This thread inspired me to rewatch Conan for the first time since probably the early 90s. I think I liked it, but it is very odd. As said, most of it is sort of anti-acting, or null-acting. I wouldn’t say the leads are wooden, or bad actors, it’s more that they are just doing these things, and we’re along for the ride. About the only real acting is Max von Sydow as the King, and that almost seems out of place.
There are two things that kind of go together, that both make the movie better and worse for me. It has that old times movie pacing. Cinematography just seems to go on and on. Yes, there are some rocks, and there are horses riding through the rocks, oh, now the horses are riding through some snow. I get that was the style, and it sets atmosphere, or whatever, but often times I just want the movie to get on with it. Not just Conan, but other movies in that style, too.
Wrapped up with that, is I think the positive thing of just showing stuff. It doesn’t have to be talked out (see the null-acting), hammered home with overwhelming music, or (thankfully) explained in flash backs of something I just saw an hour ago.
If I don’t remember that the beheading sword at the end is the one his father made, then that’s my problem. Conan gives some good visuals on it, so I can see it clearly, but I feel like a modern movie would have had a whole flashback scene of Conan’s father making the sword, probably showing again some sappy scene where Conan shows how much he loved his father. Here, they don’t need to show that. We know Conan loved his father, because in general that is what kids do, and then he spends the whole moving avenging his death.
Same with the red haired man. If we don’t notice that’s probably the same person as the kid who closes Conan’s manacles, then we just lose out.
That was an interesting take, but I always thought that Conan was left alone on the wheel, because he had grown so strong he could push it himself. There were no other slaves, because none were needed. [The thread @rejemy linked claims the works associated with the wheel had fallen on hard times, so Conan was the only one left working there.]
Overall, not really amazing, but certainly of it’s time, and I think a classic, in the sense that something can be a classic without being stellar. I’m sure if I’d been told over and over that it was amazing, and I needed to see it, I would have been very disappointed. Watching it with some nostalgia mixed in certainly helps smooth over the rough spots.