Okay, I know I’m late to the party. I tried this show when it first aired and just wasn’t feeling it. A few weeks ago, I decided to give it another go.
I finished the latest episode today. Man what a great show! Love the writing and the “science” in the show feels as close to realistic as I’ve ever seen. It makes me wonder how many aeronautics engineers they have consulting with them on this show.
We just started watching it, on EP 4 of Season 2.
I really like it, and appreciate how the author must have read a lot of Niven as a kid.
I think the production values are pretty high, and the acting is B or better, but there are some serious science flaws, even as they try to be accurate.
I also think that there are some plot points that never got addressed (maybe they were in the books) - e.g. - Why was the Scopuli set up as a trap, and why did the stealth ships destroy the Canterbury?
I loved the first few books. Cibola Burn though is a plodding labor so far (up to chapter 40). I guess it doesn’t help that I’m audio-booking it and the guy has some kind of reading disorder and doesn’t know names.
Photogen was trying to spark a war between Earth and Mars by making it look like the Martians ambushed the UN registered Canterbury. (The OPA Scopuli was Mars-built and used a Martian distress signal). This was intended to distract Mars and Earth from what Protogen were up to on Eros.
Apparently somewhere along the way, engines started making sound in space. They do in Season 4, but I thought for sure they didn’t earlier in the series. This bugs me since they used to get it right!
The other thing that irritated me was how at one point (in 3rd season, I think) they started panning over the spaceship in such a way as to make it look like it’s decelerating with the thrusters pointed and firing in the opposite direction.