Learning to Play the Piano

My husband and I are considering getting an electric piano for our six year old boy. He doesn’t know how to play, but every time he sits down in front of one he seems to have a unique facility with it.

As someone once commented from rooms away at a family gathering, “Whoever is playing the piano sounds like they both know and don’t know how to play the piano.” I think my son might get really into the math of music, too.

Neither I nor my husband play the piano, but as we’re considering this purchase, we’re both interested in learning. I know how to read music as I spent a decade playing trombone, and I have a little music theory education. We figure it might at least stick for one out of the three of us.

I don’t think face to face lessons are an option right now, especially not for the boy, because of his severe ADHD and behavioral issues. His learning will have to be driven by himself, self-taught, or maybe an online course. My hope is that I can learn enough to start teaching him what I know. Then once he has better self-control we can transition to something in person.

Anyhow. This is the piano we’re looking at. Anything else is outside of our budget at this time. My husband has been visiting local music stores but so far we haven’t found anything better.

If anyone knows of great beginning online courses or has any tips or things to look out for, I’d appreciate it.

Invalid link, even when I go through their robot or human test.

Not sure what’s up with that. Here’s the description:

88 Weighted Keys with a Complete Beginner Bundle

The Donner DEP-20 Lite is a full-size 88-key digital piano with hammer-action weighted keys and adjustable touch response, giving beginners an authentic piano feel from the first practice session. The set arrives with an X-style stand, sustain pedal, music sheet and keyboard stickers, so new players can start without buying extras.

Learn Faster with LCD and Wireless Practice

A 1.3-inch LCD shows chords and notation as you play, while Bluetooth supports wireless connection to compatible iOS, Android and USB-MIDI devices for lessons and apps. Explore 185 built-in tones and 116-note polyphony for richer practice.

Room-Filling Sound and Quiet Practice

Dual 25W speakers deliver clear stereo sound for home playing. For silent practice, connect headphones through the headphone jack and keep the built-in speakers off.

Connect Your Gear

Ports include headphone, line in, line out, microphone, USB-MIDI and pedal connections for recording, accompaniment and external devices.

88 WEIGHTED KEYS: Full-size hammer-action keys with adjustable touch response.

185 TONES & 116 POLY: Rich sounds plus 116-note polyphony for layered playing.

1.3 LCD & BLUETOOTH: Shows chords and notation; wireless iOS, Android, USB-MIDI.

DUAL 25W SPEAKERS: Built-in stereo sound for room-filling home practice.

COMPLETE SET: X-style stand, sustain pedal, music sheet and keyboard stickers.

VERSATILE CONNECTIONS: Headphone, line in/out, mic, USB-MIDI and pedal jacks.

QUIET PRACTICE: Plug in headphones for silent night practice without speakers.

The piano is $300.

Oh man. I’m kind of excited because your kiddo sounds like he could be truly amazing at it!
I’ve had piano and clarinet lessons, but I think a dog would probably pick it up faster than I would.

Let’s try this link:

https://us.donnermusic.com/products/donner-dep-20-beginner-digital-piano-88-key-full-size-weighted-keyboard-portable-electric-piano-with-sustain-pedal-power-supply#1

Look for the Edna Mae Burnam, Step By Step learn piano books.

The Dozen a Day books are daily exercises. They helped me a lot.

Published in the 1950’s thru 70’s it’s what our grandparents and parents used to learn piano.

My teacher recommended them during my first year of studying piano. She introduced more theory based books my 2nd year studying.

The Step by Step books are written for children. They’re great for adult self learners that need very easy to read and learn lessons. Start with book 1. The books provide a structured path to learning piano.

I bought a vintage lot of the Step By Step Course. I think it was 6 heavily used books for under $40. I also bought a used lot of the Dozen a Day books cheaply.

Or you can buy new reprints.

In high school music theory class I tried (without any special instruction) and found it quite difficult, but I’m optimistic I will improve over time. I enjoy learning hard things.

I see it has the most important feature .. a headphone socket !

Honestly… I think a six year old without a teacher is not necessarily going to get far. But, having an instrument to play on that is readily available, and having mom and dad also using it at times is enough for developing a sense of curiosity and play, and maybe some skill if he really gets focused on it as something that he likes. If you two can give some general help with some elements, that can go a long way. There certainly are people who are ‘self-taught’ from a young age, but I’d expect that if he starts enjoying it you’d want to figure out some way to connect him with a teacher/mentor.

I think the biggest thing to keep in mind is that while one can play an instrument without reading music, any true beginner is learning three things at once:

  1. Music ‘theory’ (or even more simply, musical vocabulary)
  2. How to play their particular instrument
  3. How to read music

… not all of which carry the same level of challenge for any particular student. I find that most student frustration happens when one of these skills lags behind the others.

I’d suggest for you and husband: Alfred’s All-in-One Basic Adult Piano book.

For Son, a set of Alfred’s Basic Piano Library level 1A.

I’m partial to Alfred and it’s the one I teach out of, but Faber is another popular and equally good method/library. There are a few others out there as well.

With respect to our history, I’d avoid old method books like @aceplace57 recommended. They tend to be more rigorous and less holistic than more modern methods, and so I think would not be great as primary resources for the self-taught.

I started to learn to play piano at about that age; lucky for me, my father played (which of course is what got me started playing too.) After some months, my folks signed me up for lessons, which went on until I was in college. I still play, decades later.

I found that even toy instruments were useful in getting started. I didn’t start learning to read music until after the lessons started.

My teacher used the Alfred method my 2nd and 3rd year.

Edna Mae was only for learning to read notes, basic rhythm and scales.

I already had good hand Independence from six years of playing violin in school orchestra. I’ve been told hand Independence can be difficult for adult learners that didn’t play instruments in school.

I still needed a lot of practice to play separate parts with each hand.

Definitely.

Due to autism, ADHD and other executive function challenges, my son can be difficult to manage. He is normally very bright and enthusiastic, but he can turn on a dime. He is highly perfectionistic and throws a fit when something isn’t exactly how he thinks it should be. Medication helps, but I’m reluctant to foist these challenges onto a hapless piano teacher who may not be equipped to work with children with disabilities, particularly those who are sometimes aggressive.

Another challenge is that he doesn’t typically enjoy doing things that don’t come easily. But if he finds something he really loves, he will stick with it. His most recent obsession is chess, and within a few months he went from losing every game to beating me pretty regularly. He did that by setting up and playing out scenarios on his own, reading books and thinking about chess pretty much non-stop. So he does have the capacity for self-motivation if it’s the right fit. (We’re just now helping him dip his toes into the local chess scene, starting with a library chess club, but we’re nervous about how it’s going to go.)

If this isn’t a good fit for him, if he doesn’t find internal motivation, we’re prepared for that, but we wanted to give him a chance. And in the meantime I think it will be a fun family activity we can share. And if he does really take to it maybe we can find a teacher who will let us sit there throughout the lesson and help out if he becomes distressed.

At some point, possibly literally. When I was taking lessons, usually each year I learned one or two duets to play with my teacher or with another student. Duets can be a ton of fun!

I’m self-taught from a teen and having a keyboard around back then made it possible. I’d stick with a smaller 61 key if you can help it, bigger is furniture, but make sure they’re full sized keys.

I’d check craigslist and other local listings, loads of used keyboards for cheap on the condition you move. I’d search titles for keyboard or piano and then try some of the manufacturers in titles: Yamaha, Casio, Williams (Guitar Center’s house brand).

Chicago’s listings:

I’m going to put in a recommendation for exposing him to playing by ear, rather than anchoring it all in reading sheet music.

People who learn strictly from reading sheet music can play what’s in front of them and nothing else. People who can play by ear can sit down and, if they can hum the song, they can play it on the piano, probably in more than one key, and can jam with other musicians and perhaps improvise on-they-fly.

I earned a BFA from Berklee College of Music in 1998. Film Scoring. My diploma was handed to me with a handshake from Carly Simon.

My principle instrument was guitar, but I started piano lessons at six.

So, all that aside… WRISTS UP! Fingers, not arms.

Learn “Evil Woman” first.

And yes. EAR FIRST. With Evil Woman, first riff (after intro) is Am, Gmaj, Dm7. Why? Your right hand plays FAC but your left switches to D (pinky and thumb), giving you the signature Jeff Lynne use of Dminor!!!