be kneeling there still if it wasn’t for me. I suppose it might have been because she looked down-and-out – in fact, until she told me where she lived (a retirement tower just up the street) I thought she might have been homeless. Her unkepmt hair from under a ball cap, missmatched, somewhat raggedy clothes, and a plastic shopping bag that had seen better days could have put some people off. I wonder if she’d fallen down in a more well-to-do part of town, or if she had been better dressed and groomed, if the outcome would have been different? I dunno.

It almost certainly would have. People have a hard time empathizing with down-and-outers, because they can’t see themselves ever in that position. If it was a 40 year old middle class guy having a seizure, the first person to see him likely would have stopped to help. People have seen enough homeless bums that they’re desensitized to their plight. Everyone probably assumed she was just drunk.

Sadly, yes. When my brother used to drive around in beater cars, if they ever broke down (which was frequently), he would get out of his car and push it to a safe spot himself without intervention of any kind from passers by. Once when I was being cheapzilla and idiotic enough to think my car would run indefinitely on a 1/4 tank of gas, my car (you guessed it!) ran out of gas and left me stranded. I put on my hazards and kind of feebly tried to get it around the corner, when three different people stopped and pushed my car to the gas station for me. Similarly, a thousand years ago when I got a flat tire on the highway, as I was walking to the call box (remember when highways had callboxes instead of everyone having cell phones?) at least two people pulled over to ask me if I needed anything. One person even said he saw me walking but was unable to pull over immediately, so he exited the freeway then got back on to see if he could help. By the time the tow truck came, I can’t even tell you how many people offered to help. One guy even directed me to a shop where I could replace my tire for cheap. And this is all happening on the 405 freeway at night.

Am I attractive? Not really, but it would appear more people are eager to help a neatly presented but distressed 19 year old girl than they are a shabbily dressed elderly woman, or a male of any sort. Of course, these are just anecdotes that don’t prove anything, but since this is the sharing forum, I’m sharing.

What a sad story. Good on you for being the most decent human being in town that day. That lady will probably remember your kindness more than she will remember the people who didn’t stop.

Oh, and I need to add that this thread makes me feel :(.

I also wonder how good the woman’s health care is. Ambulance rides are expensive. I hope she’s okay.

I disagree. I saw a show on The Science channel (or a channel like it) that demonstrated this.

They had a guy pretend to of hurt himself (I can’t remember how he was supposed to be hurt) down on the ground of a busy sidewalk. I was amazed at how many people walked around the guy.

It’s been so long since I saw that show; the details are a little vague. I do remember that the guy was dressed in a business suit.

It’s a social phenomenon really.

Back the truck of dissappointment up a bit. The op said the woman was on her knees holding onto a fence. That is not AS obvious a sign of distress as lying on the ground with groceries strewn about. I’ve never seen overt refusal to help someone who was in obvious distress, just the opposite. I’ve repaired a number of cars on the side of the road over the years. It’s getting harder with the newer technology but I still stop. Everytime I’ve seen someone plow a car into a snowbank it has attracted a number of people who stop and help push the car back if possible.

Yah, but two lanes of traffic would be stopped right in front of her, waiting for a traffic light to change, every few minutes. It’s not like people were only driving by at 40mph. Also, the area is covered up with business, people pulling in and out of parking lots, etc. Also – I didn’t mention this in the OP – there was a young woman walking around that very parking lot I pulled into, talking on her cell phone, who completely ignored the lady on the sidewalk. As I was parking and getting out of my car, she got into hers and pulled away. She would have even heard me yelling at the woman on the sidewalk if she needed help. So …

I agree that it’s not like she was laid out cold, but it took me less than a minute to realize what was really going on.

Yes I worried about that too … and how she would get home from the hospital. sigh Luckily the hospital they took her to is only another mile or so down the road, so if she had to get a cab, at least it wouldn’t cost an arm and a leg.

Like Magiver, I’m a bit more optimistic – I’ve seen plenty of incidents of folks coming to the aid of distressed folks out and about. Falls, medical emergencies, random accidents, etc.

I only have to qualifiers:

  1. “Can you give me some money” tales - I am jaded enough to walk right past anyone soliciting for change. (I had a huge change of heart after spending a desperately poor period during which at no point it made sense to go out and ask strangers for change.)

  2. I did once observe several people stepping around (or pointedly ignoring while waiting for the bus) a fellow who was laid out in the middle of the damned sidewalk. I asked him if he needed help, and he said he couldn’t get up. I called an ambulance and got some water for him (it was high summer) while waiting for it to show up. I never did find out what was going on with him. I do know that he definitely wasn’t drunk. I think that the folks who ignored him may have assumed that he was. He was native, dontcha know? :frowning:

Well done, Claire! You do the Dopers proud!

Around here (a college town of 28,000) people would stop immediately. The whole state has a small-town atmosphere. On the backroads people with in-state plates always give a friendly wave.

Good on you!

Someone did stop to help. This time it was you, Claire. And God bless you for that.

We are all encouraged when we see our fellows helping out in a situation like this. Everyone else rushing home for reasons that aren’t important. But you stopped.

You sound upset that someone didn’t stop sooner. But you did stop and help, that made a difference today.

If no one has told you what a fine person you are lately, well I will. Smile and know that when you were needed, you acted.

Its people like you that make up for all the slack bastards out there. Well done for being intelligent enough to work out what was going on and compassionate enough to assist. We need more like you.

Amen to this!!!

You sound like a good egg, Claire—If you are ever in Salt Lake, I will be happy to buy you a cold one…

Matthew

I’m glad you could help her, Claire.

I am in the mostly optimistic camp. When I fell badly at the T station on the way to work a couple of years ago, and broke my ankle, not only did people stop, but one guy just plain appointed himself my guardian angel until such time as emergency services arrived. Wouldn’t leave until he was absolutely certain that I was bundled off in safe hands. I have no idea who he was, but no doubt I made him late on his commute, and I still think of him with profound gratitude. I was kind of shocky and in no shape to be left on my own. (And, ah, I was trying to dissuade anyone from calling 911 because ‘I never broke a bone in my life. It must just be a sprain. I’ll go home and ice it. I can take a taxi.’ Heh.)

I try to repay the favour and help people in distress. Fortunately it’s rarely anything that dramatic!

The lady on the cell phone was not in the parking lot, she was in her own little world. If she perceived your voice at all she would have talked louder to drown it out. And I hate to say this, but I don’t rubberneck much when I’m in my car. I look out for other traffic. If I’m at a light I play with the radio or take out a window wipe and clean the windows.

When I got my digital SLR a few years back I was all excited to go around STL and take photos of stuff. My friend and I were walking around downtown one day and I was snapping photos of cool buildings and whatnot. We were crossing a street and I tripped over a very high curb. Fell face down (with the camera around my neck! thank geez it did not break) and I fell HARD on my right elbow and left knee, was bleeding, crying from shock of falling that hard and pain.

At least 2 people stepped over me. Didn’t stop, didn’t say “are you ok?” Just literally stepped over me. And it was the middle of a weekday, there were not tons of pedestrians clogging up the sidewalk. My friend helped me up after he stopped laughing (he only laughed after he knew I was OK, and that’s how my group of friends is) and I had to hobble to a nearby hotel lobby to clean the blood off.

My knee and elbow hurt for at least two months, I fell so hard - being very tall and all. In short, people suck sometimes.

Most of you are probably too young to remember the horrible murder of Kitty Genovese in 1964. It was a huge story for several years, and prompted a great deal of psychological research into people’s apathy and unwillingness to get involved.

We came across a guy lying spark out in the street in our small town last winter. It was outside a pub so first instinct was that he’d got hammered and was having a short nap on the pavement (sidewalk). It was pretty cold and drizzling, so you’d not be there by choice!

Several people had already passed by without saying or doing anything, including my wife (who’s a medical student!!) - I guess they assumed it was someone in drink who just needed to sleep it off a bit, but it was only 7pm and the pubs tend not to be all-day boozing dens so you’d have to be going some to be battered by then.

I figured it was worth a check - he was on his front and was mumbling a bit, so obviously had good airway and pulse, and there was no sign of blood so didn’t look like trauma / mugging.

We called an ambulance (999, which is our 911 equivalent) and covered him with a couple of coats, and just before the ambulance arrived his friend came steaming down the road in a panic… she’d been on her mobile to him and it’d suddenly cut out, and it turned out he was diabetic and hadn’t been managing his insulin properly.

He was too far gone to get any chocolate / coke into him, so had to wait for the paramedics to treat him.

If he’d been wearing a suit and tie I think more people would have stopped to help, but because he was in “going to the pub” gear the natural assumption was that’d he’d had one too many.