Lack of moderation of quotes in McCain GBT thread

[Lance_Turbo]

This guy…

@Bricker

I agree, reluctantly, that december deserves criticism for the way he did this.

Should duke it out with this guy…

@Bricker

And since he did, in fact, simply say “President” instead of “Bush,” I found his tactic perfectly acceptable.

[sleestak]

@Colibri

Right. If we moderated every joke at a politician’s expense we would be very busy indeed. Nor can I imagine that we would insist that every quote of anyone anywhere must be attributed.

As has been said, there is no rule against modifying quotes of non-posters. If someone fabricated a quote and pretended it was real, there might be an issue, but in this case the first quote was clearly a parody, and the second was both accurate and attributed within the quote.

Yet you are extremely intent on defending him.

Or, possibly, raising the bar at the 'Dope.

Na, couldn’t be that.

Slee

[Ravenman]

Be careful what you wish for. If the moderators enforced a higher standard of posting behavior, I believe the first to fall prey to such “raising the bar” would be a small number of pro-Trump posters whose typical contributions are barely this side of trolling.

[Gyrate]

@Ravenman

Be careful what you wish for. If the moderators enforced a higher standard of posting behavior, I believe the first to fall prey to such “raising the bar” would be a small number of pro-Trump posters whose typical contributions are barely this side of trolling.

…which would then be used as evidence of how biased moderators are against right-wing posters.

[Bricker]

@Lance_Turbo

This guy…

Should duke it out with this guy…

In 2003, there was no explicit ruling from the mods similar to the one that began this thread.

[Lance_Turbo]

What ruling by the mods began this thread?

Also, when you said, “I found his tactic perfectly acceptable,” I didn’t realize that was based on recent mod rulings. Would the phrase, “I now find his tactic perfectly acceptable,” be more accurate.

Back in 2003 it seemed like you found attributing Hillary Clinton’s words to, “The President,” to be deserving of criticism, but now you seem to be saying that based on recent mod rulings you found that to be perfectly acceptable… back in 2003.

Care to clear this up.