Still working my way thru Battle: The Story of the Bulge and it is not disappointing. I mentioned the first chapters establishing the “it’s quiet out there - too quiet” atmosphere. That atmosphere has given way to a horrifying mix of War with a Capital W. Mass confusion, nobody knows what is going on, there seems a realistic chance of disaster for the Allies, interspersed with moments of heroism and real tragedy - the general forced to abandon to destruction the division that holds his only son.
Toland excels in presenting both surrender, and “fight to the death”, in relatable terms. The moral courage of a commander ordering another to stand his ground and fight, no matter what, and the physical courage of the commander receiving the order, who accepts that it will probably mean the deaths of his whole company - and probably himself as well. And the agony of the commander who has to surrender, because no object will be gained by sacrificing his men, and the derision he expects, and receives, from himself, his other officers, and even from some of his men.
As well as the juxtaposition of attitude among the soldiers. Some of them saying, “I am out of ammunition, I haven’t slept in three days, I haven’t eaten in two days, Panzers are killing us like flies - fuck this, I am going to the rear” and some others who are just as hungry, just as tired, just as scared - but saying “I joined this army to kill Germans and that’s what I am going to do” and joining back up with companies heading back into the thick of things. And you can see yourself doing both.
And George Patton - as documented elsewhere, a jackass and a blowhard. But at least he’s not a defeatist. Maybe even he is grossly over-confident, but Eisenhower seems to need someone who will take what he’s got, put together a plan, and commit to victory. Is that going to get a lot of guys killed? Oh my yes. But a lot of them are going to be German.
Very good stuff.
On a totally un-related note, I found an audiobook of The Further Adventures of Doctor Syn and I am going to give it a shot. Maybe that will be more like the Disney Scarecrow of Romney Marsh I remember from my childhood - if not, let’s see what the psychopath does next.
Regards,
Shodan