comments:
“John, that is beautiful. You’re really putting me in the Christmas spirit.”
“Are you angel? I felt like a rainbow just flowed through my ears! That was beautiful!”
“Behind Blue Eyes” (A while ago I was thinking about auditioning with that song on Australian Idol)
comments:
“Wow John, you have a very interesting voice. Never stop singing.”
“Silent Night”
comments:
“Sounds like a carol singer who has come to harvest my skin.”
“Cheers John. That was lovely.”
I guess the only way you would “know” would be if you saw the comments for yourself. Though it might still be possible that “real” people didn’t make them.
I’m not going to cushion that with a “sorry” or anything. I believe those who encourage bad singing by not telling the truth are a dearth to us all. Or truly tone deaf themselves. They were being nice to you and I guess that’s nice and all, but no. If you really enjoy singing, then all I can say is you need lessons.
And yes, I tell people that IRL, too. Singing on the bus, train, sidewalk? I’ll tell you to keep your day job if it’s not good.
Guys, guys, if you didn’t click any links, there’s no shilling here. Believe that fo’ sho’.
John, you’ve been really prolific on the board in the last few days. And whilst in itself that is not a bad thing, your singing REALLY is a bad thing dude. It’s awful, and the comments you received were intentionally ironic mate.
Please, go back on your meds, or get them changed to ones that work. Because you are doing yourself a great disservice posting here at the moment, and in fact your membership (if I read correctly) is up for review as well.
Take care, Happy New Year, and DON’T SING anymore, OK?
The ‘shilling’ is the made up comments that he ‘copied’ from some un-named source made by some un-named people - thats exactly what a ‘shill’ is or does -
now that you and kambuckta have viewed the songs and declared him to “not be good” here - that will drive more curiosity to his ‘singing’ - and more honest/ironic/negative feedback to him - which is exactly what he wants -
So, the shill worked - on multiple levels.
eta - has nothing to do with ‘making money’ - has to do with drawing interest to a thing - in this case, an apparent train wreck.
I kind of like William Hung: (though perhaps he thinks he is ok?)
He became somewhat successful and song quite a few albums… I’m wondering if I could do that one day… that’s why I chose the “Behind Blue Eyes” song to possibly audition with…
Also the topic is “tries to” rather than claiming I actually can sing.
