Not hardly. And, I don’t go around making any effort to see when a poster was or was not last online. Uh… that is over the top, IMHO. Nice, to have a life. I’ve got one too. No doubt he does as well. At some point, he may or may not see this Pitting. It doesn’t matter much if he does, since he won’t go back in there and apologize for shitting on that guy’s post with an attitude not exactly in keeping with Straight Dope Scientific Advisory Board tone.
We’re here to fight ignorance, not to shit on people. If he wanted to shit on the OP’er, he would have been within his rights to come in here to the Pit and pit the guy. Fine. But in that thread? In G.Q. ? Sorry. Doesn’t fly, and this is not the first time he’s come sailing in obnoxiously. I’m not the only one waiting for an apology for the vitriol spewed out during the best/worst of the Duke rape/Nifong threads.
No, I pitted him because of a well-recognized pattern of absolute statements and absolute refusals to admit he was incorrect.
Fine. He knows the law. Mazel Tov. However, he has never proved to us that his area of expertise ( and the area he is relied upon to provide assistance in SDSAB ) is even remotely connected to Astronomy. So. Read the OP again, then read his post again with care.
I wasn’t pitting him because he gave a wrong answer, I was pitting him because of his incredibly snarky shitting of the poster he quoted in his post. Everyone makes mistakes, and either admits it or gets called on it and then admits it.
Everyone but our dear Bricker.
Loach, that’s an interesting post you threw in there. Last time I checked, The Pit is the place to flame other posters as well as issues and ideas. As for hawthorne and Miller, you guys are precious.
The best you can come up with by way defending Bricker’s behaviors is to whine about past posts of mine? --grin-- Well, nicely done fellahs. You sure put me in my place.
None of which changes the simple fact that his behavior really was shitty in there.