So what’s your ideal plan, do you think? That the Dem nominee should go around and proclaim “every Republican politician in Congress is a malign, corrupt shitbag; they’re hopeless, just give them up, I am never going to work with them because they’re fucked. And the voters too, those assholes who voted for Trump in '16 even though they went Obama in '12. We don’t want their rednecked, sister-fucking, mouth-drooling kind in our party. Fuck 'em, we can’t trust them. No, my friends–and by friends, I mean everyone who has always only voted Democratic–trust me, we’re going to be at war with the Republican Congresspeople in 2020 when I get into power. In fact, thanks to my magic crystal ball, I can tell you right now–a year-and-a-half before the election–that the Senate is gonna buck the odds and turn almost completely blue. So fuck Mitch McConnell right in his turtle-esque maw, because we don’t need him or indeed any Republican votes. Y’know what, I’m not even gonna accept any of their votes. With the 65 Democrats in the Senate we’re sure to get because of my MagicFairyDust, no one can stop us from doing ANYTHING! So who needs to listen to a single thing anyone who isn’t One Of Us has to say? It’s a year-and-a-half away from election! We can absolutely ignore 50% of the country! SCORCHED EARTH STARTING NOW.”
Yeah. Super. This will totally NOT prove every alt.right deep-state-believing freak correct, and they totally won’t use this as a specific talking point to rally every single Republican, right-leaning Independent, and not a few conservative Obama/Trump Democrats into shoving and mauling their way into the voting booths next year to pull the lever for Trump.
Give a thought beyond the (admittedly justified) contempt that these quisling Republicans have earned under Obama and Trump. Think beyond revenge and punishment and everything we’d love to revel in.
Biden is not a stupid or naïve man, however you want to think him. Consider that maaaaybe the idea is to give the not-invisible number of Republicans or anti-Hillary Dems who voted Trump and are capable of shame a teensy lane into which they can cross back and justify their changeover to their other red state pals? A hint of grace so they don’t worry that they’ll be the enemy of Mr. or Ms. Blue President 2020?
We can do SCORCHED EARTH when we actually have a chance in hell of regaining the Senate with a considerable majority, which–unless I’m greatly mistaken (and I would love to be)–is nigh impossible given the Republican seats that are up for grabs. It’s only nine or so Republicans, isn’t it? And most are in blood-red states?
Psychologically speaking, these people have egos. Even for sane people (unlike Trump), it is often very very difficult to admit we’re wrong. And these voters and politicians were so, so drastically wrong, in thinking Trump wouldn’t be a catastrophe and a disgrace. Instead, they double-down instead of acknowledging they should’ve fought harder against Trump, against McConnell, against the psychos in the alt.right and Trump’s racist base. The Anyone-But-Clinton people still refuse to admit they should’ve held their nose and compromised. That’s the tragic flaw of human nature.
Biden and, I hope, other smart candidates, will preach left-of-center and progressive ideas while also carving out a “I’m reasonable” path to allow every possible vote we can get from the non-true-blue side exit the side of psychosis and authoritarianism and walk cautiously through the gateway back to a semblance of being willing to listen and, maybe even cooperate.
Without that gateway WE. ARE. FUCKED.